this. there should NEVER be raid limits in a game. if i'm in a guild, and there are 100 of us, and we all decide one friday night that we all want to play, then why should there be a limit placed on how many of us are allowed to? that doesn't make any fucking sense at all. if a guild wants to bring that many peeps to the fight, and /random with 99 other people for 5 or 6 pieces of loot, so be it. hell, you can scale the difficulty of the fight depending on how many people you have, or even increase the loot or the rarity of the drops depending on how you want to reward the players (more loot for less players? more loot for more players but less of a chance for the rarest items? who knows? a hundred ways you could do this) but there should never be a limit placed on how many people are allowed to go. i had a shit ton more fun doing 70+ person raids in everquest than i ever did doing 15 or 40 or so in WoW.