Making a Murderer (Netflix) - New info

For me, it was interesting watching the appeal battle because I simultaneously believe these two things:

1. I believe that Dassey was, at the very least, coerced into giving false or misleading testimony. I go back and forth about whether he was actually voluntarily involved, but I think that the fact that he was convicted of life in prison based solely on very dodgy testimony and exactly 0 physical evidence either tying him to the murder or verifying his version of events is a travesty of justice.

2. I firmly believe in Federalism as a concept and really dislike the federal government sticking its nose into state business.

Ultimately, I still believe that the Wisconsin courts got this unjustifiably wrong for Dassey, but it was still interesting to watch the battle.

Lanx said:

he was convicted b/c the story they coerced out of him was so egregious the jury decided to throw the book at this mentally handicapped boy.

you rapped her!

then you killed her!

then you chopped her up!

then you burned her!

that's why no matter the opportunity i'll never move to a super redneck, super dumb place, b/c if you get framed for murder, you're being looked at by a "jury of your peers", dumb peers

Click to expand...

My children will be raised to never answer a police question without me present. They will be raised to respect law enforcement, to go to them for safety, but to never answer any questions after I saw this show.

Breakdown said:

My children will be raised to never answer a police question without me present. They will be raised to respect law enforcement, to go to them for safety, but to never answer any questions after I saw this show.

Click to expand...

The kid is borderline mentally retarded. That shit is fucked up and should've never been admissable. That said, dude got his dick wet in that girl.

Noodleface said:

This season perfectly illustrated why this should've been a one season mini series

Click to expand...

Shouldn't be over until Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey are out of jail, and everyone involved in putting them there in the first place needs their shit stomped in hard.

Sorry bud. They are guilty. I know it's hard to imagine that a documentary could be so one sided

If I ever get put on trial I hope Noodle isn't on my jury. He doesn't believe in reasonable doubt at all!

You'd probably get a hung jury with me on there

OJ is guilty as fuck but it wasnt proven in court. We all know it. Doesnt mean he should be in Jail. These guys are the outliers. For Every Avery and OJ there are millions of others that the law should properly apply and people believe in the core tenants of the legal system, Innocent until proven guilty. Guilty or not, a whole case on what should be an inadmissible confession is a sham.

Noodle is sounding like the Pussy Hats that dont require a burden of proof on Prosecution. He will make for a great soy farmer at the faggot commune.

I still is crazy to me that it is possible to convict two different people for the same murder while arguing that the murder took place in contradictory manners for each man.

And that the confession was so shaky as to be unusable in one of the trials but be the sole evidence used to convict in the other.

Breakdown said:

OJ is guilty as fuck but it wasnt proven in court. We all know it. Doesnt mean he should be in Jail. These guys are the outliers. For Every Avery and OJ there are millions of others that the law should properly apply and people believe in the core tenants of the legal system, Innocent until proven guilty. Guilty or not, a whole case on what should be an inadmissible confession is a sham.

Noodle is sounding like the Pussy Hats that dont require a burden of proof on Prosecution. He will make for a great soy farmer at the faggot commune.

Click to expand...

OJs trial was definitely a sham, prosecutor fucked up. Not even remotely the same thing as Avery's case. Martha was outclassed.

Either way they both belonged in jail. I take issue with dasseys confession of course.

You already know what my opinion of him is. How could you look at that evidence and buy it and was an accident... Or... LMAO...an owl??