Buy what you want but I really dislike using redbox because:Not when I can go to Redbox and grab a Blu-ray movie for $2 compared to $5.99 for an HD equivalent on Amazon, iTunes, or Comcast Pay per view. If I watch 60 movies a year, (Totally made up number) that's $200+ savings per year minimum. And that's not even watching 5 movies a month. Plus for those who like bonus content, I have not seen that at all in the streaming world. Plus we aren't getting loss-less audio with HD streams or DTS-HD MA. So those that want the full experience with a movie and have good movie theaters in their house, will not be happy with streamed content until that changes at a minimum.
Overall, the theater experience on Blu-Ray eats streaming alive.
1. Waiting in line
2. Navigating a small selection
3. Having to return stuff.
4. Having to use a physical medium.
As far as bluray quality vs the compressed quality I get from downloading stuff online I don't really care. I notice the difference but it just doesn't matter to me much.