Everquest Legends

Ridas

Pay to play forum
2,996
4,295
They just needed to release expansions in a timely manner for a success. The incompetence is astounding. The interest and initial population was there and THJ showed that you could retain a lot of people.

Oh well, jokes on them. There still is Triune for now.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Punko

Macho Ma'am
<Gold Donor>
8,510
13,673
I wrote a long post and deleted it.

The game runs on nostalgia, we don't want new zones. We want the same shit with QoL and being strong vs content. Throw in some new shit, just a sparkle suffices.

New content will drive the old school players away.
 
  • 4Like
Reactions: 3 users

Araxen

Golden Baronet of the Realm
11,536
9,032
From looking at a stream today(there aren't many anymore) on Qeynos, there was about 678 in general. The pop is down obviously. WoW Forever will erode that number even more.
 
Last edited:

Punko

Macho Ma'am
<Gold Donor>
8,510
13,673
Rogean managing this just like r99.

"Who cares if there are only 3 people online, this is my game."

Custom content takes years and should be appreciated whenever our EQ gods grant it.

Big oofs.

He seems to have forgotten that offering a free service to degens is not the same as offering a paid service to customers.

2/10 for the job. Sacking community managers while staying absolutely absent on the front.
 
Last edited:

Drakurii

Aten Ha Ra Slayer
15,991
53,074
It's mind blowing they had the perfect blueprint for success (THJ) and somehow still managed to fuck this up. Getting people in the door is easy, keeping them is hard and getting people back after they leave will be impossible in most cases. New content somewhere in the distant future will not make anyone forget this abomination. WoW4life it is.
 
  • 3Like
  • 1Worf
Reactions: 3 users

rolien

Golden Knight of the Realm
365
384
Watching this burn is almost cathartic if you ever took part on the discord trying to give suggestions or opinions.

It was an echo chamber.
"DON'T LIKE IT LEAVE"
"DON'T THINK THIS BAD IDEA IS GOOD DON'T BUY IT!"

Okay I won't. It's almost if you tell this to enough people it happens...

I do like that the community manager told people to do something else on the weekend when they were having problems instead of saying what was going on.

You're not ff14 you need the people lol.
 

hory

Silver Baronet of the Realm
2,669
6,697
The best thing that they came up with was making you replay plane of sky arguably the worst zone in all of EverQuest on a loop for months on end.
Is this a surprise to any one.
 

Araxen

Golden Baronet of the Realm
11,536
9,032
No patch this week essentially.

1791843413391.png
 

hats

Molten Core Raider
77
44
not that i care about hate DC or hand of the maestro.. but has anyone noticed that this patch note from 3 weeks ago still hasn’t actually taken effect in the game?

there are some bug reports about it but almost no activity in them. lot of apathy in the remaining players

same thing for the alter plane hate x reagent patch note. small thing but the note just didn’t actually get implemented

there should probably be some kind of test server, but what do i know
 

Cutlery

Kill All the White People
<Gold Donor>
8,506
27,737
Buddy got me into this. Gotta say - I'm not really understanding the hate. It's a pretty decent trip down memory lane. Enough new mechanics to make you think about some interactions a little, but it's basically the same. It's like fucking your wife's sister.

Anyway, mostly amused at all the "oh, I poopsocked this and there's nothing to do" "how could they fuck this up.". Guys, you paid $20 for this. I KNOW you spent more on games you played way less on Steam. Take it for what it is. Some power gaming dad game, play it till it gets boring, quit, and forget about it. Ain't that fuckin serious. Ya'll act like this was ever gonna be anything but an extreme niche game.

Just because a game is made doesn't mean you gotta play it for the rest of your life. Knock out a month and go play something else.
 
  • 5Like
  • 1Truth!
Reactions: 5 users

Tuco

I got Tuco'd!
<Gold Donor>
51,407
94,220
Buddy got me into this. Gotta say - I'm not really understanding the hate. It's a pretty decent trip down memory lane. Enough new mechanics to make you think about some interactions a little, but it's basically the same. It's like fucking your wife's sister.

Anyway, mostly amused at all the "oh, I poopsocked this and there's nothing to do" "how could they fuck this up.". Guys, you paid $20 for this. I KNOW you spent more on games you played way less on Steam. Take it for what it is. Some power gaming dad game, play it till it gets boring, quit, and forget about it. Ain't that fuckin serious. Ya'll act like this was ever gonna be anything but an extreme niche game.

Just because a game is made doesn't mean you gotta play it for the rest of your life. Knock out a month and go play something else.
I agree with the advice that this isn't a game people should expect to endlessly play, but most of the hate for this game is due to this game copying a much better version that the owning company forced to close. IP theft aside, if you're going to shut down a third party group and try to rip off on their ideas, you need to execute it well.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Burns

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
9,538
18,445
Buddy got me into this. Gotta say - I'm not really understanding the hate. It's a pretty decent trip down memory lane. Enough new mechanics to make you think about some interactions a little, but it's basically the same. It's like fucking your wife's sister.

Anyway, mostly amused at all the "oh, I poopsocked this and there's nothing to do" "how could they fuck this up.". Guys, you paid $20 for this. I KNOW you spent more on games you played way less on Steam. Take it for what it is. Some power gaming dad game, play it till it gets boring, quit, and forget about it. Ain't that fuckin serious. Ya'll act like this was ever gonna be anything but an extreme niche game.

Just because a game is made doesn't mean you gotta play it for the rest of your life. Knock out a month and go play something else.
A lot of the hate comes from drama outside the game itself.

The story goes that there once was a Emu server that, while not the first to include multi-class into one character, they were the most successful at taking the idea and making it work. It got hugely successful and they were taking "donations" for "server costs" which ended up being rather profitable for them. Supposedly the people who own the EQ IP (DBG) didn't even know about said server until a different EMU developer ratted them out.

Then DBG, instead of trying to work with developers of the successful EMU, sued the shit out of them and got it closed down (Emu devs supposedly asked to enter negotiations for licensing, or some such, after DBG took an interest). Instead DBG decided to hire the alleged rat to try to make a copy of the successful server, which is EQLegends.

Not sure how much evidence there is that Secrets was the rat. There was some email in the court files that was supposedly his?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Tuco

I got Tuco'd!
<Gold Donor>
51,407
94,220
Supposedly the people who own the EQ IP (DBG) didn't even know about said server until a different EMU developer ratted them out.
Not that DBG has their finger on the pulse of their own community, but it doesn't really take a rat to find out about an emulation server when they're making tens of thousands of dollars a month with thousands of daily users for years.
 

Kithani

Vyemm Raider
2,725
3,876
Not that DBG has their finger on the pulse of their own community, but it doesn't really take a rat to find out about an emulation server when they're making tens of thousands of dollars a month with thousands of daily users for years.
Which server are you talking about? THJ def didn’t have “thousands of daily users for years.”

I think the other part of EQL is that it forces people into being a captive audience for Secrets who likes to do the bullshit of “let me put my own TWIST on it!” Like releasing some alternative Kunark timeline that nobody asked for ever
 

Burns

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
9,538
18,445
Not that DBG has their finger on the pulse of their own community, but it doesn't really take a rat to find out about an emulation server when they're making tens of thousands of dollars a month with thousands of daily users for years.
In the legal thread on THJ, that's how it was portrayed. The whole thing that kicked off the lawsuit was the email. Then DBG assigned the janitor (probably) to try to play the EMU server to collect evidence and couldn't even figure out how to properly scout zones with a rogue (who is invis to all at level 1).
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Tuco

I got Tuco'd!
<Gold Donor>
51,407
94,220
Which server are you talking about? THJ def didn’t have “thousands of daily users for years.”
I don't know how trustworthy it is but


Worldserver Name: The Heroes' Journey [Multiclass, Solo\Duo, No-Box]
Server Version:
Server Status: Down (Last Seen: 09/24/25 03:02 AM EST)
Average Players: 1713
Max Players: 4525

Regardless of how it shook out, THJ wasn't some underground secret that Secrets ratted out. Secrets might've been involved in pushing for action against THJ, but that's uhh, more of a snake move than a rat move?
 
Last edited:

Cutlery

Kill All the White People
<Gold Donor>
8,506
27,737
Guys, guys - business is dirty. Everyone gets greedy, some underhanded shit happens, people win and people lose

Let's just get back to hating Secrets for the good reasons.

He's a tranny and living with a disgusting hambeast.
 

Kithani

Vyemm Raider
2,725
3,876
I don't know how trustworthy it is but





Regardless of how it shook out, THJ wasn't some underground secret that Secrets ratted out. Secrets might've been involved in pushing for action against THJ, but that's uhh, more of a snake move than a rat move?
I don’t know when the server popped off but in our own threads here you can see it launched less than 8 months from the lawsuit and it was closed down within like 10 months
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user