Girls who broke your heart thread

Sutekh

Blackwing Lair Raider
7,489
106
Zehn - Vhex said:
Out of curiosity, does anyone know anybody where this has actually happened? I think this thread is batting like 0 for 30 on "She said she just needs time" leading to a happily ever after. We could use a success story for a change.
This guy right here.
 

Seths_foh

shitlord
0
0
Bladefury said:
That shit sucks, man. Not sure what you can do, other than hope she comes around to it. I don"t think trying to "convince" her would be a good idea.

If she really feels like being with you, then she"ll make up her mind and it"ll all be golden. If she"s not mature enough to go for it or for any other reason, well, honestly you may be dodging a bullet.
This. Do NOT try and convince her of anything. Nothing you say, no matter what it is or how you phrase it, will come across as anything other than "pressure" in her mind, and pressure will make her run away from you even faster. Leave her alone and develop the mindset that it"s over so that you have a good handle on your emotional state. Leaving her alone completely is pretty much the only way she"ll come to the realization that she wants to be with you if she is going to.
 

Zehnpai

Molten Core Raider
399
1,245
Big Sutekh said:
This guy right here.
We"ve been over this. I never said I needed time to think about my feelings about you Sutekh baby. I just needed to go take care of my past. They"re dead now, all of them. Nothing shall stand between us ever again.
 

Eomer

Trakanon Raider
5,472
272
Zehn - Vhex said:
Out of curiosity, does anyone know anybody where this has actually happened? I think this thread is batting like 0 for 30 on "She said she just needs time" leading to a happily ever after. We could use a success story for a change.
Actually the story I posted about one of my buds a few weeks back seems to have resolved itself. The chick moved in with him and all seems good. They"ve just decided that they can"t be anywhere near each other when drunk.

Soygen said:
That"s worse than fuckin" a chick you work with. At least I can go home and hide when that shit goes south. Your neighbor, though? She could cockblock future endeavors!
Yeah, that"s kind of what I figure as well. But at the same time, it would also be so convenient if it was just screwing around.
 

Seths_foh

shitlord
0
0
Eomer said:
Yeah, that"s kind of what I figure as well. But at the same time, it would also be so convenient if it was just screwing around.
I disagree. At work you"re pretty much sure to see them, and if its awkward or uncomfortable it will make work a place you don"t look forward to being at. That can make your work suffer, and all around just be a sucky part of the day to look forward to 5x a week.

At home for all you know you might never see each other at all, and if you do you can always just up and leave and go out. Not something you can do at work. I would much rather fuck some chick living next door and have it go sour than a chick I work with and have that go sour. Trust me I"ve tried the work thing.
 

Louis

Trakanon Raider
2,836
1,105
Seths said:
I disagree. At work you"re pretty much sure to see them, and if its awkward or uncomfortable it will make work a place you don"t look forward to being at. That can make your work suffer, and all around just be a sucky part of the day to look forward to 5x a week.

At home for all you know you might never see each other at all, and if you do you can always just up and leave and go out. Not something you can do at work. I would much rather fuck some chick living next door and have it go sour than a chick I work with and have that go sour. Trust me I"ve tried the work thing.
Going through this right now at work and it"s made it so shitty and uncomfortable. I try to avoid seeing her as much as possible, but seeing each other is inevitable. It"s a real mind fuck.
 

Heylel

Trakanon Raider
3,602
429
So glad it"s only an intern I"m seeing and not an actual co-worker. She"s in a whole other office now.
 

Chaotic_foh

shitlord
0
0
Thanks guys, yea I don"t know.

I tried to be supportive, I told her straight up I don"t have the answers but I care about her very much and despite the fact it sucks for me right now that i"m not going to let my pride get in the way and throw everything away. I said to take her time and her happiness is paramount to all the bullshit. I know better then to try to force someone in this situation.

I just can"t see the outcome being very good. I"m hoping it was just a "holy shit" reaction, and it derived from a place of fear and insecurity that I think everyone gets when considering serious commitment. Hopefully that, rather then deriving from a place of negativity and resentment - which I don"t think can be recovered from. Either way it doesn"t bode well.

Just bullshit that i"m sitting here miserable while shes weighing the pros and cons of our future. Really sucks. I can be on to the next without a problem but for the first time in my life i don"t want to.
 

STFU_foh

shitlord
0
0
Palum said:
Da Fuq? 5 months of dating and going on vacations and being a couple after that is a shock?
Seriously, that sounds kind of crazy to me. Did you bring up possible future marriage, living together, kids? I can see that scaring someone off, but just being official after 5 months of dating does not seem like a valid reason to get cold feet.

The whole "settling down and not knowing" doesn"t make any sense. Relationships end all of the time, and if you don"t live together it really isn"t that complicated. Sounds like that while she may be the girl of your dreams, you"re not exactly the guy of hers, and she"s still waiting for him to come along. I"m not sure how being in a relationship opposed to just dating someone changes that though. Maybe she thinks she"d have too hard of a time letting go of you at that point.

Either way, like others have said, there"s not much you can do. I agree with what Seths said. Just wait it out, let her contact you, start getting into the mindset that it isn"t going to continue.
 

STFU_foh

shitlord
0
0
Chaotic said:
I tried to be supportive, I told her straight up I don"t have the answers but I care about her very much and despite the fact it sucks for me right now that i"m not going to let my pride get in the way and throw everything away.
Question:

If she says that she"s not ready to be in a committed relationship, but just wants to continue to date like you have been, what do you say?
 

wickedj51_foh

shitlord
0
0
Chaotic said:
Need perspective please.

Met girl of my dreams. I"ll leave it like that. I"m almost 30, did the player thing for the past half a decade, never saw myself settling down. Met this girl and she turned my world upside down. First time in my life I pictured marriage, kids, buying a house together.

Dated 5 months. She felt the same. She never wanted to be married until she met me, couldn"t imagine kids until now blah blah.(Shes 24 i"m 28) Mind you, we arent looking to get married or have kids or even move in. We are both done with school, have excellent jobs, solid savings.

We just got back from this incredible vacation. Best sex of my life, genuine good time, worked great as a team. It was a big stepping stone for us I guess. So I didn"t want to do to her what I do with every girl I bang more then once, which is string her along. I havent been seeing anyone she hasnt been seeing anyone, so we had "the talk" aka; hey are we official?

She lost it. Many things were said, but ultimately it was a combination of her not knowing if she was ready to sacrifice her time and independance and her ability to grow as a person for a serious relationship (she had two over the span of about 6 years, had a fuck buddy for 4 months prior to me, i"m the fourth guy shes been with) I attempted explaining to her that a healthy relationship should never inhibit or take away anything from anyone. She said that she feels either way she would be making a huge mistake, either letting me go or settling down and not knowing.

She said she assumed all along we were together, and she knew how she felt about me, but she kept herself secure in her head by telling her maybe I didn"t feel the same (female logic) so when it turned out I did, it made it all quite real for her.

There"s more to it but I don"t want a bigger essay. I"m just fucking devastated. I can"t even remember even being hurt by a girl since I was seventeen. It just wasnt my MO. I just don"t know how to go about coping besides the obvious staying busy etc. I just never pictured a future, so i"ve never been in the position to have that future shattered. Not eating, not sleeping - i"m sure people have been there.

We spoke and as it stands she needs time. She feels emotionally depleted and doesn"t know why. It"s so out of left field and such a strange reason. Oh, everything is perfect let"s break up. With what she"s saying I don"t have the answers. You can"t "make it better" if someone fears they will lose their independance or wants to make new friends or meet new people. It"s not something I can fix, which also makes me helpless. I"m trying to give her space to get her shit sorted, but while shes figuring it out i"m miserable and it"s pretty telling where it"s going to end up.

Ps we both have hung out with each others families, stayed at each others houses made all the introductions I mean, it was pretty serious. She even met my grandmother.

tldr; fuck relationships.
The man who claims to be a "player" finds himself out played by a woman who is a greater player. Now his feelings are hurt. Good advice to you is to read the book "He is not that into you."
 

ctalbus_foh

shitlord
0
0
Heylel Teomim said:
but you"re still better off if you can lead them to the right conclusion in a way that they arrive at it themselves.

I have a hard time with this even though I logically understand what a terrible idea it is to try and be helpful. It"s just the kind of guy I am. I like doing things for people, whether friends or girlfriends. Knowing where to draw the line is tough.
Here we go! I was going to say something to this affect before I read this post. I actually study psychology and from my experiences the best way to help solve problems... not just females but it definitely works better in those situations. You want to ask them questions like well what do you think would help? Or things like that. It"s the same as someone going to a psychologist (and that"s how girls see it when they are asking for problems. It"s really just us guys being their psychologist that they sleep with).

A psychologist doesn"t just ask questions and then tell the person what their problem is and/or fix their problem. They ask what their problems is and then tries to get the person to figure it out themselves by asking them questions that they answer by themselves. It rarely works out if you "tell" them what their problems are and how to fix them. They are more likely to listen if they think they are coming up with the solution. It works with both sexes. Us guys don"t really WANT to be told what to do all the time lol... but if we are given options or at least pointed in a direction and then we happen to find the address we were looking for... we are happy because we feel like we didn"t actually get help from anyone
 

intelnavi_foh

shitlord
0
0
AlexTheDictator said:
Dudes should never bring up "the talk".
Yeah wtf. Girls look for someone with confidence etc. Tell her what you want, don"t ask what she wants, if she"s serious about you, etc. That"s the second she starts doubting you. Fucking shit. Be a man and wear the goddamn pants. If you want to move to the next level, say "I want to move to the next level, you can either come or gtfo." Don"t ask if she wants to move to the next level, that just shows that you are doubting yourself, just assume that you are gods gift to man and that she would be a fool not to.

Girls don"t know what they fucking want, they just want status. If she doesn"t think you will help her gain status, there is no reason she won"t run off to be with someone who will get her more status. It sucks you have to manipulate women this way, but it"s how they are programmed.
 

Dandain

Trakanon Raider
2,092
917
If having a poor body image = crazy - that"s most chicks in this culture. To be fair, an eating disorder might classify as worse than a poor body image.
 

Grumpus

Molten Core Raider
1,927
223
Dandain said:
If having a poor body image = crazy - that"s most chicks in this culture. To be fair, an eating disorder might classify as worse than a poor body image.
Chick is vocal about it and seeking treatment. Not a hidden "I wish I was pretty" thing.
 

Dandain

Trakanon Raider
2,092
917
Grumpus said:
Chick is vocal about it and seeking treatment. Not a hidden "I wish I was pretty" thing.
Its not a I wish I was pretty thing - at least for my experience some very attractive girls perhaps 7-9"s get all hung up on a flaw or two to the point that they have literally little to no self esteem. I guess they measure themselves to the perceived 10. Can"t say I understand it, but it isn"t uncommon. Its not like attractive people compare themselves to the elephant man, but to the one that"s "more" attractive than they are.
 

Sutekh

Blackwing Lair Raider
7,489
106
intelnavi said:
Yeah wtf. Girls look for someone with confidence etc. Tell her what you want, don"t ask what she wants, if she"s serious about you, etc. That"s the second she starts doubting you. Fucking shit. Be a man and wear the goddamn pants. If you want to move to the next level, say "I want to move to the next level, you can either come or gtfo." Don"t ask if she wants to move to the next level, that just shows that you are doubting yourself, just assume that you are gods gift to man and that she would be a fool not to.

Girls don"t know what they fucking want, they just want status. If she doesn"t think you will help her gain status, there is no reason she won"t run off to be with someone who will get her more status. It sucks you have to manipulate women this way, but it"s how they are programmed.
If he was gods gift to man. Then he would be a faggot.
 

Chaotic_foh

shitlord
0
0
STFU said:
Question:

If she says that she"s not ready to be in a committed relationship, but just wants to continue to date like you have been, what do you say?
This is where my pride kicks in. Originally I was very dismissive of the thought. Then my brother was like "You"re going to lose her over that? Just let it happen man" and I realized that I would continue on.

It"s just a slippery slope letting a women have all the power, however it"s past that point now.

As far as the confidence thing / initiating the talk etc she knows how I was in the past. I"m making no excuses for it. I was not the best guy whatsoever. To this girl though, I was. I was trying to make her happy and do right by her because I figured that"s what she wanted (being official) her response being "Haven"t we been this whole time? I cant!" threw me for a loop.

The status thing. Without delving too much into that shit, I have the career and income that most women brag to their friends about. I think that"s a large part of why i"m able to land the women that I normally do. It"s not my killer skills at mashing LMB in diablo 3.

I also realize that unfortunately, manipulating women is a large part of the traditional dynamic. I"m just not willing to do that with her. Or wasn"t. She"s also pretty fucking smart and i"m a bad liar so I don"t know how it would even go over.

I know i"m the guy of her dreams. I know there"s no one else, at least not now. Her problem is "I can"t ever imagine finding someone better to marry" but being in relationships in the past where she sacrificed alot of herself and her ability to grow (her words) and not wanting to do the same again. You can"t talk someone out of that mentality. She knows if she allows herself it will get to that point, and shes scared.

I havent initiated any contact. Sucks my fucking balls. I"m so tempted to go meet or hang out with women, old hook ups etc but i won"t disrespect her like that even now. It would be a coping mechanism and bullshit. I"m just venting, makes me feel better just to write stuff. I definitively have the mentality that it"s over though - I just can"t wrap my head around the way people think sometimes.


As an aside. I had a lady today that was trying to take her kids home (3 and 5) she is 25. Her ex husband shows up with his new girlfriend (whom have been sending porno videos of themselves in an attempt to hurt our original lady that she"s brushed off) I guess this infuriated them. He ends up holding her down while this other girl beats the fuck out of her. Then he begins to punch her in the stomach over and over again, wherein she lost a kidney, half her ribs, fractured pelvis and is just a jarbled mess of scar tissue from an accident they were in together years ago calling her a worthless stretched mark cripple. This poor girl comes to me absolutely unable to control just her pure fucking anguish let alone her grief for her children.

Sometimes things are about perspective. I tell myself things are so much worse for much better people then me.
 

wickedj51_foh

shitlord
0
0
Chaotic said:
As an aside. I had a lady today that was trying to take her kids home (3 and 5) she is 25. Her ex husband shows up with his new girlfriend (whom have been sending porno videos of themselves in an attempt to hurt our original lady that she"s brushed off) I guess this infuriated them. He ends up holding her down while this other girl beats the fuck out of her. Then he begins to punch her in the stomach over and over again, wherein she lost a kidney, half her ribs, fractured pelvis and is just a jarbled mess of scar tissue from an accident they were in together years ago calling her a worthless stretched mark cripple. This poor girl comes to me absolutely unable to control just her pure fucking anguish let alone her grief for her children.
What?