Gun control

Big Phoenix

Pronouns: zie/zhem/zer
<Gold Donor>
47,633
102,719
The point isn't really to deny people guns, seriously, except in extreme cases where a person would probably have some kind of questionable level of legal competence*, it is to ensure the people getting them are as knowledgeable and aware as possible. To make sure they are understanding the responsability, blah blah.

I would be less concerned about everyone running around with guns if we took more steps to making sure their heads were farther away from their asses beforehand.

*I think we can put "Should people with sub-80 IQs be afforded their second amendment rights in from of the high courts and let them fight with it.
Thats not just guns though. I mean anyone who cant be trusted with a gun probably couldnt be trusted with a car.

At the heart of "gun violence" is are social/economic issues. Making it harder to obtain guns or banning them doesnt fix the underlying issue, it simply changes what tool is used.
 

Lusiphur

Peasant
595
47
Thats not just guns though. I mean anyone who cant be trusted with a gun probably couldnt be trusted with a car.

At the heart of "gun violence" is are social/economic issues. Making it harder to obtain guns or banning them doesnt fix the underlying issue, it simply changes what tool is used.
And lowers the bodycount. But lets keep skipping over that shall we?
 

fanaskin

Well known agitator
<Silver Donator>
56,298
139,965
Dude you're missing the entire point. The organized crime isn't the fucking problem, it's the self described 'responsible gun owners' who nonetheless are just as prone to laziness and violence and intoxication and lax judgement, combined with having such an absurd number of firearms in the country that they're so freely and cheaply available for any asshole gangbanger selling bags on the corner.
that's bordering on megalomaniacal to even say you even could take all the guns away. The Problem is violence crime and murder. And as such you wouldn't even treating the disease by taking all the guns away, just the symptoms.

I cant understand the rational that on one hand says urban crime isn't a persons fault. Urban crime is caused by social/economic factors, Yet people who use that Argument doesn't list social/economic changes as the prescription for the symptom gun violence, gun control would have the perceived effect of easing the pain without fixing the root cause.

That is a inappropriate way to problem solve. taking a pain reliever(gun control) will never fix the root cause, in fact its worse it causes you to ignore the root problem for the lack of pain and allows the chronic condition to continue. Its a terrible way to do business in the medical field and its a terrible way to do business socially.

fix the problem not the symptom.
 

fanaskin

Well known agitator
<Silver Donator>
56,298
139,965
And lowers the bodycount. But lets keep skipping over that shall we?
that statement probably isn't true.

Also you cannot place an infinite value to human life, In fact human life, even peoples own lives, is valued by most everyone in practice as rather cheap. There is a clear moral hazard when put a value on peoples lives.

That's why this emotional exploitation is so wicked the reality and the emotional phantasy that's being incited is radically different.

On top of this you would sacrifice a core liberty for what is mostly regarded in practice as cheap(human life) is insulting.
 

Azrayne

Irenicus did nothing wrong
2,161
787
that's bordering on megalomaniacal to even say you even could take all the guns away the violence and murder problem. And as such you aren't even treating the disease, just the symptoms.

I cant understand the rational that on one hand says urban crime isn't a persons fault it is caused by social/economic factors,Yet people who use that Argument doesn't list social/economic changes as the prescription for the symptom gun violence, gun control would have the effect of easing the pain without fixing the root cause.

That is a inappropriate way to problem solve. taking a pain reliever(gun control) will not fix the root cause, in fact its worse it causes you to ignore the root problem for the lack of pain and allows the chronic condition to continue. Its a terrible way to do business in the medical field and its a terrible way to do business socially.

fix the problem not the symptom.
Which is great in theory, but when you show no sign of making progress towards fixing the problem, it's generally a good idea to halt the symptoms in the meanwhile.
 

hodj

Vox Populi Jihadi
<Silver Donator>
31,673
18,384
stuff about a sociopathic society
This is basically my thoughts on it. We're sociopaths, we as a society as so wealthy, so far up our own asses with our own importance, so arrogant, so self absorbed, that its inevitable that some people will come to see their failures as caused by others, which then leads them to blame, irrationally, society for their failures as people. I think in particular this affects "white males" because of their position of power in our society for so long, hence why the vast majority of spree killers are "white men". Basically, the mindset is "If I've failed, it can't be my fault, I'm a perfect snowflake mommy and daddy told me so, so someone else must be to blame, and I'm so important that if someone else caused me to fail, then I have the right to harm them, and others, to show the world some justice for the wrongs it has caused to me."

Mix that kind of thought pattern with a mental illness that leads to a lack of impulse control, and you get an explosive combition in some people.
 

fanaskin

Well known agitator
<Silver Donator>
56,298
139,965
Which is great in theory, but when you show no sign of making progress towards fixing the problem, it's generally a good idea to halt the symptoms in the meanwhile.
which is why it's generally stupid idea. fix the problem not the symptom.
 

fanaskin

Well known agitator
<Silver Donator>
56,298
139,965
Mix that kind of thought pattern with a mental illness that leads to a lack of impulse control, and you get an explosive combition in some people.
it's worse than that, the drugs psychiatrist put people on defiantly has side effects on the mind.And as with the problem of treating the symptom not the disease, pills do not force people to face the underlying cognitive dissonance in their minds that can cause people to develop neurosis, mental suppression by way of drugs really is terrible in that aspect. Long term repression will usually lead to a violent outbreak at some point.
 

Zombie Thorne_sl

shitlord
918
1
This is basically my thoughts on it. We're sociopaths, we as a society as so wealthy, so far up our own asses with our own importance, so arrogant, so self absorbed, that its inevitable that some people will come to see their failures as caused by others, which then leads them to blame, irrationally, society for their failures as people. I think in particular this affects "white males" because of their position of power in our society for so long, hence why the vast majority of spree killers are "white men". Basically, the mindset is "If I've failed, it can't be my fault, I'm a perfect snowflake mommy and daddy told me so, so someone else must be to blame, and I'm so important that if someone else caused me to fail, then I have the right to harm them, and others, to show the world some justice for the wrongs it has caused to me."

Mix that kind of thought pattern with a mental illness that leads to a lack of impulse control, and you get an explosive combition in some people.
It absolutely is our society that is the problem. Most of the mass shootings are done by well off, educated kids from the 'burbs that had thier parents tell them they were perfect angels and special snowflakes all of thier lives. Then they get to high school and realize that they arent. ANNNNNNNNGST!!!! I dont think we need to go back to the 50's mentality of child raising, but i dont think any of us on this board can say most 12-18 year old kids today are pillars of humanity.

Kids need parents to actively parent. They need a Mom AND a Dad (or mom and mom / dad and dad). This is a lot of the problem with the black community, no parenting, teachers dont care and kids turn to the streets. But no one in the media will say this, instead they say we need more money for schools and education to fix it. Throwing money at the schools will not do a damn thing when the kids dont have a home environment that promotes education and bettering themselves. No, they get Honey Boo Boo on the TV and gangs/drugs on the streets. You want to spend money on social programs? Lets get something like Big Brothers and Sisters in the community with some ppl that actually give a shit. I honestly think you would see a dramatic decrease in ALL crime if some of these hood rats actually had someone that gave a shit about them.
 

Flank_sl

shitlord
499
0
Obviously guns are the symptom and not the cause. I don't think gun control advocates would disagree with this but it would actually be easier to implement gun control than to fix the social problems. For a start, you would need to eliminate poverty and we have no idea how to actually do that. The choice is either implement gun control or do nothing. Better choices may become available in the future, but in the mean time a lot of lives will be lost.
 

Cathan

Silver Knight of the Realm
410
52
You think they would want to do this if after the torture was over they were left with no limbs, no teeth, no tongue, no eyes, deaf and forced to live with no pain killers in a hospital bed where they fed them just enough to keep them alive? I think that would be a huge deterrent if you combined it with a law that forces a media black out of ever announcing who the person was, no fame and and the rest of your life in what I could only imagine if there is such a place as hell you would welcome it every fucking second for the rest of your life.

Death is to good for some people, you kill children like this, you deserve what I mentioned above.
Torture just doesn't work. The Romans were wholesale torturing christians and anyone else they thought needed it. Crucifixion was invented to be one horrible means of torture. The middle and dark ages all had some incredibly awful methods and machines of torture like draw and quarter, the iron maiden, the rack, braveheart cut your gut open and rip your guts out or just good old fashioned beheadings...

I 100% agree with you there is nothing we could ever do to a child murderer that would make any of us feel like he'd properly paid his debt. The only thing I could think of is if he spent his life saving the lives of children for the rest of his life but obviously that's not going to happen.

I'm reading a book: Guns, Germs and Steel that describes how civilization developed over thousands of years to have laws. We (humanity) has tried torture but all that does is piss the people off even more when they're treated horribly. The people will rise up then and rightly so. I can't articulate everything the book says into 1 short post but the laws we have, soft as they may be, are built to form a society that feels they are treated fairly yet punishes those that wrong others appropriately. If you stray from that it unravels the very fabric of that society over time...

The reason we have these problems is a dozen or more things that have gone wrong in our society that we haven't effectively addressed. I'm sick of our sensationalist media. We aren't handling mental illness properly. Lawyers have gone too far "protecting" criminals, etc etc etc.

I am pro gun but there's no need for the common citizen to have assault weapons, anything full automatic or bajillion round clips.

I'm not religious nut but I think we should teach kids about religion in schools but it shouldn't be JUST CHRISTIANITY. Make a mandatory class that teaches spirituality and teaches every religion so kids can decide for themselves which religion, if any, they want to follow. I won't even begin to make the argument that lack of GOD in schools is the problem, but kids learning about spirituality and the tenets of religion that are good, such as do unto others..., would "help" teach some values to kids if their parents won't.
 

Gavinmad

Mr. Poopybutthole
44,479
54,010
"Faggot" and "American Inventor" in a single post. Let me guess...ah...you are a Republican. amirite? Just missing "Spick".

Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you a typical Republican. The party of the future.
Yeah, ignore the fact that I proved how much of a fucking moron you are.

P.S. Not a Republican, sorry to disappoint a retard like you. Racism isn't confined to the right, just like gun control isn't confined to the left.
 

a_skeleton_03

<Banned>
29,948
29,765
Torture just doesn't work. The Romans were wholesale torturing christians and anyone else they thought needed it. Crucifixion was invented to be one horrible means of torture. The middle and dark ages all had some incredibly awful methods and machines of torture like draw and quarter, the iron maiden, the rack, braveheart cut your gut open and rip your guts out or just good old fashioned beheadings...
Torturous deaths are nothing like torturing people for information because there is no incentive, at that point the die has been cast and the person knows it. You need to think about things like "to the pain" and leaving somebody's ears on.

Westley:WRONG. Your ears you keep and I'll tell you why. So that every shriek of every child at seeing your hideousness will be yours to cherish. Every babe that weeps at your approach, every woman who cries out, "Dear God! What is that thing," will echo in your perfect ears. That is what to the pain means. It means I leave you in anguish, wallowing in freakish misery forever.
 

fanaskin

Well known agitator
<Silver Donator>
56,298
139,965
The choice is either implement gun control or do nothing. Better choices may become available in the future, but in the mean time a lot of lives will be lost.
option 3, stop having a megalomaniacal delusion that gun control laws will lead to a better society, you have to look at the losses besides the black and white the loss of life, When Politicians appeal to Peoples emotions based on peoples fear of death you are being exploited politically for maximum gain.

human life is rather cheap in the grand view of things, you have to stop putting such a high value on human life it leads to irrational consequences.

You have to balance the cost(liberty, gun rights(right not to have government tell you how to live your life), right of self protection, among other things) vs human life, and the value of human life isn't nearly as high as people make it out to be.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cD0dmRJ0oWg
 

Zombie Thorne_sl

shitlord
918
1
The choice is either implement gun control or do nothing. Better choices may become available in the future, but in the mean time a lot of lives will be lost.
I keep hearing arguments like this and it makes me sad. I have read your posts, you are not an idiot and i think you understand how our media/society works. We will ignore the real problem because its hard, and no one wants to stand up in front of a camera and blame PEOPLE. We have created a society basically white knights everything. So, we are going to go for a band aid fix that essentially does nothing and everyone will feel great and noble. Then in 2 weeks the media is on to the next big thing and the original problem is completely forgotten about. Fast forward 2-10 years and the same horrible event happens again and we start back and square one.

I do not want to see the overwelming majority of gun owners lose a constitutional right because "it is better to do something then nothing at all". Not when that "something" does nothing but impact lawful citizens.
 

Numbers_sl

shitlord
4,054
3
You also have a culture of security for whatever reason and it doesn't seem to be keeping you safe. It appears to be making you less safe to random mass attacks.
 

Dashel

Blackwing Lair Raider
1,836
2,941
Gun control wont effect me directly in the sense that I dont own any and if I were to get them it wouldnt be anything they're looking to ban. Unless they go radical and try to ban all guns which I cant see happening.

I'm generally not in favor of legislating everyone based on the action of a literally insane person however, and this gives me little confidence in where it's headed.

http://www.nationaljournal.com/white...lence-20121219

President Obama will announce Wednesday morning that Vice President Joe Biden will head up an effort to form administration policies to curb gun-related violence.