Desktop Computers

Jovec

Jovec

?
879
463
9800X3D vs 9900/9950 X/X3D

I'm not a big fan of the 12 core models. I prefer to go with the 8 core (single CCD) X3D chip for gaming. This eliminates any core parking/scheduling issues where the game may end up running on the non-X3D part of the CPU. I know AMD and MS have gotten better at making sure that doesn't happen, so perhaps it is not as big an issue was it previously was.

Or go with the full 16 core model if you need the threads. 9950X3D can still have the scheduling issues (as can all 12 and 16 dual-CCD models) though.
 
Lanx

Lanx

<Prior Amod>
72,123
169,882
Lanx said:
Their bios has been fucking over ppl for a few years now
Click to expand...
man i remember when bios was cool
f39d1a409d2b6b57b8cd61f52edcc09d.png

back in the 2000 i had a corrupted bios, the fix was to boot into another pc i had (my wife and i played eq and we both multipc), and while in the bios screen, remove the bios chip, and put in the corrupted one and overwrite the bios.

it didn't give a new bios to the chip, but rather once it was transplanted it just saw it as the wrong bios (instead of corrupted) and i was then able to reflash it.

and since it was offered
55e6244df8dc35a3ccd40e8f5e4f80ea.png

i always buy the mb that had dual bios, even tho i haven't used a dual flash since that one time. (it's like having a spare tire and changing it on the road, and thinking i'm never driving w/o one in the trunk ever, fuck these weird spray foam tire fix)
 
  • 2Like
Reactions: 1 users
Neranja

Neranja

<Bronze Donator>
2,891
4,656
Lanx said:
i always buy the mb that had dual bios, even tho i haven't used a dual flash since that one time. (it's like having a spare tire and changing it on the road, and thinking i'm never driving w/o one in the trunk ever, fuck these weird spray foam tire fix)
Click to expand...
Most modern motherboards (at least the ones I own) with the AM5 platform can flash the BIOS when it fails, or when you have trouble with CPU compatibility. On Gigabyte it's called Q-Flash Plus: You download the BIOS and put it on a FAT32 USB Stick as "gigabyte.bin", plug it in and press the button.

You don't need a CPU, graphics card or RAM. Push button, receive BIOS.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user
Jovec

Jovec

?
879
463
ShakyJake said:
Btw, what's up with ASUS? In the past, I usually went with Gigabyte or MSI anyway, as I had always seen ASUS as a premium brand and a bit overpriced.
Click to expand...

Increasingly high price premiums and shady customer service where they are denying warranty repairs and trying to charge instead. They've also had some manufacturing issues 4 years ago (they reversed the direction of a polarized capacitor) on one high-end mobo (Z690 Hero) that they lied about until the youtube tech media final pressured them.

They've taken some heat for their mobos over-volting CPUs to juice benchmarks, but all brands do that. When Intel Core Duo was king Asus was enable MCE by default for the same reason. This was more public with the SoC voltages on AMD CPUs, especially X3Ds, but that was more a AMD issue allowing mobos to set it too high and again, all brands did it too. Asrock still seems to be having problems with X3D CPUs dying (current theory is bad BIOS chips corrupting things - they were fine, then swtich supplliers and had issues, and now switched back), but the other brands have it resolved.

On the price side, they've introduced the Astral line above their previous top end (Strix), but besides the high MSRP the quality is fine. They've also introcuded some new low cost lines, so this lets them raise previously low/mid lines up the stack (TUF line was mid tier, now it's high tier by how Asus defines it).
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user
ShakyJake

ShakyJake

<Donor>
8,324
20,811
Jovec said:
9800X3D vs 9900/9950 X/X3D

I'm not a big fan of the 12 core models. I prefer to go with the 8 core (single CCD) X3D chip for gaming. This eliminates any core parking/scheduling issues where the game may end up running on the non-X3D part of the CPU. I know AMD and MS have gotten better at making sure that doesn't happen, so perhaps it is not as big an issue was it previously was.

Or go with the full 16 core model if you need the threads. 9950X3D can still have the scheduling issues (as can all 12 and 16 dual-CCD models) though.
Click to expand...
I'm not gaming on this PC, I have another for that. The main application that I want to run as best as possible is the Thinkorswim trading platform. It's a Java-based application and its performance is already God awful. From my understanding, single core performance is all that matters for it which is why I originally was just going to stick with Intel. But I admit it probably makes little difference, as I'm effectively trying to brute force performance onto an already shitty application.
 
Jovec

Jovec

?
879
463
ShakyJake said:
I'm not gaming on this PC, I have another for that. The main application that I want to run as best as possible is the Thinkorswim trading platform. It's a Java-based application and its performance is already God awful. From my understanding, single core performance is all that matters for it which is why I originally was just going to stick with Intel. But I admit it probably makes little difference, as I'm effectively trying to brute force performance onto an already shitty application.
Click to expand...

Best single core AMD is the 9950X or 9950X3D. It's also possible to disable a CCD in the BIOS to make it an 8-core so everything stays on the same CCD. I cannot say how it compares to Intel, but I think the difference is going to be a few % between Intel and AMD for single core Java, unless somehow the massive L3 cache of the X3D matters.
 
Kajiimagi

Kajiimagi

<Aristocrat╭ರ_•́>
3,611
6,842
Lanx said:
Their bios has been fucking over ppl for a few years now
Click to expand...
This 100%. Last and I do mean THE LAST Asus MB I bought was an upper mid-range board. Whatever they called their 'military grade' stuff at the time. Every other MB with that chipset got a bios update for the round(s) of Intel exploits except mine. I decided then they can fuck right off.
 
Kajiimagi

Kajiimagi

<Aristocrat╭ರ_•́>
3,611
6,842
Neranja said:
Most modern motherboards (at least the ones I own) with the AM5 platform can flash the BIOS when it fails, or when you have trouble with CPU compatibility. On Gigabyte it's called Q-Flash Plus: You download the BIOS and put it on a FAT32 USB Stick as "gigabyte.bin", plug it in and press the button.

You don't need a CPU, graphics card or RAM. Push button, receive BIOS.
Click to expand...
Pretty sure you can do this with MSI boards as well.
 
Malakriss

Malakriss

Golden Baronet of the Realm
13,034
12,408
We run some machines with 12th gen chips on ASUS boards, some because they were current other because I avoided 13th and 14th and went with a discounted 12. Fortunately the latest one with a GPU quick release button was the attached wire version and not their propriatory BS that would scrape and rip chunks off the card. Poor decisions were made after that era by both design and customer service.
 
Lambourne

Lambourne

Bronze Baronet of the Realm
3,558
8,444
It's hard to recommend intel right now. I built my first AMD system since about 2004 this year so I'm hardly an AMD fanboy. Current intel boards will likely be a dead end, AM5 should get a few more generations and the X3D chips just rock.
 
Lanx

Lanx

<Prior Amod>
72,123
169,882
INTHEMIDSTOFLIONS said:
I want it to be at least a small desktop build. Is the cost much higher for that to make it not worth it?
Click to expand...
well i'm sure you realize your expandability is nil and you won't turboboost to higher sustained speeds/oc b/c your heatsink is limiting you

if i were to work w/ that, i'd suggest you get a aio, the case you chose can accept a 280

if youre going for budget, idcooling is no frills
31b8e121357dcc7f8e38274d67b6f743.png

for 35$ more
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user
INTHEMIDSTOFLIONS

INTHEMIDSTOFLIONS

Lord Nagafen Raider
556
780
Lanx said:
well i'm sure you realize your expandability is nil and you won't turboboost to higher sustained speeds/oc b/c your heatsink is limiting you

if i were to work w/ that, i'd suggest you get a aio, the case you chose can accept a 280

if youre going for budget, idcooling is no frills
31b8e121357dcc7f8e38274d67b6f743.png

for 35$ more
Click to expand...
Sure. I have no issue with AIO vs air cooling. Just looking for performance better than my XSX and legion go, but while maintaining a smaller framework. I’m open to larger but it seems that the cost/size for a bigger case is only about $100 less.
 
Lanx

Lanx

<Prior Amod>
72,123
169,882
INTHEMIDSTOFLIONS said:
Sure. I have no issue with AIO vs air cooling. Just looking for performance better than my XSX and legion go, but while maintaining a smaller framework. I’m open to larger but it seems that the cost/size for a bigger case is only about $100 less.
Click to expand...
well youre a young buck so i guess you can still put up w/ the sff limitations.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user
ShakyJake

ShakyJake

<Donor>
8,324
20,811
Alright, this is what I'm thinking about going with. Again, this isn't a gaming PC, mostly just a workstation for some software dev tinkering and the aforementioned Thinkorswim trading platform.

Waiting on Prime Day to see if any of this stuff goes on sale. Also, decided on a 9700x instead of 9900x. 9900x seems like an overkill and for single threaded apps and doesn't really offer much benefit for my uses anyway.

pc_parts.png
 
DirkDonkeyroot

DirkDonkeyroot

Blackwing Lair Raider
982
1,705
ShakyJake said:
Alright, this is what I'm thinking about going with. Again, this isn't a gaming PC, mostly just a workstation for some software dev tinkering and the aforementioned Thinkorswim trading platform.

Waiting on Prime Day to see if any of this stuff goes on sale. Also, decided on a 9700x instead of 9900x. 9900x seems like an overkill and for single threaded apps and doesn't really offer much benefit for my uses anyway.

View attachment 604670
Click to expand...
If it's a workstation only that will do anything gaming you could probably save some money with a b550 motherboard.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions: 1 users
You must log in or register to reply here.