-Animated
-No Whedon
-This guy (who is totally entitled to his beliefs...on his own time) probably injecting tons of partisan politics into it. How's he gonna work with Adam Baldwin then? Kill off Jayne in episode 1?
Show has a lot going against it. I could probably deal with two out of three of the above things but all 3 and enthusiasm is pretty much already at zero. If people on here say it's solid and it doesn't have a bunch of preaching in it, I'd be happy to give it a try.
Killing off Wash in the movie was a pretty dumb choice in retrospect, because it limited any future revival of the IP. If you want Wash included, it needs to be before the movie. Which limits the story quite a bit. Instead of being able to build on Serenity, Kaylee and Simon can't be together yet, Mal and Inara have to still be doing their "will they won't they" thing with no hope of a resolution, and so forth.
Then again, in Serenity the whole damn system got brought down, right? So I guess having it before then is good.
In an ideal world, this would dig up and utilize show concepts* that never got utilized (in the four seasons and change that the show was planned to have and never got).
Like what the hell was up with those Hands of Blue guys. Were they aliens? Androids? CIA super-soldiers?
* - If Serenity was a sum-up of what Season 5 would have been, then maybe this new show can be what Seasons 2/3/4 would have been. However, that probably requires input from Whedon and his team, and we won't get that because Muh Cancellation, so...I don't know.