I played Archeage and ya.. it "sort of" reminds me of that. But not really. This one seems like a different game altogether in the "theme" department. PVP is almost non-existant. The story I posted earlier is one story. Another happened this morning at a high lvl camp. This group trained us, and killed one of our members. He had an epic material on him that dropped, some jack off picked it up in their group and then the bard got pvp, then the cleric etc. That flagged them all - we're higher lvl. We go in and merc their whole group and then had the camp to ourselves. There just isnt any "random" pvp "so far" and no roaving bands of red players .. thats like some boogie man story or something I guess? Or its just too early for it, one. Guards merc anyone that is flagged, so it seems like it bricks your character pretty much.
The game isnt polished, though. Its playable and Im enjoying it. But there seems like a new bug every day.. but so far?.. Theyve been fixing them within a day or two. Like there was a bug recently that was bricking characters by resetting their lvl to 0 in everything, from combat to trades. Now its fixed. So.. ya, its alpha. But if you have patience? It's worth the box price, but not a sub.