The D&D thread

Grabbit Allworth

Confirmed J6 Insurrectionist
2,087
8,323
I don't even see how this new D&D team could make a Dark Sun setting. Everything would be "triggering".
Yep. If it does make it to print, it's going to be sandblasted into something that is Dark Sun in name only.

The old setting material is enough to put Leftists into a permanent seizure. There's a super long thread about it at ENWorld (don't visit that board if you value your IQ) and based on those comments alone, I genuinely hope it never makes it to print.
 
  • 1Solidarity
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 users

Arbitrary

Tranny Chaser
33,418
97,973
You move the timeline up so that all the slaves are free and the desertification through magic is mostly fixed (heroic cabal of women practitioners) but there's a holdout of baddies for our diverse team of diversity to go stop. They want to make everything a slave desert again because they're men.

edit - got some concept art

1770496964168.png
 
Last edited:
  • 2Worf
  • 1Barf
Reactions: 2 users

Grabbit Allworth

Confirmed J6 Insurrectionist
2,087
8,323
I don't even see how this new D&D team could make a Dark Sun setting. Everything would be "triggering".
Yep.

For the last few years I have been holding on to the miniscule bit of hope that WotC might pull D&D out of its tailspin, but the recent wave of hires has completely destroyed that hope. There's .01% chance that a new Dark Sun product is anything more than the logo.

The D&D IP is completely cooked and whomever is in charge of their design/market direction is either a 70 IQ troglodyte or an extreme activist that couldn't care less how much money the brand loses.

There's no other explanation. Games, movies, and basically all forms of entertainment infused with Leftist propaganda have been getting gutted for years now. The 'people' do not want it, but the retard activists continue to produce it and lose their asses.

I'm all for watching them set billions on fire, but I don't want my beloved IPs to be a part of their sacrificial pyre.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Chanur

Shit Posting Professional
<Aristocrat╭ರ_•́>
34,886
64,028
Yep.

For the last few years I have been holding on to the miniscule bit of hope that WotC might pull D&D out of its tailspin, but the recent wave of hires has completely destroyed that hope. There's .01% chance that a new Dark Sun product is anything more than the logo.

The D&D IP is completely cooked and whomever is in charge of their design/market direction is either a 70 IQ troglodyte or an extreme activist that couldn't care less how much money the brand loses.

There's no other explanation. Games, movies, and basically all forms of entertainment infused with Leftist propaganda have been getting gutted for years now. The 'people' do not want it, but the retard activists continue to produce it and lose their asses.

I'm all for watching them set billions on fire, but I don't want my beloved IPs to be a part of their sacrificial pyre.
Yeah new D&D is essentially dead to me. In starting to focus on smaller games like Shadow Dark and Lamentations of the Flame Princess. They are old school D&D based and keep the dangerous sword and sorcery feel.
 

Grabbit Allworth

Confirmed J6 Insurrectionist
2,087
8,323
Yeah new D&D is essentially dead to me. In starting to focus on smaller games like Shadow Dark and Lamentations of the Flame Princess. They are old school D&D based and keep the dangerous sword and sorcery feel.
I still play 5e regularly, but I've house-ruled it so much that you could argue that it's a new system. I haven't really changed any of the core fundamentals, but I have layered a massive number of additional systems on top of the existing framework.

Over the last few years I have experimented with a lot of new rules. Some worked, some didn't.

I needed (and still need) to go through those growing pains because some rules that sounded good in theory, didn't work well in practice.

For example - I really like the idea of characters needing to maintain their equipment after being damaged in combat, etc.

However, 99.5% of the time it ends up being effectively handwaved because it's mostly trivial unless you build a subsystem that accounts for character skill, armor type, damage type, materials involved, the availability of tools, etc.

It ends up becoming more simulation than game and a massive waste of time. It's much better to assume that characters will do what's necessary to maintain their gear unless it's outright destroyed or a specific narrative point puts some moment-to-moment emphasis on it.

The handling of resources such as food and water is another example, but this one is more nuanced and fun. The way I describe it to my players is that they don't matter until they do. For example - when you're in a town or village, it's assumed that you're able to easily feed yourself, but if you're in a desert tens of miles from anything -- well, that's a different situation.

Also, my long rest system is something I am really, really proud of. It adds some much needed variability to a system that is easily exploitable by players.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions: 2 users

Chanur

Shit Posting Professional
<Aristocrat╭ರ_•́>
34,886
64,028
I still play 5e regularly, but I've house-ruled it so much that you could argue that it's a new system. I haven't really changed any of the core fundamentals, but I have layered a massive number of additional systems on top of the existing framework.

Over the last few years I have experimented with a lot of new rules. Some worked, some didn't.

I needed (and still need) to go through those growing pains because some rules that sounded good in theory, didn't work well in practice.

For example - I really like the idea of characters needing to maintain their equipment after being damaged in combat, etc.

However, 99.5% of the time it ends up being effectively handwaved because it's mostly trivial unless you build a subsystem that accounts for character skill, armor type, damage type, materials involved, the availability of tools, etc.

It ends up becoming more simulation than game and a massive waste of time. It's much better to assume that characters will do what's necessary to maintain their gear unless it's outright destroyed or a specific narrative point puts some moment-to-moment emphasis on it.

The handling of resources such as food and water is another example, but this one is more nuanced and fun. The way I describe it to my players is that they don't matter until they do. For example - when you're in a town or village, it's assumed that you're able to easily feed yourself, but if you're in a desert tens of miles from anything -- well, that's a different situation.
Don't get me wrong I still enjoy 5E as well and play it occasionally too. For new products though I don't even look at it anymore. Still a great playing game.

I'm really looking forward to Deathdealer from the Proffessor Dungeon Master guy. It's kick starting next month I think.