Crimson Peak - Guillermo del Toro's return to horror

Jait

Molten Core Raider
5,035
5,317
In a year filled jam packed with blockbusters like all del toros films this will be the one that gets least talked about and ends up being the best film of the year.
 

Homsar

Silver Baronet of the Realm
8,780
7,553
No, besides pans labyrinth which wasnt the best film that year, Hellboy and Pacific Rim were beautiful but story sucked and were writen by him. His work isnt terrible but he also does deserve credit. If you look at his writing it gets worse
 

Asshat Brando

Potato del Grande
<Banned>
5,346
-478
No, besidespans labyrinthwhich wasnt the best film that year, Hellboy and Pacific Rim were beautiful but story sucked and were writen by him. His work isnt terrible but he also does deserve credit. If you look at his writing it gets worse
I only think the Prestige was better that year, the Departed was definitely an excellent film but it's a story that's been told a lot of times.
 

Chukzombi

Millie's Staff Member
71,832
213,177
film looks like it might be ok, though i would love to see a British horror film that actually takes place in modern times. what is it with setting these films in victorian england?
 

Dioblaire

And now my Watch has ended...
<Donor>
1,841
452
This is one "horror" themed movie I would be willing to see in theaters.
 

etchazz

Trakanon Raider
2,707
1,056
No, besides pans labyrinth which wasnt the best film that year, Hellboy and Pacific Rim were beautiful but story sucked and were writen by him. His work isnt terrible but he also does deserve credit. If you look at his writing it gets worse
"Pan's Labyrinth" deserved best picture, and a half dozen other awards, including best actor for Sergi Lopez (one of the greatest villains in cinema history). Del Toro also produced "The Orphanage" which was a great film. Have no problem with Del Toro doing "Mountains of Madness", just do it right.
 

Homsar

Silver Baronet of the Realm
8,780
7,553
"Pan's Labyrinth" deserved best picture, and a half dozen other awards, including best actor for Sergi Lopez (one of the greatest villains in cinema history). Del Toro also produced "The Orphanage" which was a great film. Have no problem with Del Toro doing "Mountains of Madness", just do it right.
It got shafted but was better film over the Departed......thats just stupid
 

Heriotze

<Gold Donor>
1,032
1,410
Del Toro was just born to make movies and the man has a masterful grasp on what that entails. He's got that Coen brothers vision of everything that needs to be and his movies never end up failing due to having a scattershot tone like most horror movies fall to nowadays. I think, after watching all of his films, the biggest criticism that I could muster against him is that the movies that he writes or produces tend to have the feeling of a Del Toro movie but the director pulls back the intensity so it ends up feeling flawed, it never gets to that Pan's Labyrinth level. If the dude never gets his 120+ mil to make Mountains of Madness he needs to sign on with HBO or Showtime and do a Del Toro version of The Dark Tower. Really looking forward to this movie, thanks for the trailer.
 

Caliane

Avatar of War Slayer
14,637
10,147
film looks like it might be ok, though i would love to see a British horror film that actually takes place in modern times. what is it with setting these films in victorian england?
Have you not seen Attack the Block?
Theres the werewolf movies. A good number really. from 80-2010's. Varying level of budgets.
A number of vampire movies too.

Shaun of the dead, worlds end, etc obviously too.
 

Caliane

Avatar of War Slayer
14,637
10,147
Del toro does fantasy better then horror.
Now, this can be done well. And he often does do it well.

Its a fine line between what he does, and what Burton does, and ends up with Sleepy hollow.
Del toro manages to make the supernatural feel alien still. Which is good. Its required to make them scary. and he does it, while showing you them. A magical unseen world.

Look at Mama, which he just produced. Pretty good, until the end, where the CGI take over and the ghost is humanized. Particularly when the ghost "wins", and what should be utterly horrific, is kindof undermined.

Its largely why japanese ghost stories are so much better lately. the ghost/horror culture has not been Americanized by years of poltergheist, freddy/jason, house on haunted hills, etc. Japanese ghosts are still utterly alien to American audiences and totally evil. American ghosts can be appeased, and often even reasoned with. we have guardian spirits and innocent spirits. Japanese do not. all ghosts are bad, even children. They must be cleansed, not appeased.
 

Chukzombi

Millie's Staff Member
71,832
213,177
Have you not seen Attack the Block?
Theres the werewolf movies. A good number really. from 80-2010's. Varying level of budgets.
A number of vampire movies too.

Shaun of the dead, worlds end, etc obviously too.
attack the block, shaun of the dead and and world's end are scifi comedies or horror comedies at best. yeah 30 years ago they made good Brit horror movies set in modern times, but they dont anymore. its like hollywood decided that americans think the brits never left the victorian era or something. there are some exceptions like 28 days later. still, that was 13 years ago.
 

Caliane

Avatar of War Slayer
14,637
10,147
why in gods name would you want such great writer/director to do a piece of shit like that?

we have Justice league dark, mountains of madness, Pacific rim 2/3, Hellboy 3, Silent hill. any other number of original things, etc, and you want him to do a King novel?