You mean the guys who did this?
Dont like Rogue One and you are surprised? Jesus Christ. They are not inherently wrong that it is just nostalgia bait but AGAIN, it was different (till well it wasnt when Vader showed up). It was a mess and the acting was all over the place and CGI Tarkin is retarded, and stupid shit like the dudes from the Cantina in A New Hope being in it is mega retarded but I didn't hate it. I saw it twice. Once in theaters and once after finishing Andor season 2. I think I hated it the second time because Andor was just SO much better.
This doesn't have to do with anything being familiar, its saying the people who made Acolyte had a vision for what the show was to be, what it would look like and what the themes would be and who it may appeal to. None of that makes any product good, but what it does do is a give a product a solid foundation to be good. Apparently it wasn't a story people enjoyed and the acting was bad and the culture war exists so it failed. It didn't fail because of Darth fucking Plageus (what the fuck who the fuck cares), or some frame by frame analysis of the lightsaber fight or Angry Joe screeching like a retard. Andor is a really woke show, but noone cared. I cant fucking imagine why (can you figure it out)
The only thing I wish he would have talked about more was Solo film before Lord and Miller were fired. They obviously had a specific vision for that movie and Disney AGAIN wanted it to appeal to everyone and the end result was trash. A Lord and Miller Star Wars comedy like 21 Jump Street could have been something very special and VERY different. Instead we got something I cant even remember watching.
Again if you want them to rail on culture war shit you shouldn't be watching them. They are much more likely to mock people doing that or fans that do. They called Disney cowards for not shipping Rey and Finn, if Disney listened to them I think the meltdown would have been epic to witness.