Remove porn from the Funny, Strange, Random pics thread?

Remove porn from the Funny, Strange, Random pics thread?

  • yes

    Votes: 67 30.9%
  • no

    Votes: 123 56.7%
  • keep it but hidden by spoilers

    Votes: 27 12.4%

  • Total voters
    217

pharmakos

bµɐʁwɐʞoƨ
<Donors Crew>
9,689
19d 22h 28m
Reactions
5,389 2,033 0 0
#1
lots of discussion on it already starting here: https://www.firesofheaven.org/threads/bannings.9129/page-4

there's already threads for porn, and no one wants to see hentai. some people think that the FSR will get less traffic, others think that it being NSFW will help it get more traffic.

what do you guys think? debate away.
 

Ruhl

Boner Donor
<Donors Crew>
78
7d 13h 54m
Reactions
102 9 0 0
#2
I just don't get the bid deal to move it. I just can't see any of the mods taking the time to move & categorize the posts into the proper threads. No offense to them in saying that, I just feel like the precedent has already been in place long enough that it's a moot point in tilting at this particular windmill.
 

pharmakos

bµɐʁwɐʞoƨ
<Donors Crew>
9,689
19d 22h 28m
Reactions
5,389 2,033 0 0
#3
I just can't see any of the mods taking the time to move & categorize the posts into the proper threads.
mods wouldn't have to move it if the rule was made and posters followed it.

there's only a handful of people that even post porn in the FSR. they just post a LOT of it.
 

Archmage Lightning Lord Rule

Lightning Fast
<Charitable Administrator>
2,424
53d 15h 40m
Reactions
9,667 502 0 0
#4
One thing to keep in mind, is that the FSR drives a LOT of traffic to this site, and not just the porn.
It's going to need a delicate balance and careful touch

Also, what you're calling "hentai", do you mean the animated/cgi/drawing porn that people post, and not specifically tentacle porn? Because the animated stuff just merits a brony rating, and nothing more. As I do quite frequently.
 

pharmakos

bµɐʁwɐʞoƨ
<Donors Crew>
9,689
19d 22h 28m
Reactions
5,389 2,033 0 0
#5
Also, what you're calling "hentai", do you mean the animated/cgi/drawing porn that people post, and not specifically tentacle porn?
"hentai" is a catch-all term for animated porn. there has never been a requirement of tentacles for it to be called "hentai."
 

j00t

Trakanon Raider
2,998
14d 22h 7m
Reactions
1,514 250 0 0
#6
listen... the name of the thread is funny, strange, random thread. if what you are posting is neither of those 3, it shouldn't be there. that's an awfully vague answer but that's where i'm at. a picture of some camgirl with her shirt of isn't inherently funny, strange or random. there was a time when it qualified as random, but not really anymore. so my vote is for feel free to post porn as long as it qualifies for the thread itself. otherwise, put it in one of the handful of other porn threads.
 

Archmage Lightning Lord Rule

Lightning Fast
<Charitable Administrator>
2,424
53d 15h 40m
Reactions
9,667 502 0 0
#7
Huh, I stand corrected, I always thought hentai was specific to tentacles and not a catch-all term.

Eh, whatever, doesn't bother me unless it's in violation of the CP type rules.
 

pharmakos

bµɐʁwɐʞoƨ
<Donors Crew>
9,689
19d 22h 28m
Reactions
5,389 2,033 0 0
#11
listen... the name of the thread is funny, strange, random thread. if what you are posting is neither of those 3, it shouldn't be there.
this. i like porn as much as or more than the next guy, but there's a place for everything.
 

Denamian

Night Janitor
<Prior Amod>
2,061
31d 3h 54m
Reactions
2,074 150 0 0
#12
My opinion is that if there is already a specific thread for the content you intend to post (gifs, buttholes, beef curtains, etc), put it in that thread. Otherwise, dump it in the FSR.

Strict enforcement is unnecessary, instead posters should be shamed for being too retarded to put shit where it belongs.
 

Ryanz

<Banned>
18,902
0m
Reactions
50,809 29,277 0 0
#13
Not sure why you'd remove anything from the FSR. Trying to regulate it is just going to kill it off. But hey, go ahead and kill a good thing if you want. :shrug:
 

Archmage Lightning Lord Rule

Lightning Fast
<Charitable Administrator>
2,424
53d 15h 40m
Reactions
9,667 502 0 0
#14
If this thread gets 200+ total votes, I'll consider making porn moving a priority. If not, I'm going to just assume people don't really care either way.
 

Lanx

Aten Ha Ra Slayer
18,060
52d 8h 32m
Reactions
29,377 5,851 0 0
#15
Huh, I stand corrected, I always thought hentai was specific to tentacles and not a catch-all term.

Eh, whatever, doesn't bother me unless it's in violation of the CP type rules.
thinking hentai is only cartoons w/ tentacles is thinking sex is only missionary, get out of yo mormon ways
 

Sterling

El Presidente
<Donors Crew>
7,440
53d 5h 3m
Reactions
1,903 308 0 0
#16
Just seems like a lot of work for something most people probably don't really care that much about either way.
 

pharmakos

bµɐʁwɐʞoƨ
<Donors Crew>
9,689
19d 22h 28m
Reactions
5,389 2,033 0 0
#18
Not sure why you'd remove anything from the FSR. Trying to regulate it is just going to kill it off. But hey, go ahead and kill a good thing if you want. :shrug:
Sure you're not just too lazy to put stuff in the right spot?
 

Noodleface

Delicious Noodles
31,698
16d 7h 28m
Reactions
8,013 1,304 0 0
#19
It's weird because moving posts is easy but taking parts of a post and moving them isn't, especially attachments. Also with how often it gets posted it's all we'll be doing. Also I'll only be doing it when my entire family is asleep
 

joz123

Blackwing Lair Raider
2,246
14d 11h 55m
Reactions
1,375 198 0 0
#20
Most of the porn posted in FSR is just pics/vids or gifs and no words so it is just laziness.