Picasso3 vs Lanx -If picasso was around more this year, I feel he'd have a much stronger case, but as it is, Lanx wins this by a mile. Those of you questioning why he's here don't see enough lanx posts.
Tyen vs. Cybsled -Cybsled is a somewhat bad poster, but it takes more than 'somewhat bad' to out-asshat Tyen.
Lendarios vs. Xequecal -This is the hardest matchup so far. Lendarios is one of the saltiest people I've had to deal with in the last year, and has far more reported behavior than Xeq. That said, he DOES have occasional flashes of good humor where Xeq just... doesn't. He's always just a joyless shareblue repeater bot. There is a certain joie de vivre inherent to the troll that manifests in Lend that doesn't in Xeq, so I have to give the nod to Xeq for sustained humorless asshattery over the occasionally more intense asshattery that is Lend.
Punko vs. Ossoi -I feel these two are pretty even on the severity of their asshattery, so I'm going to have to go with volume. I see far more posts in the asshat category from Punko than Ossoi while cruising the forums, so Ossoi will have to step up his game if he wants to beat out the real heavyweight asshats out there.
This was a great round. Next round looks to be less of a contest, leading up to a tough finale.