Rent Vs. Buy housing

McCheese

SW: Sean, CW: Crone, GW: Wizardhawk
6,895
4,277
Wouldn't a landlord still be responsible for repairs if you're renting a house? Or am I reading that all wrong?
Any landlord who isn't a piece of shit slumlord should be, yes. I've never had a landlord--in houses or apartments--not take care of maintenance issues.
 

The Ancient_sl

shitlord
7,386
16
Ben Stein has proven himself to be someone you absolutely shouldn't listen to. That's not to say that article is wrong, but Ben Stein's word is dirt.
 

Deathwing

<Bronze Donator>
16,468
7,495
So buy an apartment? Or rent a house.

I think you're getting off your original point. You said renting saves you money on repairs. It doesn't. You're paying for the repairs no matter where you're living, whether you rent it or own it. Now, going from an apartment to a house will incur more repairs, sure, but that really shouldn't need to be pointed out.
 

Abefroman

Naxxramas 1.0 Raider
12,589
11,907
Not sure where you live but that's not true in my area. People hold onto their tools like they're family antiques. I remember being at a yard sale with a guy who had a used drill he paid $200 for and wanted $150 and wouldn't budge. It was even at the end of the day. There's a local pawn shop with half the store filled with tools that are around 80% their new price and the guy who owns them won't haggle much at all, and nobody buys the tools.

There's very few tools at goodwill stores.

I've been to a few estate sales and auctions and usually the family members pick apart the good tools before the auction.

I've got most of the tools I need now anyway, most I got used, a lot I got new.
Chicago area. Guess there must be a bunch of crap in Michigan, like Detroit...

I'm not saying you can get everything you need in a day. Over time though you can get everything you need. Just pay attention to Craigslist, Obituaries etc.
 

Alex

Still a Music Elitist
14,533
7,473
Are those undergrad loans? I wouldn't be so gungho about paying those off early. Usually the interest rate on those are pretty low(haha, not anymore, fuck you students! -repubs). Better off maxing out your 401k first.

10 year payoff for student loans in pretty typical anyway. What extra are you doing to finish almost exactly when you should?
I was referring to my credit card debt mainly. My student loans will probably take me three or four more years - maybe a little longer to pay off.
 

Gravel

Mr. Poopybutthole
37,005
118,637
I think your math is wrong. You don't need to be making high 6 figures to afford a 500k home, unless your definition of high six figures is upwards of 150k.
Either my point wasn't clear enough, or you missed it. I'm not saying you need to make high 6 figures to afford the monthly payment on a >$500k house. But to afford any sort of down payment? You'll either need that kind of income, or you need to have ridden housing equity boosts as a trade in.
 

Eomer

Trakanon Raider
5,472
272
Wouldn't a landlord still be responsible for repairs if you're renting a house? Or am I reading that all wrong?
I would assume 90% of the time that's the case, but it would totally depend on the lease. With commercial buildings it's frequently not the case. The company renting the space is frequently responsible for all maintenance, improvements and the like. It's called a triple net or NNN lease:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NNN_Lease
 

Cad

scientia potentia est
<Bronze Donator>
24,575
45,665
How do people save up that initial 20%? It just doesn't even seem possible. I'm stay at home, but my husband makes a decent amount but with 3 kids and housing prices in Seattle Eastside we're looking at ~$450k for what we need. I have absolutely no clue how to save close to $100k even with being very careful to put away a % of our monthly income.

In another 4ish years, once all the kids are in school I'll be able to work and contribute more to that, but at 28 I'm feeling like we should already be there. Blah
This is a good indication that you simply can't afford to live where you think you deserve to live, or your expenses are too high for your income level. One or the other.
 

lindz

#DDs
1,201
63
This is a good indication that you simply can't afford to live where you think you deserve to live, or your expenses are too high for your income level. One or the other.
We make $117k a year, live in a middle class neighborhood in a city outside of the more expensive city my husband works in (Redmond, WA) and save about 20% per month on average and spend 23% per month on rent. We can easily afford the mortgage of a house around where he works and we save a decent amount, but we had kids early - he was right out of college and I dropped out to get married and move to another country so we never got savings going before we had a family. Now we're playing catch up and doing it on a single income. My question isn't whether we should have been smarter when we were 20, but how to save that kind of deposit given that we had a family very young.

And I don't think I am asking to live in a place that is beyond our means. Seattle is an expensive housing market and going up but we're here for his job, and I'm not at all the type to be unrealistic about where we should be. Hell, I've been pushing for a move to Utah to cut costs (and be near his family) but he'd have to look for something very different to do that. A family of 5 needs a certain amount of space, decent schools but that's about it. We don't need anything fancy.
 

Famm

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
11,041
794
The answer is, you can't, so just finance the whole thing like everyone else and/or deal with less space for a good neighborhood to raise kids.
 

Cad

scientia potentia est
<Bronze Donator>
24,575
45,665
We make $117k a year, live in a middle class neighborhood in a city outside of the more expensive city my husband works in (Redmond, WA) and save about 20% per month on average and spend 23% per month on rent. We can easily afford the mortgage of a house around where he works and we save a decent amount, but we had kids early - he was right out of college and I dropped out to get married and move to another country so we never got savings going before we had a family. Now we're playing catch up and doing it on a single income. My question isn't whether we should have been smarter when we were 20, but how to save that kind of deposit given that we had a family very young.

And I don't think I am asking to live in a place that is beyond our means. Seattle is an expensive housing market and going up but we're here for his job, and I'm not at all the type to be unrealistic about where we should be. Hell, I've been pushing for a move to Utah to cut costs (and be near his family) but he'd have to look for something very different to do that. A family of 5 needs a certain amount of space, decent schools but that's about it. We don't need anything fancy.
The answer is you sacrifice now and live significantly below your means while you save for a few years.

Whats wrong with this? Its near Redmond and is $250k, 4 bedrooms, 3000 sq ft.http://www.redfin.com/WA/Gig-Harbor/.../home/39892316
 

The Ancient_sl

shitlord
7,386
16
Either my point wasn't clear enough, or you missed it. I'm not saying you need to make high 6 figures to afford the monthly payment on a >$500k house. But to afford any sort of down payment? You'll either need that kind of income, or you need to have ridden housing equity boosts as a trade in.
Well I disagree, I think it's fairly easy to scrape together a hundred thousand in savings if you make 150k+ a year, but I can understand why some people have trouble with it.
 

Cutlery

Kill All the White People
<Gold Donor>
6,499
18,175
It's pretty basic stuff here, like economics 101.. Here's a more voluminous explanation:http://financialmentor.com/financial...or-invest/7478
Yeah, except there's 2 things at odds here. There's math, and there's reality.

Unfortunately, reality doesn't give a shit how good your math is when you lose your job and you still have a gigantic mortgage payment.

You don't think there's just a tiny chance shit can go wrong over the course of 30 years? I guarantee you it will go wrong multiple times, in ways you couldn't even imagine before it happened.
 

lindz

#DDs
1,201
63
The answer is you sacrifice now and live significantly below your means while you save for a few years.

Whats wrong with this? Its near Redmond and is $250k, 4 bedrooms, 3000 sq ft.http://www.redfin.com/WA/Gig-Harbor/.../home/39892316
Gig Harbor is about 2 hours from Redmond in traffic. There is a certain amount of sacrifice that is worth it and when you have kids, losing 4 hours a day with them is not. I get your point though, as a parent I sacrifice a lot for my kids but there is always room to save a bit more.
 

Picasso3

Silver Baronet of the Realm
11,333
5,322
Surely we have a cache of the old thread from foh?

Oh i found it:

Cad: "Live to money, not money to live"
Cutlery: "FUCKIN BUY A TRAILER, GET A BOX, GET WHATEVER YOU CAN PAY OFF GET THE FUCK OUT YOU WANNA BE 90 AND EATING CAT FOOD IN YOUR MANSION OR CAVIAR IN YOUR 1200 SQUARE FT RANCH CORNER OF HELL YOU'VE SPENT 50 YEARS IN AND NEVER IMPROVED BECAUSE YOU THREW EVERY FUCKING WAKING PENNY AT A PREPAYMENT"

If you want a house, get a house. If you think you might move within 2 years, dont. I can't for the life of me understand these wizkids advocating sitting on your ass saving up 20% when you can get a mortage for 3% down at 3%. What's the big deal?

I also think everyone overstates the amount of stuff that fucks up and the severity of it. Get a $200 cordless kit, screwdriver set, and a hammer and when something breaks, google it (dont bother with the ehow article), then go to lowes and get whatever you need and do it. Or if you're a helpless gay ask the old people at work if they have any trusted handymen.
 

Nester

Vyemm Raider
4,938
3,141
1) if you dont have the down payment you straight up can not afford it. Rent for another year, save what you can for a down payment.
2) DO NOT BUY MORTGAGE INSURANCE. Buy life insurance instead. often life insurance is less expensive for more coverage.
- life insurance is underwritten up front, therefore less likely to get CLAIM DENIED
- Mortgage insurance is underwritten after you die, oh you smoked? sorry claim denied.
- life insurance pays your family (or whomever you want) the amount on your policy.
- Mortgage insurance pays the bank on the balance of your loan. You had $200k in coverage but you paid $150k off your mortgage. now your policy is only $50k but your premium stays the same.
- Mortgage insurance is one size fits all, young fit and healthy? too bad, pay the same amount as chain smoking, skydiving granny.


It makes sense when you with your lender to want to insure your mortgage but go talk to an insurance broker, its free until they convince you to buy =-D
 

Cad

scientia potentia est
<Bronze Donator>
24,575
45,665
Gig Harbor is about 2 hours from Redmond in traffic. There is a certain amount of sacrifice that is worth it and when you have kids, losing 4 hours a day with them is not. I get your point though, as a parent I sacrifice a lot for my kids but there is always room to save a bit more.
Haha shit I wasn't watching the window and didn't realize it went to the other side of the bay on that one. Does look pretty expensive around that area. The choices would be move farther out (ok 2 hours is extreme though) or get a job elsewhere, work from home more or live in a little more ghettofied area so you can afford more house.

Another thing you might do is get an au pair and go back to work, can be significant upside financially to that. The sacrifice there is you don't stay home and raise your kids.
 

Falstaff

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
8,313
3,169
Surely we have a cache of the old thread from foh?

Oh i found it:

Cad: "Live to money, not money to live"
Cutlery: "FUCKIN BUY A TRAILER, GET A BOX, GET WHATEVER YOU CAN PAY OFF GET THE FUCK OUT YOU WANNA BE 90 AND EATING CAT FOOD IN YOUR MANSION OR CAVIAR IN YOUR 1200 SQUARE FT RANCH CORNER OF HELL YOU'VE SPENT 50 YEARS IN AND NEVER IMPROVED BECAUSE YOU THREW EVERY FUCKING WAKING PENNY AT A PREPAYMENT"

If you want a house, get a house. If you think you might move within 2 years, dont. I can't for the life of me understand these wizkids advocating sitting on your ass saving up 20% when you can get a mortage for 3% down at 3%. What's the big deal?

I also think everyone overstates the amount of stuff that fucks up and the severity of it. Get a $200 cordless kit, screwdriver set, and a hammer and when something breaks, google it (dont bother with the ehow article), then go to lowes and get whatever you need and do it. Or if you're a helpless gay ask the old people at work if they have any trusted handymen.
I thought some of these posts looked familiar