ahh the stereo type.
newton imo is borderline elite- SO FAR.
his passing numbers need to be a bit better.
16th this year in yards, 28th in passing percentage(59.8) (peyton was 27th this year-rodgers also had a bad year in this too). he had good TD to interception ratio this year.
he can run, but running COULD hinder him as a QB further on in his career-ie he gets hurt.
his total yards need to go up, and his percentage needs to go up to the ~63-66% range, this year newton Averaged 12.96 yds per completion (espn lists yds per ATTEMPT)... he had 296 completions, in 495 attempts, if he completed 64% of his passes,(317 completions)
using that 12.96 number his yards would have gone up to about 4108, which would have him at 11th in yards, 15th in percentage...(brady 12th in %, 3rd yds)