Monsters and Memories (Project_N) - Old School Indie MMO
- Thread starter Flobee
- Start date
Burns
Avatar of War Slayer
- 8,872
- 17,233
Human and Ogres are the only races I really like and the size of ogres look like they are going to continually have the same clipping and access problems that EQ had (so wouldn't play ogre until better shrink options/potions). I think the whole too dark to play unless you want to clutter up an already limited inventory with light bullshit is retarded. If I was on the fence about playing this game, the night bullshit without the current gamma slider would be the deal breaker.
Edit: Even with the gamma slider maxed on a Human, you cant really see shit in Wyrmsbane or some of the outside zones (FP and one of the Elf areas, I think). I avoided underground on my first character because I heard it was dark, didn't have money for a lantern, and inventory/weight was extremely limited be be carrying around extra logs for torches when I need them all for camp fires.
Edit: Even with the gamma slider maxed on a Human, you cant really see shit in Wyrmsbane or some of the outside zones (FP and one of the Elf areas, I think). I avoided underground on my first character because I heard it was dark, didn't have money for a lantern, and inventory/weight was extremely limited be be carrying around extra logs for torches when I need them all for camp fires.
Last edited:
Kirun
Buzzfeed Editor
- 21,130
- 18,155
That argument assumes the problem is player choice instead of bad constraint design. If 80% of players all land on the same race-trait combo, that's not evidence that a point system failed, it's evidence that the traits themselves aren't balanced or interesting enough. Locking power behind race is just a blunt instrument to paper over that.
Hard racial bonuses don’t actually "spread" diversity in any meaningful way - they just predetermine it. You don't get organic variety, you get spreadsheet-mandated race/class pairings where everyone already knows what the "right" answer is. Seeing 80% Ogre Warriors isn't healthier than seeing 80% Deep Elf whatever. It's the same outcome with less flexibility and more dead races.
A point-based system lets you tune traits directly instead of pretending race identity is doing the work. If something becomes overrepresented, you adjust costs, add competing options, or introduce situational strengths. That's actual balancing. Static racial stats just freeze the meta forever and call it diversity because the models look different.
And "who cares if no one plays Ogres" cuts both ways - why is the solution forcing people into them with stats instead of making Ogres appealing through visuals, lore, animations, or unique flavor that isn't raw throughput?
The goal shouldn't be to spread players out by force. It should be to give them real choices with real tradeoffs and let race be an identity decision, not a math problem you solve once and never revisit.
Players who just "want pretty pixels" are going to play whatever race they find most aesthetically pleasing no matter what traits you do/don't offer. This option at least gives the min-maxers out there an aesthetic choice as well, without being forced into the 4 "mandated" races.
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 12,370
- 6,880
If your homogenization of racial bonuses leads to players relying on aesthetics only for race selection, 80% of the choices made will be for 20% of the options. You need competitive desire to outweigh aesthetic preferences. Not force. If you don’t have this desire, go ‘gimp’ yourself for aesthetics. But if the carrot isn’t there
, people won’t willingly accept the stick.
Whether or not racial variety is ‘organic’ is irrelevant to the conceit of the game world, which should be paramount in this game. Theres plenty of board-room flattened Trion McRPG slop out there already.
Last edited:
- 1
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 12,370
- 6,880
TJT
Mr. Poopybutthole
- 46,327
- 126,410
Ogres are cool. When I finally played an Ogre Shaman during a TLP it was absolutely wild that getting hit by stuff had zero effect on your casting. I had played Dark Elf all through EQ.
Presuming every single person plays min max to the core is kinda dumb anyway. Even if minmaxing is generally more prevalent.
- 1
Hekotat
FoH nuclear response team
- 12,992
- 13,203
Just in general, I see a lot of them running around. I saw one with an arrow quiver on his back (First time I've seen one) and it was ridiculously massive and made me want to play an Ogre Archer.
Female ogre warriors look sick.
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 12,370
- 6,880
There’s 7 races so far and not even 10% of players are choosing Ogre, and the pretty races aren’t even in yet. It’s not like EQ either where Ogre only had 3 class options and a racial xp penalty.
Hekotat
FoH nuclear response team
- 12,992
- 13,203
Quaid
Trump's Staff
- 12,370
- 6,880
Honestly that's pretty good for an "ugly and huge" race. I expect it'll trend upwards a touch. Their racial warstomp has some potential for meta cheesyness, and while they toned down the stats, they are still quite good for melee or tank classes. Ogre monks having another stun is pretty sick.
Muligan
Trakanon Raider
- 3,287
- 939
Have they revealed or tested any of the end game? I can’t remember but did EQ show any of Naggy or Vox in their testing? Only thing I remember in the last phase was some kind of GM event but that’s it. We didn’t really have a lot of developed, raiding guilds at that point I guess…
Kirun
Buzzfeed Editor
- 21,130
- 18,155
This is still built on the assumption that aesthetics automatically dominate once you remove hard power locks, and that simply isn't borne out unless the system itself is shallow. Players don't choose purely on looks when meaningful tradeoffs exist - they'll choose based on expression. If 80% of players collapse into 20% of options, that's not because aesthetics "won," it's because the remaining 80% of options aren't offering compelling identities, mechanics, or situational advantages.
You're also framing "competitive desire" as something that can only be created by rigid racial power hierarchies. That's backwards. Competitive desire comes from optimization within constraints, not from being told at character creation that you picked wrong forever. A point-based or modular system doesn't remove the carrot, it makes the carrot contextual. You still sacrifice something to gain something else. You're just not forced to accept a permanent gimp because you liked the way your character looked.
As for "go gimp yourself for aesthetics," that's exactly the problem people are pushing back against. That philosophy doesn't deepen the world. It just externalizes bad design onto the player and calls it roleplay. A world feels coherent when choices make sense in-universe and in gameplay, not when players are punished for wanting their character to look a certain way.
And invoking "board-room flattened slop" misses the mark. Modular systems aren't inherently corporate or flattened, they're tools. What makes modern RPGs feel soulless isn't flexibility, it's the lack of meaningful friction and consequence. You can have strong world conceit and player agency at the same time. Hard racial stat locks don't protect the soul of a game, they just fossilize one interpretation of it and pretend that's depth.
If the only thing holding racial diversity together is forcing competitive players to eat aesthetic penalties, then the diversity was never real to begin with. It was just enforced symmetry dressed up as worldbuilding.
Valorath
Vyemm Raider
- 1,345
- 2,671
What level of trade off are we willing to accept? I think racial differences are important and should be both meaningful and impactful. What is the point otherwise?
was the cheeseburger photo earlier a “you can get it your way at Wendy’s” comment? Make your own burger, make your own MMO?
was the cheeseburger photo earlier a “you can get it your way at Wendy’s” comment? Make your own burger, make your own MMO?
- 1
Grim1
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 4,943
- 6,958
I was fine with the original EQ "vision" (oops) that had racial stat differences, good and EVIL, harsh death penalties, xp penalties for ogres, another xp group penalty for being a SK, faction penalties, etc. I even would be fine with boons and penalties for whatever deity you pick. I like all that stuff. The fatties had to farm that shrink wand or whatever it was just to get into small areas or bribe a shammy iirc.
It causes lots of headaches for the devs, i know. And lots of confusion / drama with the playerbase. But that just makes it better. Not being sure if that guard was going to stomp me or not because I forgot to con it kept me engaged. I even liked farming dwarves for giant faction, even when it got a little tedious. Crushing those little fuckers was endless fun.
it gives the game character and creates all kinds of niche power / weakness situation in content that gets very boring very fast if everyone is the same.
All these little bitches that can't stand that an Ogre has more natrual strength and durability than a Gnome really fucked every modern game that could have been much better if the devs hadn't folded.