Monsters and Memories (Project_N) - Old School Indie MMO

GuardianX

Perpetually Pessimistic
<Bronze Donator>
8,320
21,562
I feel bad but not bad... chilling in the orc caves... at a T section to a dead end... and this bard just comes though and takes everything, passing me on the way in and out...

Then abandons the pull and trains everything on me... so I petition.

Bards cant just do whatever they want "because swarm kiting is how we solo" - as a SK if I fear kite ish and fear stuff into other stuff and it trains someone, I am on the hook for that not controlling my mobs etc.

I'm outta the loop on this, got a bard to 53 in the beta and haven't touched it in EA.

Napkin math tells me that anything more than 4 mobs and you aren't KILLING them more-so than holding them in reserve so you can kill them later and not have to pull again (AKA zone disruption).

Charm doesn't work in the sense that the horde will attack your charm, the only purpose in my mind is to dot things up and cycle through 3-4 mobs as you dot them up while keeping your movespeed up too.
 

Siliconemelons

Ssraeszha Raider
15,906
25,503
I'm outta the loop on this, got a bard to 53 in the beta and haven't touched it in EA.

Napkin math tells me that anything more than 4 mobs and you aren't KILLING them more-so than holding them in reserve so you can kill them later and not have to pull again (AKA zone disruption).

Charm doesn't work in the sense that the horde will attack your charm, the only purpose in my mind is to dot things up and cycle through 3-4 mobs as you dot them up while keeping your movespeed up too.

Yeah I do not know what they are doing other than being really big pains in the butt, while being extremely entitled and arrogant bout it. I have exp it, but also seen it in ooc etc. where essentially "if I can pull it, and eventually kill it, that ALL is my camp" - and not just "I will agro it all as it repops" but "you cannot have any of the repops, they are mine, the entire area is mine, DONT BE in the area, bc well then if u get trained thats your fault" etc etc

Doing swarm kiting where there is ANYONE else around, should increase the risk exponentially, due to the interaction with others - like in my case, they are swarming...for whatever reason in a CAVE SYSTEM... and I am sitting in the path leading to a T intersection dead end... once they saw me they should have had to stop, and turn around (yes, INTO their train) rather than run their mobs over me in, then out... this is a RISK you take doing that methodology.

There is innate shared social agro while fighting mobs - my pet can be off tanking (yeah a lt blue or green lol) and I will be hitting the one I am tanking, if I use reave and stuff, the one on my pet can turn to me because of the damage I am doing to the one I am on etc. - doing so as a bard train washes over you- can pull off mobs that you are not "directly interacting with" etc. thus, the bard is not controlling his mobs etc.

But to "them" the bards, this is 100% your fault, you should not be there, you trained yourself, YOU disrupted their pull, you were "Warned" by even just seeing a bard, you should just up and run away because this land is all theirs now!

Perhaps this is really just bad community luck on my side in only being around apparently the "bad" ones... there was one bard LFG in BTB when I was there and i was like "I thought bards just swarmed" - that was it...I didn't infer anything and he said "I guess I am not an asshole bard" lol even they know...
 

Noodleface

A Mod Real Quick
40,697
20,806
Yeah I do not know what they are doing other than being really big pains in the butt, while being extremely entitled and arrogant bout it. I have exp it, but also seen it in ooc etc. where essentially "if I can pull it, and eventually kill it, that ALL is my camp" - and not just "I will agro it all as it repops" but "you cannot have any of the repops, they are mine, the entire area is mine, DONT BE in the area, bc well then if u get trained thats your fault" etc etc

Doing swarm kiting where there is ANYONE else around, should increase the risk exponentially, due to the interaction with others - like in my case, they are swarming...for whatever reason in a CAVE SYSTEM... and I am sitting in the path leading to a T intersection dead end... once they saw me they should have had to stop, and turn around (yes, INTO their train) rather than run their mobs over me in, then out... this is a RISK you take doing that methodology.

There is innate shared social agro while fighting mobs - my pet can be off tanking (yeah a lt blue or green lol) and I will be hitting the one I am tanking, if I use reave and stuff, the one on my pet can turn to me because of the damage I am doing to the one I am on etc. - doing so as a bard train washes over you- can pull off mobs that you are not "directly interacting with" etc. thus, the bard is not controlling his mobs etc.

But to "them" the bards, this is 100% your fault, you should not be there, you trained yourself, YOU disrupted their pull, you were "Warned" by even just seeing a bard, you should just up and run away because this land is all theirs now!

Perhaps this is really just bad community luck on my side in only being around apparently the "bad" ones... there was one bard LFG in BTB when I was there and i was like "I thought bards just swarmed" - that was it...I didn't infer anything and he said "I guess I am not an asshole bard" lol even they know...
I've had bad luck with people just thinking I'm not even a real person or something because I'm holding a camp solo. I thought maybe it would be a low level syndrome, aka people don't really know social etiquette but it's continued still into the upper 30s.

Had people just setup camp right next to me, sometimes literally right on me, and start pulling my mobs. I haven't petitioned yet, I simply just start pulling like crazy to let them know yeah you won't get shit here bucko. A few times I just let people in ooc know they're pieces of shit
 

Siliconemelons

Ssraeszha Raider
15,906
25,503
I decided to be “that guy” sorry…

I got petitioned 3 times in EA - each time it was because the petitioning party didnt understand “the rules” and each time the GM was like “sorry…ill talk to them”

So, I figure, education by way of GM is better than me saying in tells or ooc and sperging out… that is reserved for here! (Sorry)
 

Blazin

Creative Title
<Nazi Janitors>
7,697
38,096
Yeah I do not know what they are doing other than being really big pains in the butt, while being extremely entitled and arrogant bout it. I have exp it, but also seen it in ooc etc. where essentially "if I can pull it, and eventually kill it, that ALL is my camp" - and not just "I will agro it all as it repops" but "you cannot have any of the repops, they are mine, the entire area is mine, DONT BE in the area, bc well then if u get trained thats your fault" etc etc

Doing swarm kiting where there is ANYONE else around, should increase the risk exponentially, due to the interaction with others - like in my case, they are swarming...for whatever reason in a CAVE SYSTEM... and I am sitting in the path leading to a T intersection dead end... once they saw me they should have had to stop, and turn around (yes, INTO their train) rather than run their mobs over me in, then out... this is a RISK you take doing that methodology.

There is innate shared social agro while fighting mobs - my pet can be off tanking (yeah a lt blue or green lol) and I will be hitting the one I am tanking, if I use reave and stuff, the one on my pet can turn to me because of the damage I am doing to the one I am on etc. - doing so as a bard train washes over you- can pull off mobs that you are not "directly interacting with" etc. thus, the bard is not controlling his mobs etc.

But to "them" the bards, this is 100% your fault, you should not be there, you trained yourself, YOU disrupted their pull, you were "Warned" by even just seeing a bard, you should just up and run away because this land is all theirs now!

Perhaps this is really just bad community luck on my side in only being around apparently the "bad" ones... there was one bard LFG in BTB when I was there and i was like "I thought bards just swarmed" - that was it...I didn't infer anything and he said "I guess I am not an asshole bard" lol even they know...
Where you in BB? If so they were likely exploiting, there is a ramp in there that npcs can't path to they will go all the way around a bard could easily manage the swarm just moving back and forth across that ramp
 

GuardianX

Perpetually Pessimistic
<Bronze Donator>
8,320
21,562
Where you in BB? If so they were likely exploiting, there is a ramp in there that npcs can't path to they will go all the way around a bard could easily manage the swarm just moving back and forth across that ramp

Why swarm though, is it just as I thought, mob control?

You can't AE damage like you could in EQ.

Reverse kiting works one time really and only in a 1:1, all the other mobs will ignore it after the 1st break really.
 

Noodleface

A Mod Real Quick
40,697
20,806
I decided to be “that guy” sorry…

I got petitioned 3 times in EA - each time it was because the petitioning party didnt understand “the rules” and each time the GM was like “sorry…ill talk to them”

So, I figure, education by way of GM is better than me saying in tells or ooc and sperging out… that is reserved for here! (Sorry)
Hand in your gun and badge to one of the guild officers and hit the road!!

Just kidding really. I have petitioned once because a dude feign deathed on me twice and killed me. First time I thought maybe it was an accident but second time right after I figured it was intentional
 

Siliconemelons

Ssraeszha Raider
15,906
25,503
Where you in BB? If so they were likely exploiting, there is a ramp in there that npcs can't path to they will go all the way around a bard could easily manage the swarm just moving back and forth across that ramp

No I was in the orc caves in KB.

I know where your talking about in BTB, surprised they haven’t fixed it…annoying for my pet to always run around the entire darn zone because of that