Maybe it's just me, but I always enjoyed SoE games, the few that I played at least, which are EQ, EQ2, PS, little bit of Free Realms. My biggest complain was EQ2 ultra bloated hotbars, but nonetheless the game was fun and enjoyable.
Their art style has always been debatable, but on decent rigs even EQ2 wasn't that bad (bit plastic indeed), but certainly not anything to be called "good" either.
EQ Next, for what I've seen so far, looks really nice, but I love cartoons, so that's probably just me. The human female of the first video is something I'd like to play, the lion not much, but I'm not into furry races usually. Sketches for Iksars look amazing and varied enough.
I admit it, I want to play the damn agame asap. Sucks it's so far away still. I'll go crying over the dozen games from Steam I still have to play to kill some time, together with NWO, GW2, SWtoR and the always present WoW to cure my MMO itch while I wait.