It wasn't a critique. A critique would sound something like, "Your buddy's guild is shit." What I said was 6/10H isn't decent progression. Out of curiosity I looked up roughly where a 6/10H guild could expect to fall in the grand scheme of "progression." For your information there are approximately 20,000 guilds in the world that have gotten farther than 6 bosses in BRF.
But you're right; I shouldn't have bothered replying. Some fit of madness came over me, and I thought this guy might appreciate knowing that a recruitment post for a guild like his buddy's would be much better framed as casual, minivan friendly, or whatever else you want to call it besides "semi-casual" and "decently progressed." As someone who considers themselves casual (I raid 3 hours a week, not 8), I would rather wash dishes for 8 hours a week than be stuck at 6/10 in a raid that I can PUG (and one shot) 10/10 in 2.5 hours.