steps to fixing all-star saturday:
a) no more gimmick shit (east vs west, dunk wheels, etc.)
b) remove shooting stars challenge, replace with a 3 on 3 mini-tournament of current players (maybe retired players too, but none of those fat shitty ones that they cart out for celeb and overseas games). format would be 8 teams and you play games on both end of the court simultaneously. so it'd be two sets of first round games, a set of second round games, then a championship game. i'd be willing to bet this is way more competitive and fun to watch than the first 3.5 quarters of an ASG.
c) skills challenge is alright as is, i'd probably just take it down to 4 guys and have them each run the challenge twice. take top two scores for a finals where best time wins. this is mostly just a filler event for extra ad money, it'll never really be very good unless they gimmick it up. if they wanted to replace this event entirely, then they could just expand the 3-on-3 tournament to 16 teams.
d) same format for 3 point challenge as 3 on 3- 8 guys invited, simultaneous runs and take top 4 scores from first round, top two from second, head-to-head final running at the same time. i think this was how it used to be but for some reason they changed it. the 3 rounds make it more of a test of skill/consistency/endurance for the finalists so that should result in better finals pairings and the head-to-head format of the final could give it more excitement/pressure if it comes down to the last rack.
e) dunk contest needs to ditch any real round shit. we have no idea what the four guys who didn't make the finals were "saving" as far as dunks go, so we're not seeing the best product put on the floor. i'd say a field of 6 guys and have them each do 4-5 dunks. only 3 attempts per dunk, each completed dunk is scored, and a non-completed dunk is scored 66% of max. drop the lowest 2-3, average the rest. top two averages go into a dunk off final, which is just three minutes of them taking turns dunking (with a shot clock per turn, maybe something like 15 seconds), then let the fans decide who won.
so it'd basically be the current pre-planned dunk format for the first "round", then layup line-esque final of awesomeness. you won't really see any dunk saving for the finals then because it's just going to be dudes throwing down eastbays and what not given the time constraints/competitiveness. for the final i also think only one ball should be used and the guys have to hand the ball off to each other after each turn, so it adds that little extra flair to the event and also makes the guys process that this is a real competition.
f) don't ever host it in houston again. shit town that inflated the prices so high that legitimate fans couldn't afford to show up (you can't charge $500 on average for tickets in a majority-hispanic city). the crowd reactions during the dunks last night were pitiful.
make it happen adam silver.