Oh, right.
Okay, my plan basically envisions a lower case t.
--- 1
2a ---2b
--- 3
--- 4
I want to keep a noob division for brand new people since there's a good chance we're gonna pick up quite a few for next season. If we have a steady roster of 32+ guys and we've been playing for multiple seasons, your idea is probably fine, but I'd hate to toss the winner of D4 to the grinder in with guys like Hatorade and Xannder right away. This gives the bottom 2 a straight linear progression, while making d2 basically a 16 man division instead of 8.
4 feeds into 3, 3 demotes/promotes into 4 and 2a/b (the number of promotes would need to be decided for sure), and 2a and b both feed into 1. In addition to that, we'll just sort 2a and 2b by record, and odd numbers will go into A, and evens will go into B, this should mix up that division pretty well. 1 will get 4 guys of churn every season, 3 will get at least 4 guys of churn every season, and 4, although not seeing as much churn, will be filled out with tier 3 teams from the top guys, enabling those in d4 to learn the game, not get bashed to death, and still see a lot of different players.
I like your idea, if everyone we had was at a baseline level, but I know for a fact we're gonna get guys into this league in 2 weeks here with less than 50 hours in the game. Think about how much you knew 50 hours into this thing -- it's a long climb to even understanding how assists work, honestly.