Got an issue with multiplayer on PS5. Friend and I are trying to co-op Stormveil Castle on our new characters (his first time through the game, I started a n00b to also play the beginning) and neither of us can get a summon sign to show up for the other. We're both outside the main gate, neither has gone through the dungeon yet. We also tried summoning at a different dungeon that neither had cleared yet and it didn't work there either.
We're using a password, we both used that consumable that makes summon signs appear, and just nada. He's level 62 and I'm level 48, which google says is within range.
Weird thing is, my level 197 character dropped a summon sign in the same place and it appeared for him right away / let him summon me so I could drop some loot (mostly cosmetic stuff and consumables, don't want to ruin the game).
TLDR: My level 62 friend (who hasn't beaten Stormveil) can summon my level 197 character (who has beaten Stormveil), but can't summon my level 48 character (who hasn't beaten Stormveil) or vice versa.
Can you only be summoned to dungeons you've cleared, meaning one of us has to do it without the other? Only thing I can think of. Edit: Nope, tried summoning him to a dungeon he's cleared and I haven't, still nothing.