Rings of Power: Tolkien's Shambling Skinsuit

sakkath

Blackwing Lair Raider
2,053
1,450
When you have as much money as Bezos you can waste it on all kinds of useless shit. A few hundred mill is couch change. Washington Post is costing him ~$100mil/year although that he can use to shape policy and public opinion. Tolkien's Shambling Skinsuit is just a vanity project.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

jayrebb

Ssraeszha Raider
16,850
16,634
Which is likely why no due diligence went into any of the rights he was purchasing-- having Amazon pay twice to retell the same story they had been telling, with just a few extra names and a little more detail.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Daidraco

<Gold Donor>
11,377
12,335

Honestly - I just dont care that the show exists. How many LOTR's type shows and games have been absolutely fucking garbage over the decades? What I'm more upset about is that the amount of money that is being spent on this abomination of tolkien's universe. Of alllllll the things that could have been done with that money and we get.. this. Thats the real heartbreak in my opinion. At 58-60 Million an episode, and we're on SEASON 3?... All the things that we could have in its place. Just fucking sad.
 
  • 4Like
Reactions: 3 users

rectifryer

Tranny Chaser
415
911
I'm sorry but "the rings of power" will always be a sonic power up. This show is a farce; they have played us all for fools.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Runnen

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
2,548
6,259
This wasn't on my S3 bingo card. Sauron vs Durin's Bane.

tlotrrop-vcms-1785093487479.jpg
 
  • 1Seriously?
  • 1Pathetic
Reactions: 1 users

Animosity

Silver Baronet of the Realm
8,484
7,481
"This show has been so abysmal we are going to remove every terrible storyline we made up and just focus on memberberries from now on"
 
  • 2Like
Reactions: 1 users

jayrebb

Ssraeszha Raider
16,850
16,634
The showrunners have made the rounds telling people that they can just watch Season 3 without any other seasons.

So sounds about right.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions: 2 users

Fogel

Mr. Poopybutthole
17,276
74,364
Their kids look like dwarves that are hippy stoners blazing 420 in the mines of moria

 
  • 4Worf
  • 2WTF
  • 2Barf
Reactions: 7 users

spronk

FPS noob
25,256
32,145


those stupid hobbits are apparently gone from the show. I mean the trailer looks good, but you know it'll have stupid shit everywhere

i wonder if they still are forced to do 2 more seasons or if they are just gonna give up
 
  • 2Like
Reactions: 1 users

moonarchia

The Scientific Shitlord
<Bronze Donator>
33,156
65,383
think we quit this show mid S1, nothing was happening and the DEI was through the roof.
Never have and never will watch this unholy travesty. Bezos has a fetish for turning billions of dollars into dozens of dollars making DEI horse shit.
 
  • 3Solidarity
  • 2Like
Reactions: 4 users

Runnen

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
2,548
6,259
Watched the first 4 available episodes of season 3, and so far it's pretty good. There's a TL,DR at the bottom if you don't care to read the following essay.

While I understand not everyone is going to like watching what feels like a very expensive fan fiction, I don't really understand why this show gets so much more hate than say, the Hobbit trilogy. Both are adaptations that tried to streeeeeeetch very small footnotes and appendix mentions into hours and hours of content at the expense of being faithful to Tolkien's vision.

When I watched season 1 of Rings of Power, I felt it was meandering a lot, and indeed there wasn't much going on. And yes, DEI for DEI's sake was a stupid decision when it comes to Middle-Earth stuff. While I realize it looks "problematic" to some crowds these days that basically anyone non-white in Tolkien's work is probably evil (Harad, Rhûn, Umbar..), there was a way to have non-white humans without also having black elves, black dwarves and black harfoots. There was WAAAAY too much harfoot content in season 1 and it really brought the overall epic feeling down. The upsides were seeing Valinor for the first time, though it was a brief moment, and even the shadow of Ungoliant was nice to visualize.

Season 2 really picked up the pace I felt, and was dedicated to the forging of the Rings, and I thought the interactions between Annatar/Sauron and Celebrimbor worked really well. The new character of Adar also became more interesting, and I thought it was pretty cool to see one of the original Elves-turned-Orcs and how different they are to what ultimately became degenerate goblins in later Ages. Much less Harfoot content in this season, and that was good. I understand they wanted to establish why Gandalf would have an affinity and appreciation for the little folk later, but that could have been accomplished without wasting as much time with them (and there were even MORE black harfoots this time).

Season 3 now, half way in since it's 8 episodes, there's no harfoots at all. Numenor still looks pretty great and events are in motion to shape its ultimate downfall, I'm liking being able to see that on screen. The show also goes into what happened to the two Blue Istari that were sent with Gandalf, Saruman and Radaghast, and that's cool too. There's links to the Hobbit movies by developping Gundabad even more, going into things that were done in Morgoth's time. There's even some backstory to the fell beasts and I liked that. Khazad-dum is simply beautiful, and I really like how much time is spent there on the dwarves (which, for the very most part, look great, the nose prosthetics and beards/hair are very well done). The only problem is how stupid the two afro-dwarf kids look, but DEI's gonna DEI. At least they're largely side characters. The season spends time developping, more or less, the characters that'll become the Nazgûl down the line, and already has several become Nazgnagôl. This word, invented by the show, translates to "Servant of the Ring" in Black Speech, and is meant to bridge the characters between the kings they were, and the Ring-Wraiths (Nazgûl) they'd become in death later.

Overall, I'd say this show definitely takes huge liberties when it comes to Tolkien's writings (I've read the Hobbit, the Lord of the Rings, the Silmarilion, the Sons of Hürin, the full History of Middle-Earth tomes and the Unfinished Tales) unless there's things I missed in some odd letters or correspondance, as Tolkien's works kept changing and evolving at his whim even late in his life. It sometimes makes a decision where Tolkien hesitated even to the end, but for an adaptation I wouldn't say it's a bad thing. I'm not a hater of things I watch most times, I'm not hard to please in general and that alone is probably a great flaw to some people, but I've been watching this as a visual representation of things I could only ever read about. I think it's nice to see those things on the screen, I think it's nice to hear more Howard Shore music when I'm looking at those things, and I think it's nice that some of the tiny footnotes or even brand new things that develop tiny footnotes are being done, so long as it's done respectfully and makes sense (which it does, so far). The show even managed to make Tom Bombadil a surprisingly interesting character.

I've seen the posts online that everything looks fake and cheap compared to the works done by Meta in the LOTR trilogy. I disagree, the show looks and feels expensive, the costumes are mostly great, the photography is often beautiful. People wave around a billion dollars budget like it's completely absurd, yet this was the budget for the entire planned five seasons, and when I've seen shows like the stupid ass Secret Invasion with Nick Fury and Daenerys costing 212 million bucks for 6 fucking episodes shot entirely in streets and warehouses, for an extremely mediocre end result, I don't really see the problem with Rings of Power's budgeting.

Some people will of course complain that the main character being Galadriel is a problem because she should be able to one-shot everything with a sharp glare, but that would hardly make for thrilling content. I feel she started a little too wide-eyed and naive for a 5000 year old Noldor elf in the first season, but across the seasons she's become, I feel, appropriately powerful.

TL,DR : show's pretty decent, season 3 is pretty good so far. If you couldn't stomach season 1 because of harfoots/hobbits, they're gone. If you hate everything about this show, don't pick it up at season 3, you'll still hate it. But it's an ADAPTATION, Dune changes a lot of things, Harry Potter changed a lot of things, Lord of the Rings changed a lot of things, it's gonna happen no matter what.
 
  • 2WTF
  • 1Like
  • 1GreNeg
Reactions: 5 users