The poll has closed, so it's time to render a decision on this matter. First, I'll go over the various factors here.
-A poll of the people, as requested by Kegkilla. The results of the poll was 122 - 81 in favor of keeping the ban. That's a significant margin with a turnout good enough to get a good idea of what people think. By a 20pt margin, the users who cared enough to vote in this poll are in favor of Keg staying banned.
-What does amod think of the situation? The Amod team is in favor of the ban staying. They were emphatic on this point.
-Was there any new evidence revealed in this thread? Yes. It was revealed that the initial assumption that precipitated this thread's creation was false: Suineg has not forgiven Keg for what he did, contrary to many reports I had seen. Also there is still solid (though not concrete) evidence that Keg did indeed give OlScratch the idea to go after Suineg, and it is undisputed by either party that Keg knew about the plot and said nothing to Suineg about it until after the fact. If either 1 of these conditions are true, it is sufficient evidence to show that the original reason for banning Keg is still valid.
-Within 1 day, Keg was already saying in Discord that he had no intention of listening to the results of this poll, or gives 2 shits about whether this community thinks he should be gone. He's going to continue to make alts in an effort to circumvent his legitimate ban (Keg is loveboat here):
View attachment 319415
View attachment 319417
-What do I think of the situation? I think Keg was on his best behavior and putting on an act while posting as China Bat Soup. Observing his posts in discord after the facade had dropped revealed the same old Keg, a duplicitous liar trying to manipulate everyone into getting what he wants and breaking his word at the first opportunity.
Putting all of this together, it is my decision that Kegkilla will remain banned. In perpetuity.
Thank you to all who participated in this poll and this thread, you were a great help in my decision making process.