Rabbit_Games
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 3,138
- 6,463
Saw this the other day
I can't remember if we've discussed it here, but there was one of these conversations popping off around the Internet which posed the following dilemma:
"There are two buttons: red and green. If everyone pushes the green button, everyone lives. If anybody pushes the red button, only the people who pushed the red button will live. Which button do you press?"
I really had it out with my family (extended family included, it was the holidays) over this one. Every one of them said they'd push the green button. I said not only would I push the red button, I would go out of my way to make sure they did, too. They said I was evil. Then I proved that no, they were all evil. My logic is very simple:
In a perfect world, where every human being was intelligent enough to understand the dilemma, you could maybe convince everyone to push the green button. Or, in a perfect world where every human being shared the same moral compass, you could convince everyone to push the green button. But we, obviously, do not live in a perfect world. Therefore, and without question or doubt, at least one human being IS going to push the red button. So to convince yourself to push the green button is suicide, and to convince others to push the green button is murder. Thus, evil.
Push the red fucking button.