War Dogs PvPvP 100 Person Tactical Shooter

Sludig

Sludig

Potato del Grande
12,274
13,404
Xevy said:
There's some pretty easy counters to a lot of the bullshit:

-GL's do reduced damage to lower body and/or you can't pinpoint shoot them. They should lob more than they do, and maybe lose damage at distance. They need to be the anti-infantry RPG equivalent for battlefield fights and fortified positions. Not cheap 1-shot ordinance.
-Vehicles unlock as score progresses like the APC.
-Vehicles have restrictions on amount/user cooldown that decreases as score goes up so you can spam vehicles when it's closer to end game. No tanks/Havocs off the rip.
-RPG does only anti vehicle damage but has a huge projectile hit box so you can blast vehicles, but can't spam infantry. RPG direct hits doing 35 damage guaranteed on infantry probably fine for rez cleanups and window peakers after they're dinged up.
-BMR/FAL I'm not sure about. BMR should just have a headshot modifier, but it's still easy to 1-2 tap heads. But 2-3 body shots killing is dumb. FAL is 3 shot full auto and that's pretty dumb. Maybe major damage falloff for FAL and minimum distance for BMR.
-Reduce the weight of anti vehicle shit and MINIMALLY make RPG shells 2x1 slots, not 3x1. The fucking MAWS is 2x1.
-Mortars can't triple spam. That's a no brainer. They could easily remove the RNG built in to counter this.
-HP Ammo I'm unsure on. It's definitely a strategy, but being able to kill 10 people in a 30 round MP5 HP mag is absurd. Probably just make it do more to armor, slightly less than fmj, with a bonus to limbs. The complete opposite of AP. Having a +30% damage bonus vs FMJ and 30% penalty on armor makes it worth it if you're legging still, but not nearly triple damage.
-Free kits that are free, I'm SICK of seeing like 5 dead fully naked guys in a crucial battle because they're trying to free kit up. These fuckers can't drop 300 dollars on a free gun, bag, and two mags with bandages. Wasting defibs and smokes to rez them in an absolute kick in the dick.
-One Drill per Fob. Limited pull time as I think with enough logi currently with fuel pallets you can basically infinitely suck it. Also maybe make Drills unlocked based on scores/game progression. The Tower system was supposed to do this but outside the beta and day 1/2 I don't think ANYONE has ever free tower sucked in the hundred games I've played. It just doesn't happen.
-Overall outside CERTAIN vehicles, I think most shit should do reduced damage to infantry and increased damage to vehicles/buildings. I don't want chopper cucks farming us for less than the cost of my armor and gun. Beefier RPG changes would help, but they gotta do one or the other.
-FOBs need another use. Drills are fine if toned down, but kind of annoying when the Tower system exists. They need a way to resupply troops or guarantee respawns, especially with the changes to parachutes coming where pilots have to land. The APC is nice, but it's fodder for rocket choppers unless you build a shell FOB around it. Even then they don't have to kill it if they camp it.

Basically they need to horn in the bullshit while tailoring niches to niches. Vehicles should be made for fighting vehicles and provide a presence, but they can't be better, cheaper, stronger, faster infantry with limited weaknesses. SMG's should be rewarded for <10m engagements and quick movement, but not shooting my toes off at 45m in 3 bullets. AR's should be the king of mid range, but shouldn't out dps an smg with hipfire like the M4 often does. Snipers are good early wipe, but shit later unless it's the 50 cal. I'm not sure if it's balanced or not, maybe it should do 90% damage to 2 armors instead of instakill and obviously ALWAYS 1 shot headshot. Shotguns work pretty well if you can get flesh shots and are cheap and effective. LMG's are disgusting with bipods and insane recoil if not crouched otherwise and even then pretty rough, SAW especially. PKM you can tap fire because it's shooting fucking sniper rounds. FOB's should be useful, but not the end game. I'm not trying to dodge mortars and helis for 45 minutes while drill A-C all recycle cooldowns. Hot Zone needs to be more required. Too many people just go for kills where they can get them, stale fights from HZ areas from 15 minutes ago, Bob farming, etc.

They got the parts they just need to smooth the edges and grease the right wheels.
Click to expand...
Yeap I brought up the being able to purchase supplies from the fob via ammo or maybe mechanical supplies. Otherwise 99% of the time coordinating a resupply is slower than just looting or respawning and coming back.

The apc I don't think was meant to really just always sit parked in rear fob. It's a big target but obviously has good synergy and power of it can help a blob push and start supported with a tank or if they ever add someone l don't more midsize vehicles.
 
Sludig

Sludig

Potato del Grande
12,274
13,404
Mao said:
Cheats are also back today. Seeing the full auto SVD again. I guess its in response to the GL Helos, cause if I was a cheater I'd fire up the old tools to just nuke GL Helos.

The problem with the game is I don't think they can balance it honestly. When it works, its fun, and that when it works is why I'm still slamming my dick in the door jam over and over, but...

I don't see how they balance it well with vehicles and bases. Attack and GL helos are just ridiculous. The map is small enough that they can fly over, mostly wipe a base of people and AA weapons, then fly back to rearm and be back by the time we've gotten everyone rezzed and back up again. The maps honestly should be bigger. I think that would change a lot of maps were bigger and people had more ground to cover with helos so they couldn't just do a lazy circuit around the CZ and knock everything down, land, rearm, return, repeat.

Also, bigger maps would put some stuff out of range of mortars more.

Bases are also a problem. How do you make them defensively good, but not overpowered? As it is they are too easy to crack, especially if the enemy has any coordination. Last three games are good examples. GL helo's in pairs. If something shoots at 1, the other snuffs it out. CWIS, Talons etc. Last game was 2 GL Helos and Rocket Helo following an upgunned humvee. It was the start of the match. We'd just gotten the FOB placed :D So your idea of timing unlocks might help. An 'escalation' timer that starts it with a meeting skirmish and as time goes by the stakes upgrade and we get more and more toys. There might be a good playable solution there, but I don't really know if the devs are interested in that. My impression is... not really.

The problem I see is you can individually balance a lot of this shit, but its way tougher to balance at scale. You can have your single helo vs a talon, or even two. Or vs a CWIS, but... when you start flying multiple Helos in one sortie and poor Bob the builder can only get up 1 Talon and maybe a CWIS before they arrive? Yeah, he's fucked. If you make the base stronger and requiring great effort to crack, we're just going to see tonnes of base spam. We'll optimize the fun out of anything :D

Anyway its late and I'm tired. I'm gonna go sleep and see if I have more rational thoughts tomorrow :D
Click to expand...
I think map already plenty big, it's a long enough drive if you don't get griefed on the way. The control zone could use a 20% increase in size, would put a carrier of large buildings in the zone that currently are on the outskirts.

Delay timer I agree with though one of the strongest options is base little bird with the gl. Not sure if time locking the gun would be a good option, otherwise circles back to my previous post it's always going to be absurd or near useless. Forget cost, but even at 10k just means the guys rolling in 3 million will be the only users.
 
Mao

Mao

Trakanon Raider
767
1,793
Sludig said:
I think map already plenty big, it's a long enough drive if you don't get griefed on the way. The control zone could use a 20% increase in size, would put a carrier of large buildings in the zone that currently are on the outskirts.

Delay timer I agree with though one of the strongest options is base little bird with the gl. Not sure if time locking the gun would be a good option, otherwise circles back to my previous post it's always going to be absurd or near useless. Forget cost, but even at 10k just means the guys rolling in 3 million will be the only users.
Click to expand...
This is more what I meant. Bigger control zone. So much of the map is rather wasted. If you notice they kinda hide this it seems by changing the center of the CZ on different iterations of the same map.

The problem with attack Helo's is how do you balance them properly? If you make them easier to kill, which in my opinion they need to be, you make it so only skilled pilots can fly them successfully locking the majority of people out. If you make it so they are easier to fly, you make skilled pilots damn near unkillable which makes the game pretty much unfun for anyone else. The game design is much more casual than skill based, so I don't see them nerfing helicopter survivability in any significantly meaningful way, other than perhaps the Havok being able to 1v1 a CWIS and win. Its... dumb.

This is the problem I have with vehicles in general. To make them worthwhile they have to be more powerful, and it can easily let 1 or 2 people have outsized power for their numbers. 1 or 2 people with vehicles is a lil spice to the mix and makes the game more interesting, but how do you do that balance without making spamming vehicles game breaking? Ground based vehicles at least have the issue of LOS and having to conform to terrain. Having the run and gun Humvee sucks, but you can sorta deal with it. Spamming heli's you have none of that. They have free range and LOS and if you don't get them with your first volley of AA, you're prolly not going to live long enough to get another chance.

The simple answer for me is move the GL to a support weapon slot, and make all support weapons unable to be fired from helo's. I'd also make the pilot unable to wear T4 armor. Especially if they do the viewport vision nerf on the T4 helmet. It would have no effect on pilots in 3d person. Let the passengers carry all the armor, just disable support weapons in the bird and make the pilot wear light armor only. Would do a bit to give people on the ground some options and make the pilot actually care about taking ground fire. Which, in real life, they get real anxious about :D
 
gauze

gauze

Molten Core Raider
1,246
490
Sludig said:
GL probably should go. You don't see it a lot in games imo because it's too hard to balance having 6 he rounds on hand fast unless they need to be almost unusable small radius, damage, etc. Should replace with single shot break action, or maybe try just a pretty long refire delay.
Click to expand...

I was thinking about it on a morning poop. They've openly stated that they want to add more ammunition types to the game. But GL having two main damage rounds would go so far. Could easily make 20mm HE rounds that would essentially require a direct hit to kill a player, but the explosive damage is effective against structures and vehicles. I think there is a mechanic there, similar to putting hedgehogs and bremmers next to your structures to absorb damage.

Then add HE-Frag. Direct hits can kill lower armor targets but the damage mostly comes from a scatter shot // rng behaviour. Need more than one HE-Frag to reliably kill infantry in a field, but a closed room or tight corridor incredibly dangerous. Dropping 10/20/30 damage to a bunch of people on an open field with a frag round to dunking into a window, the chaotic nature sounds like a fun time.


And as far as the CIWS and AA. If you could move the command post of the CIWS anywhere within the fob zone. I think a lot of the problems go away. If you have a CIWS on wheels essentially, problems start to melt away abit. Even increasing small arms damage through the canopy, and it doesn't even have to be at a murder rate.. just enough where they would at least consider coming in with armor.

And while I didn't consider t4 helmet and third person. I think it'd be pretty funny if they added third person being effected by t4. If that happens, then they are real fucking gamers. While I've yet to see it, there is a bit of talk regarding fog and droplets accumulate on the visor of the T4 helm and have heard talks of the same with vehicles. While I could be absolutely wrong and we will definitely see.. but people have also said it extends to vehicles and gives me the vibe that the rain will be anti-vehicle mechanic but not a no vehicles. Makes me think of Arc and the storm effect, the armorless fights in a game where youre always fighting with armor was a good fucking time.
 
Last edited:
Sludig

Sludig

Potato del Grande
12,274
13,404
gauze said:
I was thinking about it on a morning poop. They've openly stated that they want to add more ammunition types to the game. But GL having two main damage rounds would go so far. Could easily make 20mm HE rounds that would essentially require a direct hit to kill a player, but the explosive damage is effective against structures and vehicles. I think there is a mechanic there, similar to putting hedgehogs and bremmers next to your structures to absorb damage.

Then add HE-Frag. Direct hits can kill lower armor targets but the damage mostly comes from a scatter shot // rng behaviour. Need more than one HE-Frag to reliably kill infantry in a field, but a closed room or tight corridor incredibly dangerous. Dropping 10/20/30 damage to a bunch of people on an open field with a frag round to dunking into a window, the chaotic nature sounds like a fun time.


And as far as the CIWS and AA. If you could move the command post of the CIWS anywhere within the fob zone. I think a lot of the problems go away. If you have a CIWS on wheels essentially, problems start to melt away abit.
Click to expand...
Lol even better with that last idea, imagine if that control could operate multiple at once somehow, like choose ones pov, and the other tracks to roughly that point of aim. If it's into a building oh well. Still give you some awesome battle star point defence scenes. I've had a number of times where the base getting pounded but no one at the controls. Too scared to get shot up or the helps appeared too fast so it's a suicide run to get to the station. If they are orbiting a tower usually too low or break los too quick for stinger.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.