Windrose (PC Pirate Survival Game)

Kaines

Potato Supreme
19,611
56,140
Here is my top 5, with the understanding that i have not played Windrose or Subnautica yet. So either of those would likely crack the top 5 once I play them.
1 Valheim
2 Enshrouded
3 V Rising
4 Palworld
5 Dragonwilds
 
  • 2Like
Reactions: 1 users

Droigan

Blackwing Lair Raider
2,772
1,518
I'll check it out after I get done with Windrose. Thanks for the suggestion.

Abiotic Factor is a bit different though. It's like a survival game, but with a start and end, feels less like a sandbox than most survival games. Half Life 2 visuals and feel set in a Mesa Lab designed by FromSoft. Level design is amazing in it, shortcuts everywhere. Feature complete 1.0 as well. Highly recommended for anyone who likes survival games, especially if you have "fantasy" fatigue in terms of the genre.
 

Springbok

Karen
<Gold Donor>
10,268
16,072
This games starting 3 hours makes Crimson Deserts look like Elden Ring. That said, it is a ton of fun once you get a real ship. Combat is very meh, but it's a great concept and the ship stuff is a ton of fun. They will continune iterating this I'm sure and make it better for 1.0, but just the concept alone is enough to vault this near the top of survival games for me. Love the vibe, the ship stuff, the base building is intuitive and well thought out as well. Subnautica, V Rising, Grounded are probably my favorites and this is up there for sure. I like this more than Enshrouded, for example.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Seananigans

Honorary Shit-PhD
<Gold Donor>
15,763
40,057
This games starting 3 hours makes Crimson Deserts look like Elden Ring. That said, it is a ton of fun once you get a real ship. Combat is very meh, but it's a great concept and the ship stuff is a ton of fun. They will continune iterating this I'm sure and make it better for 1.0, but just the concept alone is enough to vault this near the top of survival games for me. Love the vibe, the ship stuff, the base building is intuitive and well thought out as well. Subnautica, V Rising, Grounded are probably my favorites and this is up there for sure. I like this more than Enshrouded, for example.

You playing solo or coop? The first stuff is pretty basic bitch but with the combat being actually dangerous, my friends and I are having a fucking blast being noobs.
 

Gavinmad

Mr. Poopybutthole
45,903
56,617
I've never played Subnautica because I'm not big into horror, and deep water already freaks me out enough. I do plan on trying the second one when it releases, though.
What the fuck.

A) The first blind playthrough of Subnautica is the best survival experience anyone will ever experience, EVER.

B) It's not a horror game. Yes you will probably get jump-scared at least once while playing (almost everyone does) but it's not a horror game.

C) The second one is going to be trash just like Below Zero was trash because Unknown Worlds is a trash studio and the brilliance of the original game was an accident

D) Play Subnautica
 
  • 1WTF
Reactions: 1 user

Serwol

Vyemm Raider
559
1,204
About 3 - 4 hours in and I am enjoying it despite some of its very rough edges
Its a nice combination of many survival crafters and also crafting stations pulling from chests right out of the box without the need for modding is a 10/10 move.
The combat needs a lot of work, I am finding my best method of attack for solo and groups is swing once, back step, run till full stamina, swing again....repeat.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Adebisi

Clump of Cells
28,490
21,522
Subnautica is a goddamn masterpiece. It is very much a survival game but different because it is so story driven (and single player only). It is one of the few games where I wish I could unlearn the plot so I could do another play through. The mechanics are good survival genre fair, paired with underwater survival stuff. But my god, go in blind, the story is just fucking excellent. Usually with these games, I would recommend looking up interactive maps for resource deposits and such, but not for Subnautica. Don't play Below Zero, it is ass in comparison. Resource collection and base building is the exact same, but the story is trash, and story is the reason you play the game. I have no idea what the new one will turn out to be with all of the behind the scenes drama going on.

I have so many of these games on my wishlist at the moment, so I don't have to wait for content to be added slowly. I do own Enshrouded, Palworld, Valheim and StarRupture, so I am trying to only get finished games at this point. I have Dragonwilds, Windrose, Grounded 2, the Last Caretaker and Dune Awakening on the wishlist at the moment.

If I were to make a Top 5, it would probably go:
1. Grounded
2. Subnautica
3. V-Rising
4. Abiotic Factor
5. Enshrouded
Valheim your ass already
 

Tarrant

<Prior Amod>
16,873
11,167
What the fuck.

A) The first blind playthrough of Subnautica is the best survival experience anyone will ever experience, EVER.

B) It's not a horror game. Yes you will probably get jump-scared at least once while playing (almost everyone does) but it's not a horror game.

C) The second one is going to be trash just like Below Zero was trash because Unknown Worlds is a trash studio and the brilliance of the original game was an accident

D) Play Subnautica

I genuinely do not enjoy jump scares, and the water aspect makes me uncomfortable...I know that sounds dumb, I'm fully aware of it, but it's just hard for me to want to get into, especially solo.

I'll play it someday, though I'm sure, the second one for sure.
 
  • 1Solidarity
Reactions: 1 user

Tarrant

<Prior Amod>
16,873
11,167
About 3 - 4 hours in and I am enjoying it despite some of its very rough edges
Its a nice combination of many survival crafters and also crafting stations pulling from chests right out of the box without the need for modding is a 10/10 move.
The combat needs a lot of work, I am finding my best method of attack for solo and groups is swing once, back step, run till full stamina, swing again....repeat.


Rapier of 1000 Cuts is your friend if this is the method you use.
 

Gavinmad

Mr. Poopybutthole
45,903
56,617
I genuinely do not enjoy jump scares, and the water aspect makes me uncomfortable...I know that sounds dumb, I'm fully aware of it, but it's just hard for me to want to get into, especially solo.

I'll play it someday, though I'm sure, the second one for sure.
The game does not set you up to be jump scared, it's just a thing that will inevitably happen sooner or later by chance. As for the water, it's really only an issue for most people in the very early game. It doesn't take long before it feels about the same a game set in a vacuum which I'm guessing you can play with no issue.

Pretty sure you keep mentioning the second one just to be a smartass though.
 

Tarrant

<Prior Amod>
16,873
11,167
The game does not set you up to be jump scared, it's just a thing that will inevitably happen sooner or later by chance. As for the water, it's really only an issue for most people in the very early game. It doesn't take long before it feels about the same a game set in a vacuum which I'm guessing you can play with no issue.

Pretty sure you keep mentioning the second one just to be a smartass though.

no, I had planned to play it when it comes out. No smart ass intended.
 

cyrusreij

Trakanon Raider
1,757
726
Valheim your ass already
I played it on release. I tried going back after they added Ashlands and... it is no longer enjoyable to me? I think the genre passed Valheim by over the years they have been dragging this out. Game seems a bit too clunky and grindy for me nowadays in comparison to some of the other games I have listed.
 

Kirun

Buzzfeed Editor
21,535
18,774
About 3 - 4 hours in and I am enjoying it despite some of its very rough edges
Its a nice combination of many survival crafters and also crafting stations pulling from chests right out of the box without the need for modding is a 10/10 move.
The combat needs a lot of work, I am finding my best method of attack for solo and groups is swing once, back step, run till full stamina, swing again....repeat.
Look at this non-parrying swine!

Jousting is certainly one method, but the combat is setup to take advantage of dodges and parry. The talent tree has specific talents just for buffing those things. The game absolutely requires moments of "backing off" or "back peddling" around mobs, but that's not really much different than how Souls games do things.

The first boss was a real fucker until learning his moveset and actually using the right food buffs.
 
  • 1Truth!
Reactions: 1 user

Adebisi

Clump of Cells
28,490
21,522
I played it on release. I tried going back after they added Ashlands and... it is no longer enjoyable to me? I think the genre passed Valheim by over the years they have been dragging this out. Game seems a bit too clunky and grindy for me nowadays in comparison to some of the other games I have listed.
Well now I feel like the one out of the loop

What's the closest to valheim progression feel.
 

Breakdown

Gunnar Durden
6,299
9,232
I got my ship tonight , went to tortuga, and really got into it.

This is great. Love the systems so far.

But yeah, combat is a mess. im playing solo offline. parry is great until you get to a camp of 7 pirates that all aggro you.

the root joust thing is real, works, I use it but for dorks like me who solo i can just overwhelm.

I love the ship combat. Legit. Crafting is great. IF you have a crew I imagine this is amazing. Even solo im 7 hours in and love it.
 

Vorph

Silver Baronet of the Realm
11,996
5,822
Anyone gotten into the later biomes? I heard it becomes a mess at that point. Enemies like wolves attack so quickly you can't do the 'run in, swing twice, dash out' thing anymore and you end up having to rely on your gun to have any chance. From what people were saying the devs adjusted the stuff that was in the demo based on feedback (like how shitty boar charge used to be), but anything past that point is just completely unbalanced.