Murderbot
- Thread starter Goatface
- Start date
Chanur
Shit Posting Professional
- 34,068
- 61,393
Lanx
<Prior Amod>
- 72,832
- 172,173
Chanur
Shit Posting Professional
- 34,068
- 61,393
Arden
Blackwing Lair Raider
- 2,999
- 2,275
Eh, maybe I'll watch ep2 then. Was pretty underwhelmed with ep1. Stale dialog, half-hearted acting, predictable plot points. Didn't really grab me at all tbh. These days I need to feel compelled to watch a second episode in a series and I definitely didn't feel compelled in this case.
I also didn't read the books, so no preconceptions
Lanx
<Prior Amod>
- 72,832
- 172,173
so i got the 1st book for my neice to read, cuz it's a woman writer and sci-fi? shes one of those "voracious" readers and is currently slogging thru dune, shes like 10
is the book too much for her? i know the tv series is too much, good lord throupling on the 2nd eps
is the book too much for her? i know the tv series is too much, good lord throupling on the 2nd eps
Void
BAU BAU
- 10,494
- 13,018
I hate woke shit, but I've read the books, and I'm not entirely disgusted by the woke shit in the show because it was kinda always there in the books, just not in your face. Also, them being space hippies is what makes it work with SecUnit, because if they were normal they wouldn't be so fucking retarded and need him to save them.
The throuple crap and all that shit would make me immediately turn off any other show, but somehow it is tolerable in this show because I know that's how it always was. Even if it wasn't gone over in detail in the books, you knew they were exactly like this, so seeing it on screen doesn't shock me. But I can see how non-readers would immediately be disgusted by it.
I will say that I don't remember hating the augmented guy (the only other white guy, of course) so much in the books, but maybe I'm forgetting since it was so long ago.
The throuple crap and all that shit would make me immediately turn off any other show, but somehow it is tolerable in this show because I know that's how it always was. Even if it wasn't gone over in detail in the books, you knew they were exactly like this, so seeing it on screen doesn't shock me. But I can see how non-readers would immediately be disgusted by it.
I will say that I don't remember hating the augmented guy (the only other white guy, of course) so much in the books, but maybe I'm forgetting since it was so long ago.
Intrinsic
Person of Whiteness
- 16,376
- 15,976
I like Dastmalchian so much though it is hard to hate him even when we're supposed to hate him.
Also, not sure if they'll even try to address it in the show but in the books it is just <future year> and there's barely any foundation for the history of Earth, space exploration, etc. There are small references to things, but it isn't something trying to solve how Humans go to this point in time and technology and politics. The setting is very interesting with the corporate vs. free stuff and all the factions mixed and mingled. There's really in-depth discussions about the requirements for these people to take the SecUnit, be bonded, how the finances flow between everyone and the politics of it all. It isn't like an Anne Leckie book or anything, enough detail to make it interesting and really goes into the financial motivations of the protagonists. Hopefully they dive more into that aspect of the story.
Also, not sure if they'll even try to address it in the show but in the books it is just <future year> and there's barely any foundation for the history of Earth, space exploration, etc. There are small references to things, but it isn't something trying to solve how Humans go to this point in time and technology and politics. The setting is very interesting with the corporate vs. free stuff and all the factions mixed and mingled. There's really in-depth discussions about the requirements for these people to take the SecUnit, be bonded, how the finances flow between everyone and the politics of it all. It isn't like an Anne Leckie book or anything, enough detail to make it interesting and really goes into the financial motivations of the protagonists. Hopefully they dive more into that aspect of the story.
- 245
- 211
Show is faithful to the books including being too short. Skarsgard is not as snarky as Free but he really nails the social awkwardness. The way they weave in the Rise and Fall of Sanctuary Moon is great!
Gravel
Mr. Poopybutthole
- 44,960
- 160,735
Agreed with too short. I feel like every time I'm like "did I quit this show?" Watch the next episode, it gets maybe kind of interesting, but not really super interesting. Next one rolls around and I'm not sure if I give a shit about the show or not.
On the plus side, they're short, so I'm not losing much if the show sucks.
On the plus side, they're short, so I'm not losing much if the show sucks.
Lanx
<Prior Amod>
- 72,832
- 172,173
- 3,941
- 7,436
I had all of them, then deleted them mid way through book 2. I can only read about anxiety and nervousness so much and then we got to the pronoun race and I was the fuck outta there. I'll still watch the show though.
Xarpolis
Life's a Dream
- 16,026
- 18,041
That new blonde chick is a bit creepy. The episode was really painting the picture that someone, pretending to be this team, was the reason the other team all died. I suspect that the writers want us to come to the conclusion that she actually caused it all. But whatever. I'm enjoying the show.
Chanur
Shit Posting Professional
- 34,068
- 61,393
I'm wondering if she was the one programming the boys to kill the crews. She mentioned having technical know how and has been interested in what they are doing.