We have this discussion every 2 months. Seemingly everyone here falls into one of two groups:
A: DA 2 was absolutely fucking horrible.
B: DA 2 improved upon DA 1's combat and class system, and Varric was awesome. Unfortunately, they fucked up with reusing areas, parachute troops, retarded plot moves which rendered player decisions worthless and fucking Anders (literally).
Instead of typing out another series of 1000 word posts for the 13th time, everyone can just post A or B. If you want to read the discussions, read the other 5 threads on the forum.
I'm with B.