haha. at Saints row 4 romance.
What are you looking for in an rpg? "RPG" as its own genre is breaking down. MassEffect is an rpg. Red dead redemption is an rpg. Hell, saints row is an rpg. Deus Ex, etc.. MMO rpgs.. action rpgs? like Path of exile, etc.
You could probably play GW2 as a single player game, and it would be near the best rpg ever. Neverwinter works well as a single player rpg too.
A story? so, ME2-3, JRPGS, or how about
A few of the more overlooked ones, either due to genre split, or actually under the radar.
Vampire the Masquerade: bloodlines. probably the best ever. (needs to be patched)
Alpha protocal.
Red Dead Redeption. (a bit GTA clone, a bit RPG, a bit FO3. you decide.)
Divinity 2:dragonknight saga. AMAZEBALLS. (a new divinity just came out too.)
Dark souls.
Will have to look into indie rpgs. there are definitely many out there. not coming to mind atm.
city of steam. action rpg. f2p browser based.
Legend of Grimrock.
Witcher series and Drakensang (not amazing, but pretty typical rpgs), oh and lets not forget Amaluer. Which was generally deemed "ok to good, but not amazing"
Skyrim, and Morrowind of course.