Wheel of Time
- Thread starter hodj
- Start date
Sterling
El Presidente
- 12,958
- 7,855
Sure, then they'd just need new writers, directors, and actors.
- 5
- 3
Brahma
Obi-Bro Kenobi-X
- 11,936
- 42,139
Ravishing
Uninspiring Title
- 8,452
- 3,577
I was disappointed after ep1, had some hope through the middle eps, then the last 2 episodes left me severely disappointed. Overall i rate it about a C.
Imo the end felt too rushed. I thought the first book was going to be 2 seasons.. maybe that was people before amazon,idk.
They made a lot of terrible changes and the end suffered a lot.
Imo the end felt too rushed. I thought the first book was going to be 2 seasons.. maybe that was people before amazon,idk.
They made a lot of terrible changes and the end suffered a lot.
- 3,104
- 2,711
Its been decade+ since I read the books, don't even remember the last one I read (maybe 10 or 11) before i noped out of that drawn out cash grab shit show. Literally only books 1-5 were any good and I can barely remember most of the details, just a fuzzy outline of the first 5 books, but uh. Wasn't the whole point of book 1 about the green man? Something about an acorn getting planted ir a pool or something and some big ass tree or something?
Very traditional fantasy trope of adventurers going off to meet a wizard who educates them on shit and they learn the myths and folklore of their world are actually real. You know just setting up the setting and world building?
Other than most of the names being the same this had nothing in common with WOT, and it did fuck all with world building. People who havent read the books have no clue wtf is going on and people who have are just pissed about everything they changed.
Say what you want about sextaposition that GOT used to trick people into learning about the world during gratuitous sex scenes but at least it got people invested. Not that anyone would be interested in any sex scenes with this mongaloid cast.
Very traditional fantasy trope of adventurers going off to meet a wizard who educates them on shit and they learn the myths and folklore of their world are actually real. You know just setting up the setting and world building?
Other than most of the names being the same this had nothing in common with WOT, and it did fuck all with world building. People who havent read the books have no clue wtf is going on and people who have are just pissed about everything they changed.
Say what you want about sextaposition that GOT used to trick people into learning about the world during gratuitous sex scenes but at least it got people invested. Not that anyone would be interested in any sex scenes with this mongaloid cast.
- 1
Mudcrush Durtfeet
Hungry Ogre
- 2,428
- -758
It's possible to change things from source material and still end up with a good show that retains the spirit of the source (Preacher for instance).
This is not, unfortunately, the case here.
- 3
- 2
- 1
Caliane
Avatar of War Slayer
- 14,542
- 10,031
phisey gave you a downvote... while he LOVES Arcane. which did just that. invented new characters for the show. some of which are primary characters. completely changed others. Vi's amnesia is totally gone. what was a core part of her character, and conflict.
Falstaff
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 8,311
- 3,166
It's Mudcrush, so while I completely agree with him, you just want to garbage the guys posts.
- 2
- 2
- 1
- 11,962
- 29,131
I'm catching up on this thread, but fuck me. The only thing I could think while suffering through this show (a favor to the gf, who hasn't read the books) was:
Why couldn't the Wheel of Time IP been given to the Arcane/Riot folks? Arcane's animation was exactly where it needs to be to finally show enough emotion to get you invested in characters. Animation is now >>> live action for anything fantasy, IMO. Riot/Arcane style WoT would have blown this fagshow out of the water, assuming it could have had non-faggot writers.
- 2
- 1
Qhue
Trump's Staff
- 7,475
- 4,419
Fair point. However they spent soooo much money on costumes and sets and props and various accoutrements only to film it as if they were shooing a new season of Single Female Lawyer. In contrast the Witcher production costs are likely much much lower in terms of physical objects but they succeed because they are focused on what the camera sees rather than trying to create some sort of Tar Valon themepark.
- 2
- 11,962
- 29,131
It does a good job of reinforcing The Great Narrative. Thus, plenty of people like it because they belong to a fucking cult.
Hateyou
Not Great, Not Terrible
- 16,287
- 42,310
The problem is only one studio has shown they can do that so far. There are tons of stories that would be amazing in the arcane style but who is going to do them all? Are any other studios capable of turning out something that high quality?
There have been several good animated stories in the past few years but nothing like that. Castlevania, spiderverse, dota. All great in their own way and not even close to arcane level.
- 1
phisey
Buzzfeed Editor
- 1,917
- -4,658
The only guy whose veto could've saved this show is dead.
I can't imagine anyone with the stature and/or spine to step up and say no to Bezos' creatures who reshaped this story into something that would better appeal to the people they follow on social media. IE: people like them. IE: shitty garbage humans.
A good litmus test would be to ask Sanderson if he'd let Amazon adapt Mistborn or Stormlight Archive. You can hear his "Fuck NO" from the future.
I can't imagine anyone with the stature and/or spine to step up and say no to Bezos' creatures who reshaped this story into something that would better appeal to the people they follow on social media. IE: people like them. IE: shitty garbage humans.
A good litmus test would be to ask Sanderson if he'd let Amazon adapt Mistborn or Stormlight Archive. You can hear his "Fuck NO" from the future.
Last edited:
- 1
Zindan
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 6,624
- 4,411
Eh, no. I am almost 100% Sanderson is as woke as anyone running the WoT show, and he would be alright with most changes they suggested. He failed to stop the WoT showrunners from doing as much as they did, so yea... he would take the money and run.
- 1
- 1
Falstaff
Ahn'Qiraj Raider
- 8,311
- 3,166
No idea if Sanderson is woke or not because that term is retarded but he is on record in his AMA as saying there was only one or two things that he disagreed with that they changed from the books, so no. The only thing that could save his shit is that he's still alive and would/could ultimately have veto power over things.
There's like 16 or so. 14 for main story, 2 for pre-quels to ease you into the story (Strike at Shayol'Ghul and New Spring).
Even then it could be argued that AMOL (last book) was split into 3 volumes due to it's sheer size, which would cut down the entire series main books to "just" 12.
I think you overestimate how much influence a creative consultant has. If they tell him to fuck off, he has no option but to do so.
- 1
Hateyou
Not Great, Not Terrible
- 16,287
- 42,310
He’d have to have something in his contract about final creative say or you’re correct. Show runners that don’t give a shit can just pull a Wheel of Time on you and you can’t do shit, you took their money and signed away your rights.
Drinsic
privileged excrementlord
- 5,642
- 5,920