Hi I'm Shepherd! I'm a Master jungler and I actually have an idea I've been kicking around to solve this jungle diversity thing. I have an idea that can simultaneously make tanky junglers able to compete with the meta junglers without nerfing meta junglers.
SO! Everyone knows about
THISstupid mastery, right? Can anyone even remember the last time they used Runic Blessing? It's almost never used- and to make it even less accessible it is placed WAY deep in the defense tree. So what if we got rid of it and replace it with a new jungle-specific mastery- 'Monster Slayer.' Monster Slayer would be a mastery that adds 1% of your max health as bonus magic damage to monsters. But exactly how much damage IS 1%? And how does that make tanky junglers more viable? Here's a quick breakdown of the damage this mastery would provide using Rammus as an example for his base stats and build path:
6 dmg @ level 1
10 dmg @ level 5 + ruby crystal
18 dmg @ level 9 + Juggernaut jungle item
27 dmg @ level 13 + Juggernaut + giant's belt
UBER LATE GAME THEORY CRAFT
44.8 dmg @ level 18 + 4481 total hp (Juggernaut, Warmog, Shoes, Banshee Veil, Sunfire Cape, Thornmail)
This mastery would do two things:
Firstly, it would allow tankier junglers to build hp without losing too much clear speed both in the early game, and mid game. Because this slightly speeds up clear speed, it also reduces the damage these tankier champions would sustain during their clears as the camps are dying faster. This makes it harder for strong early game champions like Pantheon to invade and abuse tanky junglers during their first clear.
Second, it introduces a way for tank junglers to become competitive picks WITHOUT NERFING existing meta champions. Because the mastery is placed so deep in the defensive tree, bruiser junglers like Vi, Rek'Sai, Lee Sin, J4 etc have to give up the Executioner, Spellweaving, and Havok masteries. Losing these masteries is, in my opinion, not worth the bonus magic damage on monsters.
OKAY- Thanks for reading! Sorry for the wall of text. I've been up all night and I'm going to get some sleep, but leave a comment or message and let me know what you guys think.