Top 5 All Time Weapons

Penance

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
5,164
5,036
1. Shock Rifle from Unreal (how has this not made it on the list yet)
2. Rocket Launcher from Soldier Team Fortress Classic
3. Silenced M4 from CS 1.5
4. Portal Gun from Portal (probably wins in cool factor)
5. Gravity Gun from HL2
 

Urgoslav

Treasured Member
470
506
Lightsaber - Just satisfying to use in games
Masamune (Chrono Trigger/Cross)
South Park Alien Mind Control Gun - I like to singa
FatMan Fallout3
CounterStrike Dualies
 

Mist

Eeyore Enthusiast
<Gold Donor>
30,480
22,329
Melee weapon: FUCKING SWORD ARMS from Deus Ex:HR. Pretty much every day of my life I wish I had those, generally when dealing with stupid people. Bayonetta's hair is a close second.
Close Quarters/Crowd Suppression: UT04 Flak Cannon (FLAK MONKEY!)
Rifle: Overwatch Pulse Rifle (HL2)
Utility: Portal Gun (I was going to say the red gun from Antichamber but you can put portals underneath people's feet so that really swings it in the portal gun's favor.)
WMD: Katamari
 

Thengel

Golden Knight of the Realm
673
32
Silenced PP7
Blades of Chaos
Mega Buster
Rail Gun
aaaaaaaaaaaand a red turtle shell
 

Antarius

Lord Nagafen Raider
1,828
15
1) lightsaber
2) chaingun from wolfenstein
3) Blackhawk full up with soldiers in Battlefield 2
4) gears of war chainsaw rifle (microsoft tried to convince epic to get rid of these)
5) any big ass mech from mechwarrior
 

Zaphid

Trakanon Raider
5,862
294
In no order...

1. Stormbringer (http://io9.com/stormbringer-end-of-discussion-651385681)
2. Uther Doul's Possible Sword (from The Scar , and a mention in Dungeons of Dredmorhttp://www.dredmorwiki.com/wiki/Doul's_Possible_Sword)
3. The rocket launcher from Quake
4. The Porkolator from Hexen
5. The magic clarinet from Mitchell and Webb (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7aaw4g2tJo)
Oh how did I forget that. Mi?ville creates the craziest things in his books. Does Iron council count ? Or the Time golem. Or the fire that burns time.
 

Void

Experiencer
<Gold Donor>
9,460
11,150
I'm not going to list 5, because most of them have already been listed, but I can't believe no one mentioned this one:
 

Drajakur

Molten Core Raider
562
452
In no real order, but

1. Greenmist
2. Q3A railgun
3. BFG
4. Fallout3 minigun + perk
5. The Daikatana!!!!! (jk)
 

Cybsled

Avatar of War Slayer
16,532
12,037
1) Lightsaber
2) Farsight gun from Perfect Dark (sniper rifle that can see through walls, lock onto targets, and can then shoot the targets THROUGH the wall and pretty much one-shot them)
3) Shrink gun from Duke Nukem 3d
4) The Nuke gun from Shadow Warrior...probably the most wtf overpowered BFG-style weapon ever and literally nukes most of the map (and you) if you aren't somewhere safe
5) Gravity Gun from HL2
 

Mist

Eeyore Enthusiast
<Gold Donor>
30,480
22,329
Green Lantern power rings have to be banned from all of these kinds of threads.