So I've been playing the first on since I got in on Steam sale, and HOLY SHIT! This game is everything a game like this should be. The combat is like darksiders/GoW, but I feel its more fluid and tactical. Combat decisions should not be made lightly. So far I've found a few different combos that suit each need, but I wouldn't say it's ultimately varied. I did just start though and could be wrong. Some combos seem like nub traps (chain saw one), while others are absolutely god like (the hold[STRATK]STRATK....) seems the go to on bosses, unless they hit with a ground slam then you do that attack in the air. The light side, shadow side powers are fucking awesome and bring another decision element into the battles. Do I go light side for more defense, or dark side for more offense. Luckily you don't share resources for those.
The level design is beautiful and pretty top notch. So far in chapter 4 I'd give level design a 8/10, with backdrops a 10/10. I kind of wish for a more metroid like open world, ala darksiders. But there are downsides to that with backtracking. However, with the 100% and weapon upgrades your already backtracking as it is. Maybe it's better they did it the way they did with level selections and trials/collectibles ect; or else back tracking would have become way to tedious.
The story is pretty good so far. Nothing outstanding, but enough to keep you interested. 7 or 6.5 out of 10, but I'm not even 1/3rd through the game so that is a very inaccurate number. Nice little tid bits of lore through out the story that are well done. Bestiary entries and so forth. I like those things but IMO games need to gravitate to more of how Dark Souls gives lore. Very subtley. But it works for this game.
The platforming is done well and there are lots of off camera secret areas to explore in the levels. The camera is done kind of halfway isometric which works well for the game. However camera can fuck you as it always does in those types of settings.
The only complaint I have about this game is I feel cheated on some of my deaths. The hit boxes don't connect yet I will die. I never felt like that in Dark Souls. But oh well.
Overall I would highly reccomend to purchase this game while on sale.