Girls who broke your heart thread

Haast

Lord Nagafen Raider
3,281
1,636
Eomer said:
the best thing to have done would have been to just come right out and say "yeah it"s not my apartment so it"s probably not a good idea, cya Monday" and then just act like nothing happened but make it obvious he wasn"t going to give her the time of day any more while being civil about it. Not to game her or anything, but because she"s a twat and not worth his time. He still has to work with her come Monday.
Truf.

If you have to work with her, I"d recommend treating her as if you"d never spoke with her outside of work previously. Respectful and professional, yet distant; focus only on work stuff. The message should be very clear.

If she wants to "patch things up" after a bit, beware of tarp. You"ve seen enough to know better.. unless you are really hard up and want to make work horribly awkward when things inevitably go south. Which would make some fucking great material for this thread.
 

Tenks

Bronze Knight of the Realm
14,163
606
lost said:
Now that I think of it, it kind of sounds like he was second choice, backup you could say.. "need to have lunch, need to have dinner" soon as she"s single. Rebound etc, then someone else was quicker to the punch.
I"m hesitant to say this because I don"t know the entire story but it seems like he almost friend zoned himself. She was giving all the signs and making all the moves and it seems like he wasn"t pushing back enough. Hanging out with a bunch of people from work does not constitute a date. Meeting for happy hour with co workers isn"t a date. Going out to dinner, one on one and making your feelings and intentions knownisa date. Forcing her to do all the stuff, honestly, guys should be doing is the best way to make a girl rapidly lose interest.
 

The Ancient_sl

shitlord
7,386
16
Eomer said:
I agree with this. When I read that particular part of the story, that"s exactly what I thought as well. That part could have been handled much better.
I don"t quite think asking "who"s we" is that out there, but neither was her behavior. You had no stake claimed, I don"t really see that this girl did anything wrong.
 

Couldntbe_foh

shitlord
0
0
@chewie

Your work relationship is far more important than the events you described.
Be work-related friendly, work-related helpful, and work -related nice.
Ignore any of the negative advice that suggests you should cause her any distress.
Both of you, your employer, and work-mates will all be better off with a civilized approach to the entire thing.
 
0
0
lost said:
Sounds like the basic principle, if she"s doing it to him (bf in this case), she"ll do it to you. I would have handled it just like you did, but it would have been interesting to see you notgiveafuk and see where that played out (seems like a fwb situation), of course it doesnt seem possible since she was throwing it in your face trying to come to the party.
Yeah that"s what was most weird if nothing else. Why even show up, unless you"re incredibly socially naive, stupid, or looking to play games?

It"s one of those situations where they made the absolute worst possible decision for themselves. Had it just been as simple as "oh, I got tired last night, let"s meet up another time" - who would"ve questioned that or known any better? Sure, once alcohol is involved, anything could happen in one"s mind. But it"s mind boggling the decision made

Props that the other girls at work saw it, that certainly cant hurt you in the long run. Maybe they"ll talk amongst each other, oh hes such a good guy, then try to hook you up with their friends or something? who knws
That"s another story actually... one of the girls involved and I have a back story, then when this new girl came around... well let"s just say she hated my guts

And yeah, it surprised me how she acted that night before and after the whole ordeal. Made me feel like a huge asshole all along (oh well, I"m used to that anyways )

As for the other replies, do you think he"s really in a situation to tell her off when they work together? I havent been in that situation in a long time but I remember I got an ex a job with me, and she proceeded to get her previous ex a job there and her other guy friend.. and holy shit, I learned my lesson there.
Now *that* is a brutal fucking story I"m sure

Eomer said:
I agree with this. When I read that particular part of the story, that"s exactly what I thought as well. That part could have been handled much better.
Yeah it wasn"t the best move in hindsight, though it"s not the exact quote which comes off a lot better, or at least that"s what some of the other girls around have said about it. Then again, I suppose, all women have ulterior motives

lost said:
While she wasnt his to begin with, she was the one promoting the continuance of the whatever it was by asking to go out to dinner or future dates (supposedly), but where I agree with him getting pissed is leading him on via flirting/dates, failing to mention she was bringing a guy to the coworkers party and expecting it to be okay last minute.
And not just a guy, but clearly one they had some history (on-going it seems) after changing plans up and being untrustworthy.

And again, why qualify it with me? That"s another confusing point - why the fuck ask if it"s okay? Then get ultra defensive if I even imply no?

Dandai said:
Emphasis on supposedly. I"d be interested to hear her explain how much she was advertising how available she was.
It"s a good point, and normally I wouldn"t be so sure in a situation like this because of where, but again - quite a few outside people to the whole deal (more objective people, I"d hope) all saw it, plus the egging on all night (from females, no less). That actually surprised me as much as anything (we"re obviously all close to one another as coworkers)

Perhaps it would have been better to have stopped contact after she hung up on him.

Either way I think we can all agree she"s not relationship material from the getgo.
Like I said, bad move on my part (well, it"s fucking 1:30 AM and i"ve had some drinks - almost nothing is a good move at that point) for making any contact afterwards, but I kept it quick and simple and never bothered following up afterwards or any other shit that could have made it worse.

Any time I"m not sure how to proceed, I ice the chick for a few days. If/when she contacts me again after the third or fourth day, I give her a neutral reason for the cold shoulderplusa reason that always involves putting her feelings first ("I felt like I was putting too much pressure on you" or "I could tell you were having a rough week so I wanted to give you a little space" etc). Ya this isn"t 100% foolproof. You have to have established at least a modest foundation of romantic intent before hand. However, when you do start talking again, she"s going to be more emphatic and enthusiastic (unless you waited too long).
I dunno how I feel about that in a situation like this. Could work if I"m still legitimately interested, but it"s a lot easier I suppose if I weren"t forced to see her again cause if it fails, I"d just go about and say... fuck it

lost said:
Now that I think of it, it kind of sounds like he was second choice, backup you could say.. "need to have lunch, need to have dinner" soon as she"s single. Rebound etc, then someone else was quicker to the punch.
Dandai said:
Well, I don"t know that I would say that he was the second choice all along, but I definitely get the feeling that another dude approached her with far fewer reservations than he did and she happily directed her attention at him instead.
Well I knew she was pretty insecure in a lot of ways (and probably latched onto the first guy with fewer reservations), but the fact that her plans apparently changed in the span of 2-3 hours to attaching onto an old flame (my guess as to this guy) is something completely the fucking opposite of what she had been saying all day, makes me almost think bipolar

Then again, when you"re on the rebound, old flames make sense in a situation like that (which is my guess on who he was, as I"ve never met him), so I"m pretty glad I"m not involved in more drama which could only lead to greater material for this thread

Eomer said:
I"m not disagreeing. But as Tenks said, both his response on the phone (he knew exactly who "we" was) and his text after she hung up were super passive-aggressive. I can"t say that I"d have handled it any better in that situation.
Well, I knew exactly who "we" was - because I saw that shit happen and saw right through the earlier BS. It probably could"ve been handled better (sadly, its always in hindsight), and it was certainly a dick move, but hey so it goes. Sometimes putting your foot down might be the only choice about it

Hell, probably much worse. But looking at it objectively, the best thing to have done would have been to just come right out and say "yeah it"s not my apartment so it"s probably not a good idea, cya Monday" and then just act like nothing happened but make it obvious he wasn"t going to give her the time of day any more while being civil about it. Not to game her or anything, but because she"s a twat and not worth his time. He still has to work with her come Monday.
Again, I"m not really sure how else I could"ve handled it better other than not responding with the text or whatever. Being straightforward about not playing games and shit was what I figured would be the best option in a case like this, especially if I"m correct in that she"s used to having guys say "yes" to everything (she definitely has the spoiled princess vibe) and just manning up about it.

Worse thing that happens is they go back to being co-workers on a strictly professional basis, without much weirdness. Best thing is she throws herself at him when she sobers up and realizes she was a twat about it, Chewie hits it and leaves her hanging because she"s a twat.

As it stands, now it"s going to be super awkward at work AND he likely has no chance of poon without a heroic recovery.
As I"ve said, at this point, I"m not even worried about the poon - just more of the former, which is alleviating any awkwardness about the situation that can seep into work. It"s her loss anyways, and if she"s being an emotional trainwreck because of the breakup + all this other shit going on afterwards... well at least I didn"t hop onboard the crazytrain.

As for the awkwardness, thankfully it"d be one-on-one kind of awkwardness, since the office in general is a lot lot closer and supportive of me (and I always knew the other girls resented her, and all those feelings came straight out after the whole incident - felt good knowing who has got your back).

I guess we"ll see how it goes when we do see each other at work. Best thing I can do is just not even bring it up - she can always use the classic "it"s chill" excuse about what happens, which makes you look like an ass. On the other hand, she was the one who acted defensive right off the bat and everyone saw what happened (her original story for the night too... well she had let everyone in the office know hours in advance, then changing it in 2-3 hours? yeah, good luck rationalizing that one with people)

Haast said:
Truf.

If you have to work with her, I"d recommend treating her as if you"d never spoke with her outside of work previously. Respectful and professional, yet distant; focus only on work stuff. The message should be very clear.
Yeah, like I said, no reason to go out of my way to be an ass on this, since it can only make myself look worse in front of a bunch of people who have had my back the whole way.

If she wants to "patch things up" after a bit, beware of tarp. You"ve seen enough to know better.. unless you are really hard up and want to make work horribly awkward when things inevitably go south. Which would make some fucking great material for this thread.
Heh, that"s kind of why I"m tempted about saving this card, for those days when I think work is going horribly boring and I need something to stir the drink

Tenks said:
I"m hesitant to say this because I don"t know the entire story but it seems like he almost friend zoned himself. She was giving all the signs and making all the moves and it seems like he wasn"t pushing back enough. Hanging out with a bunch of people from work does not constitute a date. Meeting for happy hour with co workers isn"t a date. Going out to dinner, one on one and making your feelings and intentions knownisa date. Forcing her to do all the stuff, honestly, guys should be doing is the best way to make a girl rapidly lose interest.
I hear ya. Looking back, I could see where I should have been more aggressive and direct (the coworker thing was definitely a factor, and the fact that I made myself disinterested to avoid more drama w/ the entire boyfriend situation). Then again, it just happened all within a period of 4 days or so after having known each other for months before so it was more a surprise to me how quickly shit unfolded/hit the fan since I had pretty much not cared for a period of time

Camerous Valde Unus said:
OMFG Do I ever have a story for you all but I can"t post it right now they are in the car waiting on me but LOL!!
Get help. Now.
 
0
0
The Ancient said:
I don"t quite think asking "who"s we" is that out there, but neither was her behavior. You had no stake claimed, I don"t really see that this girl did anything wrong.
Of course I had no stake claimed, which is why I"m not heartbroken or anything like that. I"ve said it to others before too about this - I would"ve been completely fine if she said she was single, on a rebound, playing the field, etc.

It"s the fact that she was dishonest about the whole situation (no idea why I should even be surprised, of course) starting all the way from during the day about her plans that night (yes, I know plans change, but why the fuck would you even show up afterwards? the hell did you expect?) then getting ultra defensive about a "who"s we" statement, in a split second (couldn"t even come up with some kind of excuse - makes me wonder if she realized it was too late and didn"t have any excuses, or she wasn"t used to guys telling her no about shit) that annoyed me


Couldntbe said:
@chewie

Your work relationship is far more important than the events you described.
Be work-related friendly, work-related helpful, and work -related nice.
Ignore any of the negative advice that suggests you should cause her any distress.
Both of you, your employer, and work-mates will all be better off with a civilized approach to the entire thing.
I agree with that. I don"t see any need to go make her life miserable (though if I wanted to be petty or if she pulled some shit on me, I certainly could, through work)


Palum said:
I love this thread because I don"t even need to ask to be reminded why relationships and the work place are such a bad idea. Of course since I"m a workaholic that kind of leaves my options as... fuck.
Yeah, in this field, there"s one marriage you"re guaranteed: to you work
 

Dabamf_sl

shitlord
1,472
0
Don"t think too much about it. She wasn"t "yours," but she knows what impression she gave to you, so trying to bring another guy to hang out the night she"s supposed to meet you and other friends makes her a piece of shit. Seeing another guy, fine. But actively willing to bring him in your presence is really disrespectful. I hate those kinds of girls/people. They pretend ignorance, but they"re fully aware. Would you do that do a girl?

Chalk it up to her being a dumb skank and ignore it. Keep your work relationship professional but ignore her otherwise. She wants you to qualify yourself and apologize for being a dick or bow to her in some other way. You didn"t do anything wrong, she did, so ignore her like you would any other person who has disrespected you.

Along with that, in the future just try to be a little less passive by making a 1-on-1 plan quicker to define the type of relationship you have (not define a relationship, but just to make it known that you aren"t just friends), and if a chick calls you and asks to come down again, just tell her, "I don"t know, call soandso. Cya" She disrespected you, so its perfectly acceptable, and I say required, that you return no courtesy.
 

kegkilla

The Big Mod
<Banned>
11,320
14,738
@chewie

how old are the people involved in this story? seems like it would have to be a bunch of young to mid 20"s

i think you handled the situation well... though i wouldn"t have texted her afterwards. it"s pretty obvious the girl was desperate for some male attention after breaking up or whatever, and handled things with you really shitty.
 
0
0
Dabamf said:
Don"t think too much about it. She wasn"t "yours," but she knows what impression she gave to you, so trying to bring another guy to hang out the night she"s supposed to meet you and other friends makes her a piece of shit. Seeing another guy, fine. But actively willing to bring him in your presence is really disrespectful. I hate those kinds of girls/people. They pretend ignorance, but they"re fully aware. Would you do that do a girl?
Exactly why it"s so dumbfounding to me. I would never because I knew that if I pulled the same shit, and brought a girl, I"m sure first thing she"d do is call every one of her girlfriends and tell them how much of an asshole I am, etc. Yet somehow, if they pull the same shit...

Chalk it up to her being a dumb skank and ignore it. Keep your work relationship professional but ignore her otherwise. She wants you to qualify yourself and apologize for being a dick or bow to her in some other way. You didn"t do anything wrong, she did, so ignore her like you would any other person who has disrespected you.

Along with that, in the future just try to be a little less passive by making a 1-on-1 plan quicker to define the type of relationship you have (not define a relationship, but just to make it known that you aren"t just friends), and if a chick calls you and asks to come down again, just tell her, "I don"t know, call soandso. Cya" She disrespected you, so its perfectly acceptable, and I say required, that you return no courtesy.
Point taken. And, like I said, it"s one of those things no one expects to move so fast. I barely was back and settled back in town and it all went from high to low in less than 48 hours.

Ser Kegkilla said:
@chewie

how old are the people involved in this story? seems like it would have to be a bunch of young to mid 20"s

i think you handled the situation well... though i wouldn"t have texted her afterwards. it"s pretty obvious the girl was desperate for some male attention after breaking up or whatever, and handled things with you really shitty.
Yeah, mid 20"s - though I expect this shit out of young 20"s in college if nothing else.

The text was stupid in hindsight, but at this point - it could"ve been a lot worse I suppose. And yeah, attention grubbing is pretty much the feeling I get
 

Tenks

Bronze Knight of the Realm
14,163
606
Dabamf said:
Don"t think too much about it. She wasn"t "yours," but she knows what impression she gave to you, so trying to bring another guy to hang out the night she"s supposed to meet you and other friends makes her a piece of shit. Seeing another guy, fine. But actively willing to bring him in your presence is really disrespectful. I hate those kinds of girls/people. They pretend ignorance, but they"re fully aware. Would you do that do a girl?

Chalk it up to her being a dumb skank and ignore it. Keep your work relationship professional but ignore her otherwise. She wants you to qualify yourself and apologize for being a dick or bow to her in some other way. You didn"t do anything wrong, she did, so ignore her like you would any other person who has disrespected you.

Along with that, in the future just try to be a little less passive by making a 1-on-1 plan quicker to define the type of relationship you have (not define a relationship, but just to make it known that you aren"t just friends), and if a chick calls you and asks to come down again, just tell her, "I don"t know, call soandso. Cya" She disrespected you, so its perfectly acceptable, and I say required, that you return no courtesy.
I don"t know if you can paint her a "dumb skank." I hate when people vilify a girl simply because she either changed her mind or lost interest. They both handled the situation poorly so are we going to call Chewie a "dumb fag?" I"m not willing to really insult either. In the story no one was right and no one was wrong. She simply asked him out to lunch/dinner and lost interest in pursuing him. That is her prerogative.
 

The Ancient_sl

shitlord
7,386
16
This is the circle jerk thread so you are of course welcome to that opinion but when you break up with a long term GF I wonder how sensitive you"d be to the feelings of some chick you were sort of interested in if another sure thing came along.
 

kegkilla

The Big Mod
<Banned>
11,320
14,738
Tenks said:
I don"t know if you can paint her a "dumb skank." I hate when people vilify a girl simply because she either changed her mind or lost interest. They both handled the situation poorly so are we going to call Chewie a "dumb fag?" I"m not willing to really insult either. In the story no one was right and no one was wrong. She simply asked him out to lunch/dinner and lost interest in pursuing him. That is her prerogative.
uh she made plans with him, went MIA then reappeared dangling from some other dude"s cock. you want him to just smile and take it like some little cuckold bitch?
 

Tenks

Bronze Knight of the Realm
14,163
606
Ser Kegkilla said:
uh she made plans with him, went MIA then reappeared dangling from some other dude"s cock. you want him to just smile and take it like some little cuckold bitch?
Their "plans" was simply inviting her out to a group function
 

Stratos_foh

shitlord
0
0
(in response to TheAncient)

in your scenario the chick is random or something, cause it does not seem like you are taking into account chewie and the trash girl"s status as coworkers (a few months), the group"s perception of her interest, and then her subsequent dishonesty/flakyness and poor judgment in front of her work peers that night.
 

Haast

Lord Nagafen Raider
3,281
1,636
I assume her side would be somewhat different. However, assuming we"re being told mostly truth, it is a dumb idea to make plans with co-workers, then show up hammered & making out with someone that no one knows and assume everything is good to go. At the very least, you"re fueling unnecessary work drama.
 

kegkilla

The Big Mod
<Banned>
11,320
14,738
Tenks said:
Their "plans" was simply inviting her out to a group function
which she flaked on and embarrassed him by showing up with some other dude. girl is a piece of shit, deserves far worse than what she got, end of story.
 

STFU_foh

shitlord
0
0
That entire story sounds like something that would happen to a freshman in college, not someone working in an industry where "people are generally extremely well educated and mature (despite being an overwhelmingly youthful company)".
 

Tenks

Bronze Knight of the Realm
14,163
606
STFU said:
That entire story sounds like something that would happen to a freshman in college, not someone working in an industry where "people are generally extremely well educated and mature (despite being an overwhelmingly youthful company)".
I pretty much agree. We have:

*Guy afraid to pull the trigger to actually ask girl out
*Passive aggressive texts
*Attention whoring / jealous causing girl
*Drunken makeout in a car
*Catty girls talking about a girl behind her back


No one in the entire story comes off as mature to me