Well, they're both still playing. If Manning wins multiple Super Bowls with 2 teams I think it might change the conversation somewhat since no QB has ever done it (I'm talking about starters here, don't pull out some 3rd stringer who happened to be holding a clipboard in the right places at the right time), if I recall. Maybe not, he might never pass Brady's 3 total.
Last night's game proved that Manning is still capable of going to shit in open air stadiums when it's cold and windy, but the New England comeback was definitely out of his hands. I'm sure he would also fail to adequately cover Gronk...but to my knowledge he has never lined up on defense. If this question does ever have an answer it'll probably come when they're both done playing.
