True Detective

Maester Chuk_sl said:

how many 8 year olds make their dolls rape one another?

Click to expand...

Rewatch the scene immediately after, and I think you'll better understand why that scene was there. Cohle describes how he thinks his daughter was spared, dying a happy child instead of growing up in the 'thresher' that is life, and being damaged.

TheBeagle_sl said:

Surely there can be a middle ground where people can feel a bit let down with the finale while also not having participated in the wild theory crafting. I mean seriously, it's easy to say now the series was just "Brokeback Bayou" - a tale of man love, betrayal, redemption, and child rape. But fuck man, without Carcosa, the Yellow King, and the mystery surrounding it all, the series wouldn't have hooked us all in. Some of us feel the mystery was given short shrift in the finale, that's all.

Click to expand...

The mythology was neat, but I figured most people were attracted to the different philosophical theories presented by Rust.

I do think the case and resolution has a lot more depth and closure than most people are giving credit for, however. I mean, the show started with the investigation of Dora Lange, and that's exactly what they solved.

I also really like Errol's place in the series, and don't think people are giving him enough credit for how he ties in to the entire story. As weird as it may sound - he was also a victim. Raised in a fucked up abusive occultist family that sacrificed kids to some secretive mythos.

"You know what they did to me? What I would do to all the sons and daughters of man."

He is precisely the way he is, because he was raised in a fucked up family. The sins of a father being repeated by the son. He wanted to die (ascend), in part, to get out of the ever repeating loop.

"My ascension removes me from the disc in the loop - I'm near final stage. Some mornings, I can see the infernal plane."

Now, although it wasn't completely spelled out, I also got the impression that his wife/sister was aborting/killing the 'flowers' that he planted in that disgusting room with the bathtub, bloody blankets, and dozens of air fresheners. To me this also suggested that Errol didn't want to 'loop' to continue past him.

TheBeagle_sl said:

Surely there can be a middle ground where people can feel a bit let down with the finale while also not having participated in the wild theory crafting. I mean seriously, it's easy to say now the series was just "Brokeback Bayou" - a tale of man love, betrayal, redemption, and child rape. But fuck man, without Carcosa, the Yellow King, and the mystery surrounding it all, the series wouldn't have hooked us all in. Some of us feel the mystery was given short shrift in the finale, that's all.

Click to expand...

nope, either you are a complete moron who looks at everything as a sign of something sinister or you are a total boss who knows what everything is about from the first time you see it. there is no in between on this board.

Watching this right now. Didn't have time to watch as it aired, unfortunately. I like the dual timeline so far. Avoiding most posts in here, I'll agree that theorizing is part of the fun.

ill pour out some smirnoff in your honor, comrade.

Meh. Like I said, I had it totally wrong in the beginning. I actually read parts of that short story, I was into it. It is kind of a huge letdown to me that it isn't some big, Lovecraftian mythos thing. But it is what it is, and taken for what it is outside of my own shit that I brought into it, it is really fucking good.

Sebudai_sl said:

Whatever happened to ol' Ginger, anyway?

Click to expand...

I didn't think of myself as an overly attentive viewer, but I thought it was fairly plainly spelled out that Ginger pledged a Wookie life debt to Cohle after their successful escape from the drug raid, and that even up until the day Cohle and Hart went to Errol's place he was tailing Cohle, and that Ginger was the one inside the outhouse breathing heavily, but then he ran off to the main road after hearing Hart yell about the phone (killing the dog en route) so that he could make an anonymous call to the police and get the boys some much needed backup.

i mean jeez did you even watch the show

chaos_sl said:

Meh. Like I said, I had it totally wrong in the beginning. I actually read parts of that short story, I was into it. It is kind of a huge letdown to me that it isn't some big, Lovecraftian mythos thing. But it is what it is, and taken for what it is outside of my own shit that I brought into it, it is really fucking good.

Click to expand...

I think we catch a glimpse of Cthulhu's world as Rust stares into the cosmos at the end.

ZyyzYzzy_sl said:

Jesus titty fucking Christ you are more retarded than Astro

Click to expand...

Oh, shut the fuck up, you Canadian twat. It was a stupid scene and means nothing from a metaphysical standpoint. Nic Pizzolatto borrowed everything from Lovecraft so it was probably a nod to that mythos.

ZyyzYzzy_sl said:

Jesus titty fucking Christ you are more retarded than Astro

Click to expand...

It's true. Series is over, every retarded half-assed theory it could come up with was totally off base, still continues to throw shit at the wall.

Where they look up at the stars and Marty says, "I don't know Rust, there sure is a lot of darkness up there." And Rust replies, "I think the light is winning." Which ever way you look at it, you have to admit Rust was better off with a little optimism.

Araysar_sl said:

It actually has nothing to do with Cthulhu, its a great scene, it means a ton, (as alluded to in last 10 minutes of finale).

So you're basically wrong on everything.

Click to expand...

It means jack shit. Is it supposed to symbolize his newfound spirituality or light defeating dark? Give me a fucking break. He was telepathically guided through the compound and saw a vortex in the sky. It's the complete opposite of profound.