Runnen
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 2,086
- 5,299
- 3
Alien: Earth
- Thread starter Goatface
- Start date
Rajaah
Honorable Member
- 14,088
- 20,071
Figured out why this show doesn't feel big or important. I've never once felt like Earth is in any kind of peril from the Xenomorph menaces. The characters all seem pretty unconcerned (most of them being androids doesn't help) and while everything has been confined to the wrecked ship, I don't remember there being much tension about the aliens getting out. All the tension is between the corporations and which one will get to weaponize them first / win the android race.
Bald Brah
Trakanon Raider
- 1,980
- 2,334
I mean you know earth wins since this is a prequel and its not a hive world later.
To me this show is an interesting concept and pretty well made. It's a very watchable show. Certainly better than Andor was for me. At least this has "some" action.
I do detest the low budget sci-fi trope where aliens and high tech androids and cyborgs look exactly like regular humans. At least make them look like Robocop or Vision. It's stupid but commonplace. It was dumb in the new Battle Star Galactica and it's dumb in this. Although in this they seem to act like everyone can easily identify synths. Not sure how. You think they would at least have to have a tattoo on their forehead or something. Like a car's dash VIN.
- 1
Penance
Golden Baronet of the Realm
- 8,995
- 15,463
I mean not everything has to be world ending conflicts. Conflicts can happen between characters, corporations, and environments. We've all picked who we want to "win". Obviously Wendy has the thickest plot armor, but I'm pulling for the cybo-jogger for the lolz.
- 1
- 1
- 16,755
- 36,626
Not really, or not yet. Maybe it'll suddenly get super interesting in the last four episodes, but I'm not holding my breath.
I'm still giving it a chance just because it's my favorite IP movie wise, but I've also said since the beginning this was going to be a turd, a well polished turd my view.
Lanx
<Prior Amod>
- 71,173
- 166,988
this sounds about right, and their fallback is always to reference peter pan!
- 1
- 16,755
- 36,626
That's why I said maybe during the second or third episode that it seems like the whole damn thing is the writer's room issue. I don't even really remember what happened in the 4th episode because it was just so blase.
I just don't know what direction they're trying to take it in and it's too many cooks in the kitchen, whether it be writers or directors. I mean the show looks good, and there are various elements where I'm pretty impressed, but then it just goes off the rails and becomes retarded, and not the good kind.
nettripper
Lord Nagafen Raider
- 831
- 878
……it’s a prequel to movies that made it clear never heard or seen the alien before on earth
any movie that goes for prequels best they can do is world building and interesting takes on things
the rules are set where the starting date is here and end date is alien movie where such and such is established so then it’s how many seasons can we fit and not write ourselves into a corner
Then it comes down to the starwars question of which order do you watch things for the younger your kids generations
cause then your concern is valid as in do you want your kids shocked by the “I am your father” or they already know from letting them watch in episode order
- 1
Chanur
Shit Posting Professional
- 32,848
- 57,517
It's not like regular people would have any idea about anything the corporations didn't want them to know. It's not exactly a free world out there. Aliens on earth definitely could have been a thing and the crew of the Nostromo would have no fucking clue.
- 4
nettripper
Lord Nagafen Raider
- 831
- 878
Ok fair point
so nostromo crew can easily be kept in the dark as the rest of the general population
ash the android would truly know and wasn’t just excited to hit the alien species discovery?
aliens corpo interrogation of Ripley meeting they are just higher level management and they didn’t know?
same for Burke?
bishop same as ash?
I guess that’s the only “in the way” explanations they would need to make
I just don’t want stupid! The blatant it is going to be this way cause we own it and what we say goes so as long as they logically and properly continue and it flows and makes sense then ok
predator is still on the shit list
- 1
- 16,755
- 36,626
- 1
Chanur
Shit Posting Professional
- 32,848
- 57,517
Ash was a robot and was had programming for alien life forms. Not specifically Xenomorphs. It's why he went crazy too because his protect humans programming came into conflict with the crew expendable one.
Burke is a fucking nobody in the hierarchy. Clearly neither did any of the board because they were completely ignoring anything about Xenomorphs.
You don't know any classified info and neither does anyone else that doesn't have a need to know. Why do you think it would be any different in Alien or Aliens? They didn't even tell the Marines what they were up against. They had to use Ripley. The company sure knew to transform that moon/planet though.
- 1
- 1
- 16,755
- 36,626
Chanur
Shit Posting Professional
- 32,848
- 57,517
- 16,755
- 36,626
Well apparently she's at the stupid Neverland base, so I'm sure we're going to get more of her. I mean why wouldn't you bring your crack team of corporate commandos with you!
- 1
nettripper
Lord Nagafen Raider
- 831
- 878
Planet shake n bake colonies were a regular thing and infestation was due to Burke giving the push finally only after gaining the knowledge from ripley’s stories
None of that can be retrofitted to be “oh it was a master plan all along we always knew about the aliens and that Burke guy just happened to accelerate things before we were ready”
- 2
Chanur
Shit Posting Professional
- 32,848
- 57,517
No disagreement. We are on the same page. Burke didn't know ahead of time.
- 2