Monsters and Memories (Project_N) - Old School Indie MMO

nunny

Golden Knight of the Realm
28
10
I don't see the game being super sustainable, at least not at the level that people will want it to be at. I watch a lot of people play and many of them are kinda resonating on a few issues. They don't have the urge to continue grinding hard since there's no real reason to do so, they don't see themselves playing the game long-term, and most of them wouldn't be having fun if they didn't have a static to do stuff with. It's a fun game to waste time and run around in, but I share a lot of those sentiments. I don't see myself playing this long-term. If I hit the content wall there's basically no way I'm waiting half a year for more content. I see most people dipping when they realize how much they have to grind camps to level later on. The hell levels and real exp grind hasn't been hit by 90% of the players, and the majority of them don't know what's in store. When the requirement to grind long hours meets with the lack of a point in continuing and wildcards like WoW Forever get thrown into the mix, I think the game will be taking more of a hit than people want to admit.

It surprised me that the peak for Monsters & Memories seems to be the same as it was for Pantheon, but apparently Pantheon took longer to reach that concurrent. Also, Pantheon apparently sold around an estimated 120K copies according to the info I could find. Imagine if M&M had 120K subs, no one would be worried about its future. I watched Pantheon and it maintained ~6K for quite a while, but then it took a nose dive when people hit the content wall. WoW Forever is coming at the perfect time to take the wind out of the sails. I also don't see people returning if they decide to leave for something else. I use my past experiences with sub based mmos for this prediction. Lost time, lack of new content and a sub fee to see if you even want to log in and play for more than an hour can be a pretty big barrier.

That's a long winded way of saying I'm a bit worried for them since I like the game. It needed another year in the oven though, and that's an actual fact.

(Also ranger is fun)
 

Kithani

Vyemm Raider
2,710
3,856
435 pages into this thread and I don’t know if I ever had “Rangers OP in this classic EQ remake, had to get nerfed” on my bingo card

edit: Hatorade Hatorade the patch notes I see mention that snare nerf might be in PvP only?

Also lol

“
Good morning, all.

An exploit was recently discovered and we have actioned on all the accounts involved as well as removing the goods that were produced by the exploit.

If you find something in game that is broken, please report it and do not use it THREE HUNDRED AND FORTY ONE times. Or at all.

We take cheating seriously and have a zero tolerance policy for it.

Thank you all for playing.”

Any of you sweatlords wanna share the details?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: 1 user

Noodleface

A Mod Real Quick
40,355
20,333
435 pages into this thread and I don’t know if I ever had “Rangers OP in this classic EQ remake, had to get nerfed” on my bingo card

edit: Hatorade Hatorade the patch notes I see mention that snare nerf might be in PvP only?

Also lol

“
Good morning, all.

An exploit was recently discovered and we have actioned on all the accounts involved as well as removing the goods that were produced by the exploit.

If you find something in game that is broken, please report it and do not use it THREE HUNDRED AND FORTY ONE times. Or at all.

We take cheating seriously and have a zero tolerance policy for it.

Thank you all for playing.”

Any of you sweatlords wanna share the details?
Sorry you aren't in the secret discord bro
 
  • 1Rustled
Reactions: 1 user

Siliconemelons

Ssraeszha Raider
15,717
25,358
I dont know if I just hit the spell cheaper roulette

but, this morning I traveled to UD to see if FD was cheaper

In AV it was 40s, in UD it was 6...

Wood axe in AV is 90c, it was 26c in UD


...

I think I am seeking a bind in UD...
 

GuardianX

Perpetually Pessimistic
<Bronze Donator>
8,296
21,517
I dont know if I just hit the spell cheaper roulette

but, this morning I traveled to UD to see if FD was cheaper

In AV it was 40s, in UD it was 6...

Wood axe in AV is 90c, it was 26c in UD


...

I think I am seeking a bind in UD...

AV has a lot of prices tied to completing your "house" quest. and I bet a bunch of bugs related to it too.
 

Hekotat

FoH nuclear response team
13,561
14,160
I dont know if I just hit the spell cheaper roulette

but, this morning I traveled to UD to see if FD was cheaper

In AV it was 40s, in UD it was 6...

Wood axe in AV is 90c, it was 26c in UD


...

I think I am seeking a bind in UD...

Who did you try to buy the axe from? On the shady vendors its very high. There are q few npcs that have it in UD for cheaper, or you can pay ludicrous prices from the shady vendors. Don't buy from shady vendors, they underpay and overcharge for convenience.

Maybe av doesn't have a lumberjack vendor or garrison vendor?
 

Noodleface

A Mod Real Quick
40,355
20,333
Noodleface Noodleface God damn scared me when I logged in. Read the MOTD and though if we downloaded your map we might get banned from the game lol.
There's no risk. If you're really worried you can click off the tail player.log. I do suggest if you compile the maps you do it when the games not running. I improved performance by like 50% last night too haha.

Experimented with using their lighting system to make maps look more legit.

6279.png
 
  • 6Like
  • 3Mother of God
Reactions: 8 users

Pasteton

Vyemm Raider
3,431
2,628
I get that people are gonna do this shit but , and no offense to noodleface (not sure why but I feel like I’ve seen your dick on here at some point or am I thinking of someone else) but I highly recommend against using these things. A big part of the fun of this game is exploring places you haven’t been before. I remember my first time going into blacktide bay and thinking whoah when does this zone end, and was a blast finally finding the boat area. But with this map you’ll just be like oh , that’s cool, big zone and a big part of the fun is gone.

personally I think you guys should treat it like a movie or good tv show and avoid spoilers
 
  • 1Solidarity
Reactions: 1 user

Flobee

Ahn'Qiraj Raider
3,471
4,139
That screenshot is not really the "gotcha" you think it is. I've never argued that there is no audience for an old-school MMO. Obviously there is. 6,140 concurrent players is a perfectly respectable number, and I'd be thrilled if MnM eventually sustained that kind of population. My point has always been about scale and sustainability, not whether there are people who want this type of game. There are clearly people who do.

And this screenshot doesn't tell us what you seem to think it tells us. 25,019 active subscriptions isn't 25,019 players, and 6,140 concurrent users isn't 6,140 unique people who have demonstrated that they want a near 1:1 recreation of 1999 EverQuest's design philosophy indefinitely.

If anything, this supports my argument that there is a niche audience for this kind of MMO. I've never disputed that. The question is whether that audience is large enough to support the design at the scale people seem to be imagining, and whether all of the friction from 1999 actually contributes to the experience or whether some of it is simply tolerated because people love EQ.

If your argument is simply "See, thousands of people want an old-school MMO," then sure. I agree. That's never been the argument I'm making. But hey, good for them. That should be a nice influx of cash. Let's see how it looks in Dec. and how well they sustain it after GTA VI and WoW: Forever have released, people have botting tools rocking and rolling, camps are monopolized, etc. Every MMO looks like this after week 1.
Goalposts Moving GIF


I do however agree that the number that really matters in subs is 6-12 months or so. If they even maintain 1/4 I expect to be slaying Ashira with you and Kaines Kaines sir
 
  • 1Worf
Reactions: 1 user

huan

Trakanon Raider
19
3
I get that people are gonna do this shit but , and no offense to noodleface (not sure why but I feel like I’ve seen your dick on here at some point or am I thinking of someone else) but I highly recommend against using these things. A big part of the fun of this game is exploring places you haven’t been before. I remember my first time going into blacktide bay and thinking whoah when does this zone end, and was a blast finally finding the boat area. But with this map you’ll just be like oh , that’s cool, big zone and a big part of the fun is gone.

personally I think you guys should treat it like a movie or good tv show and avoid spoilers
Mostly agree with this sentiment, but there was some stuff I could only experience in EQ with the assistance of something like SEQ. Monk 1.0 was among the biggest bullshit and it took more than 40 hours straight of camping Raster. Without something like SEQ and having an audible alert on placeholders I would've gone completely mad. I also had a lot more free time in those college days. Not a freaking chance I could repeat anything like that today. There's a difference between being blown away by the massiveness of a zone and spending an hour trying to figure out where to sell beetle eyes (nerfed btw).
 

Noodleface

A Mod Real Quick
40,355
20,333
I get that people are gonna do this shit but , and no offense to noodleface (not sure why but I feel like I’ve seen your dick on here at some point or am I thinking of someone else) but I highly recommend against using these things. A big part of the fun of this game is exploring places you haven’t been before. I remember my first time going into blacktide bay and thinking whoah when does this zone end, and was a blast finally finding the boat area. But with this map you’ll just be like oh , that’s cool, big zone and a big part of the fun is gone.

personally I think you guys should treat it like a movie or good tv show and avoid spoilers
Hey why we bringing dongs into this

No offense taken. Just a tool I wanted and felt like putting it out there. If you don't want to experience the game like that I agree don't use it.
 
  • 1Worf
Reactions: 1 user

Blitz

<Bronze Donator>
6,309
7,063
I haven't touched the game in over a year: what classes are good, and/or fun?

(No, of course I didn't read any of the last 40 pages of this thread)
 

Kithani

Vyemm Raider
2,710
3,856
I get that people are gonna do this shit but , and no offense to noodleface (not sure why but I feel like I’ve seen your dick on here at some point or am I thinking of someone else) but I highly recommend against using these things. A big part of the fun of this game is exploring places you haven’t been before. I remember my first time going into blacktide bay and thinking whoah when does this zone end, and was a blast finally finding the boat area. But with this map you’ll just be like oh , that’s cool, big zone and a big part of the fun is gone.

personally I think you guys should treat it like a movie or good tv show and avoid spoilers
Aren’t you in the top secret Discord infos guild? Don’t want others to have access to your top secrets?
 

Pasteton

Vyemm Raider
3,431
2,628
Nothings been a secret since alpha really lol. Anything I didn’t tell people was to not ruin the fun for them like I would drop hints like hey think about the mobs name what might that tell you about when it spawns etc, it was fun for people to figure that stuff out. There were no timers or anything like that being kept secret or if they are then it’s a secret from me too. There’s a lot of new stuff on this release that no one s figured out including anyone I know.
 

Noodleface

A Mod Real Quick
40,355
20,333
Nothings been a secret since alpha really lol. Anything I didn’t tell people was to not ruin the fun for them like I would drop hints like hey think about the mobs name what might that tell you about when it spawns etc, it was fun for people to figure that stuff out. There were no timers or anything like that being kept secret or if they are then it’s a secret from me too. There’s a lot of new stuff on this release that no one s figured out including anyone I know.
You're colluding with mnmatlas aren't you you fuckin scab
 
  • 2Worf
  • 1Mother of God
Reactions: 2 users

Grabbit Allworth

Confirmed J6 Insurrectionist
2,170
8,530
I bought an Enchanted Copper Chain Tunic for 22 Silver.

I have no idea if that's a good price, but for level 15, the stats are really good. Particularly given the fact that I was wearing a tattered cloth tunic heh.