If it's so small, try showing up to your mechanic with the parts you bought online and see how happy they are about that.
Here's what Gemini says...
You're conflating two entirely different arguments. A shop not wanting to install customer-supplied parts has absolutely nothing to do with the size of the markup they're applying to parts they source themselves. That's a liability, warranty, and profit-margin issue. If I bring you an alternator I bought online and it turns out to be defective, you're now stuck dealing with the labor, the customer, and the inconvenience of a part you didn't supply. That's a perfectly reasonable business decision, but it doesn't establish anything about OEM parts markup.
And I'm not sure why we're treating Gemini's generic parts markup estimates as some sort of authoritative industry data. A 50-100% markup on a midrange part might be perfectly representative of some independent shops, but that doesn't mean it's representative of dealership OEM pricing. You're lumping together independent shops buying through aftermarket distributors, independent shops sourcing OEM parts, and franchised dealerships buying directly through manufacturer distribution channels. Those are three different supply chains with different acquisition costs and pricing structures.
My original point was that dealerships generally have a significant advantage when sourcing OEM parts because they're buying directly through established manufacturer channels. An independent shop often has to go through an intermediary to obtain those same parts. That difference in acquisition cost matters when you're comparing what each business charges the customer.
I'm not arguing that dealerships don't mark up parts. Of course they do. I'm arguing that the idea that dealerships are making enormous margins on major OEM components is generally misguided. Their profitability is much more dependent on labor revenue and the additional services they sell.
Approaching this from a different angle. Does the mechanic (the one doing the actual work in a larger shop) still get paid a flat rate based on a labor/cost book? I.e. if the book says a brake job should take an hour and the labor rate is $100 you get that if you do it in 10 minutes or 5 hours? When I got out of high school I was looking at a school that did a double ASE cert in gas and diesel and it was explained like that. That BS plus not wanting to be greasy was why I got into construction.
Yes, a lot of dealerships and larger shops still operate on a flat-rate system. However, I think that model is starting to face some serious challenges. Fewer people are going to dealerships for routine maintenance (and maintenance in general, because the economy is fucked), and an increasing proportion of dealership work is warranty-related, which puts additional pressure on the traditional flat-rate model.
Personally, I think the better route for a technician entering the industry today is to find a shop that offers a salaried position with performance-based bonuses. It provides a little more stability while still rewarding productivity and efficiency.
I wouldn't be surprised if we see flat rate gradually phased out, or at least become considerably less common, over the next five years or so. I think the economics and changing dynamics of the industry are going to make it increasingly difficult to sustain as the predominant compensation model.