MMO developers most laid off.

  • Guest, it's time once again for the hotly contested and exciting FoH Asshat Tournament!



    Go here and fill out your bracket!
    Who's been the biggest Asshat in the last year? Once again, only you can decide!

kudos

<Banned>
2,363
695
This type of thinking works great in politics, where people aren't actually solving problems. It isn't actually true where problems are solved daily...as in the private sector.

That being said, MMO development studios need to follow the trend set before them by the film industry. A lot of animation studios are beginning to outsource a lot of their work instead of doing it all in house. This does two things:
1. It keeps companies solvent
2. It releases a better product

If MMO studios would branch off from trying to do everything well into microcosms that do one specific thing well, we'd probably see a lot higher quality products being released. Hollywood is leading the way...
Everquest 2 outsourced their models to Korea. They did a better job than SoE could do.
 

AladainAF

Best Rabbit
<Gold Donor>
12,846
30,786
Yes, agreed. There's nothing wrong with making an MMO that caters to 100k-200k subs total, so long as they are able to make that game profitable for that core niche of players. The problem is, publisher expectation levels for success on most MMOs are usually way off, by at least 10-15x.
That's what surprised me about the closing of CoH. I knew and met -lots- of VIP Subscribers, myself included that played. It had a pretty strong core base. I'd be very very surprised if CoH wasn't profitable.

I miss that game already. So many good fun memories, even in the later years.
 

Khane

Got something right about marriage
19,787
13,294
Jesus christ this guy is necroing every thread on the fucking forums.
 
  • 1Dislike
Reactions: 1 user

Grim1

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
4,854
6,812
MMOs are more popular than ever but now there is competition and the genre just isn't about rpgs anymore. The millions of subs Wow lost didn't just vanish, most of them went to other mmos. And millions more are playing mmos than 10 years ago.

But the market has changed. MMOs aren't just about wizards and elves and endless questing anymore. There are a lot more options in theme and playstyle, and that is great. It use to be EQ, Wow and Lineage, now the list of mmo choices is almost endless.

And there are still a ton of people putting out the old, tired, Lord of the Rings copies. Wizards, Elves and Orcs never die, they just get renamed by the latest hack.
 

Kharzette

Watcher of Overs
4,855
3,470
I can give you my 2 coppers from having worked on one. In our case there were instanced missions that made up the bulk of the content. They had a bit of story, some scripting, usually some kind of reward and took around 30 minutes to play.

However they took around a couple months to make. The math just doesn't add up. The main reason was that creation was mired in process. A document was created, a meeting held, more documentation, actual scripting, play session with feedback, document review, then wider testing.

While it's nice to have all the feedback, and some feedback is worth more than others (ie the boss), give a typical modder the above task and they would knock it out in a couple days. And I'd argue it would probably be better for the singular vision rather than the too-many-cooks stuff I saw.

In such an environment, the best stuff got made by hiding it, working on it on nights and weekends till it was almost complete, and only then showing it.
 
  • 4Like
Reactions: 3 users

tyen

EQ in a browser wait time: ____
<Banned>
4,638
5,164
AR geolocated MMOs is where itll go next.

Pokemongo touched on it, but the AR was awful. Niantic's harry potter game will set the standard.

I have a real fucking good framework that does 2cm accuracy where you can place things and itll be in the exact spot you left it.

im mostly slanging it for enterprise use, but this type of style is going to be adapted for real geolocated games.

Not like that bullshit jenga/slingshot/lego crap theyve been showing the past month.

 
  • 3Picard
  • 1Repost
  • 1Solidarity
Reactions: 5 users

Warrik

Potato del Grande
<Donor>
1,295
-645
We need Raph Koster, Brad McQuaid, and John Smedley to save the genre....
 
  • 1Worf
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 users

Zajeer

Molten Core Raider
544
448
I can give you my 2 coppers from having worked on one. In our case there were instanced missions that made up the bulk of the content. They had a bit of story, some scripting, usually some kind of reward and took around 30 minutes to play.

However they took around a couple months to make. The math just doesn't add up. The main reason was that creation was mired in process. A document was created, a meeting held, more documentation, actual scripting, play session with feedback, document review, then wider testing.

While it's nice to have all the feedback, and some feedback is worth more than others (ie the boss), give a typical modder the above task and they would knock it out in a couple days. And I'd argue it would probably be better for the singular vision rather than the too-many-cooks stuff I saw.

In such an environment, the best stuff got made by hiding it, working on it on nights and weekends till it was almost complete, and only then showing it.
Having also worked on a few of them, as well as other non-MMO games, a lot of companies use very archaic practices to do work. A lot of them still use waterfall methodologies, or try to use Scrum, but its a bastardized version where they still value excessive documentation over working software. Also, game development is mired with poor producers/project managers that would rather micro-manage the creative process instead of just facilitating a team to build what they think is best. Very few companies in the industry do it right unfortunately, and instead choose to grind their employees to death (because hey, you're working on games! cool right?!) instead of trying to adapt and instill better processes with their teams. This then leads to either stifled creativity, or slow content releases, or both.

Consider, a lot of the guys running these companies have been building software before Agile became mainstream and haven't adapted - and frankly they somehow keep getting work/funding from companies that don't know any better
 
  • 3Like
Reactions: 2 users