Sure, he might be disappointing and you might want more for him, but you called him trash. There's a whole lot of room between elite and end of the bench garbage.
Herbert had some decision making issues in college as well. He was definitely a high upside, potential disaster pick and he looks like he's really worked out. Tua is a potential disaster pick because of health reasons, but he's shown flashes of great accuracy on some throws and is a smart kid...
expansion launches where you race another guild is still pretty fun, but being 2 months into PoP and replacing that piece of P3 loot with a P5 or Quarm loot is not very exciting for sure.
I mean is anyone really watching this show for the writing? I mean it needs to be at least somewhat reasonable and not jarringly bad, but the appeal of the show is that it's fun and feels like the Star Wars you remember.
I think some of it is matchups and how teams are built. Titans, Browns, Ravens, etc are all running teams and built for close games and holding a lead. None of those teams are particularly good at playing from behind. Colts and Browns would be amazing with a real QB.