Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
That's not the argument at all. It's not about potential loss, it's about potential growth.
Fallout 4
- Thread starter Regime
- Start date
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
3300 total DLs on just the platform that currently allows modding, in the community of people who use mods, 3 years after launch.
Demand exists.
Demand or bored and trying different mods out?
You are being ridiculous. The person that will not play this game because of dismemberment but will ignore every other aspect of the violence is a deranged person.
It's practically the same thing as Japanese porn blurring out portions of genitalia but still allowing full penetration and graphic porn. Just senseless.
Skanda
I'm Amod too!
- 6,662
- 4,506
The only numbers I have to go on is the number of download of gore removing mods for FO3/NV, most of which don't even break 5k downloads which is nothing. Can I say for certain that there aren't 100k people waiting in the wings for a G rated Fallout? No, I can't but I feel reasonably certain that they don't exist.
As for the rest of your post. Just removing limbs flying of would probably be pretty damn easy but why stop there? One of the (The Gore No More mod, same one you linked above) FO3 mods actually removed all the dead bodies hanging from hooks, etc. If gore is scaring away some hidden untapped market segment then just stopping at limb damage probably isn't going to entice them to give FO4 a second look. Changes like that would require a lot more time.
Skanda
I'm Amod too!
- 6,662
- 4,506
That is anemic demand if I've ever seen it. One thousand people a year and you're going to try to justify that Bethesda should spend labor resources to satisfy that?
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
Maybe you'real right, but I'll tell you this. I'd let my Young teen/tween play something with blood splatters from gunshots or sword swipes, but would not let him play something with graphic dismemberment.
Call it arbitrary if you like, but I bet I'm not alone.
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
Those ratings are suggestions. As a parent I have final control, and game companies should know this.
hodj
Vox Populi Jihadi
- 31,672
- 18,377
Fallout 4 on track to sell several times more copies than Fallout 3 or NV did.
They aren't worried about potential growth of sub 4k sales over three years.
As I said at the start of this, removing gore and limbs flying off and shit is effectively saying "Let's make a Fallout game but remove all the stuff that makes it Fallout. Surely that will lead to more sales!"
It won't. It will kill the franchise. You can't have post apocalyptic without over the top violence. Mad Max is a good example and one of the original inspirations of the series.
Imagine you were in the Fury Road thread saying "I've got a great idea, think about how many people avoided watching Fury Road because of all the violence, the warboys throwing themselves on the hedgehog cars and blowing themselves up and shit. What if we removed all that violence from the film? Think about how much potential sales growth you'd have by making a Mad Max game that's fun for the whole family!"
You'd rightfully be ridiculed.
Same shit here.
No different from The Walking Dead on TV.
You are being a pedantic little shit if you will let your kids play a game like Fallout but only if the dismemberment was removed.
What's next? They can only play GTA if they take the word shit out but leave the word fuck in there?
You are being a pedantic little shit if you will let your kids play a game like Fallout but only if the dismemberment was removed.
What's next? They can only play GTA if they take the word shit out but leave the word fuck in there?
hodj
Vox Populi Jihadi
- 31,672
- 18,377
Quaid is busy proclaiming he'd go all conservative Christian Jack Thompson on his kid over Fallout fantasy dismemberment.
Meanwhile I've already told my kids if they want to take November 10th off school and stay home and play Fallout 4 all day, I'll write them a note excusing their absence from school due to sickness from radiation poisoning.
Meanwhile I've already told my kids if they want to take November 10th off school and stay home and play Fallout 4 all day, I'll write them a note excusing their absence from school due to sickness from radiation poisoning.
Skanda
I'm Amod too!
- 6,662
- 4,506
No one is arguing with you about this. What we're saying is expecting Bethesda to cater to your tween with an established Mature rated franchise is a bit silly.
Go ahead Johnny and kill everyone but just don't do it messy. Instead make it super realistic so you could actually envision yourself doing it.
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
1. It wouldn't be sub 4K sales after 3 years. That's not what that figure says at all and you know it. It says that among PC gamers, who participate in modding, after 3 years of release, there is STILL enough residual demand for such a feature that 3000+ players would seek it out. Imagine if the feature was available cross platform, from the options menu, on release day. What impact would that situation have on demand?
2. The whole Mad Max thing is a false equivalence. There is very little about poorly executed dismemberment graphics that is critical to the telling of Fallout's story/message. There can still be hyper violence without it being gay. See recent DOOM gameplay.
2. The whole Mad Max thing is a false equivalence. There is very little about poorly executed dismemberment graphics that is critical to the telling of Fallout's story/message. There can still be hyper violence without it being gay. See recent DOOM gameplay.
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
hodj
Vox Populi Jihadi
- 31,672
- 18,377
Butthurt at being on the losing side of a shitty argument you started about stuff you know nothing about detected.
Let me help make this perfectly clear to you:
No one gives a fuck if you find dismemberment triggering, Jack Thompson.
No one gives a fuck if your non existent children wouldn't be allowed to play this game because you find dismemberment triggering, either.
You don't understand development cycles. You have spent multiple pages shitting up this thread speaking solely from your ignorance.
Get over it.
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
Skanda
I'm Amod too!
- 6,662
- 4,506
Fallout 3 *shipped* nearly 5 million units. Even being generous and saying that such a feature would generate 10k sales that's still absolutely nothing in the scheme of things and trying to justify to Bethesda that they should spend more labor dollars chasing a paltry 10k sales would probably be a bit of a hard sell.
hodj
Vox Populi Jihadi
- 31,672
- 18,377
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 11,558
- 7,866
Hahahaha or maybe I'm trying to bring some levity into a conversation that you have absolutely polluted with your usual levels of batshit crazy aggression?