zzeris Ill give you credit, was a good try but your Alex Smith dig is misguided.
Jimmy G has a healthy YPA over his short career, and his INT to TD ratio is troubling, meaning he is willing to air it out and take chances.
Alex couldnt gain 16 yards through the air over an entire quarter sometimes, as he would be ultra conservative, leaving an uncountable number of big plays on the field. If the 49ers were down 10+ the game was OVER, every TIME. He couldnt convert on 3rd down, and would never take risks. Not only that but opposing defenses would zone in and just work 1/3rd of the field (nullify the middle of the field, 2 man press, safety over the top) and totally neutralize their offense, as they had NO fear of him throwing the ball over their head.
Garoppolo isnt that type of QB. These first two games have been disappointing, but he has an innate willingness to take chances and get some fucking air under the football.