Vanessa's Tranny AMA Blog Thread

Vanessa said:

You know my views on this. If watching countless hours of Dawkins, Hitchens, Harris and Dennett (the 4 horsemen) on evolutionary concepts and "facts" isn't enough to make me believe in it, I doubt our convo is either. I'm a Christian Conservative amigo. I think evolution is a pile of bullshit and Darwin is burning in hell to be blunt.

Click to expand...

*yawn*

Did I just wake up in Falwell's 80's?

Listening to 4-Horsemen conversations means you know, maybe, %5 of evolutionary theory? That's being generous. They take evolution as a given and thus do not feel the need to discuss it to any sort of real depth. The 4-Horsemen talk about Religion, Sociology, Politics, and Faith. They do not talk about evolution to any real deep degree (although a few of them do understand it to a deep degree).

Were you under the impression that that is what they were up to? 'Deep' conversations about evolution? Oh mylanta....

-----

On the topic of faith, I've pretty much lost all of mine in you. You struck me at first to be a free-thinker who might possibly posses a fearless intellect, but now I see that you are just as deeply ideological as, well, most humans that have ever been born. I don't go as far as hodj or wormie and label you as a bad or evil person, but I do consider you these days to be quite a boring one. Someday you might prove me wrong, but I will not be holding my breath. (Evolution has dictated that I need a very active molecule, like oxygen, in order to help provide chemical energy to my cells).

That being said: you do you, boo. Keep on trying to convince people that sex and gender are sciologically malleable rather than biologically fundamental. I'm sure God will cast a spell someday to make it real. Just pray harder.

Dom said:

I had a tv show (Doom Patrol) preach to me about how a metaphysical street (yes, a street) is non-binary and gender-queer and blah blah blah yesterday.

I have nothing more to add. That's it. I no longer even have the energy to properly gripe about this sort of shit anymore.

Click to expand...

Okay I have to ask, what is a metaphysical street?

Do you mean some sort of imagined utopian street that cannot exist, or do you mean any street that is metaphysical and not psychical?

I would like to know more....

Does Magic The Gathering have a spell, cast by God, that says:

"Instant:

All genders are a social construct"

I imagine it would definitely be a white spell.

Vanessa, I actually appreciate your existence.

When I study history, biology, sociology, and philosophy, I am not necessarily preoccupied with transgenderism as a phenomenon in and of itself. But you (and others) have sort of forced me to envelope and swallow it.

As I think about it, your position makes sense.

It sort of has to be the case that someone who thinks that transgenderism is 'real' or 'good' must also think that biology is 'bad'. Doesn't it?

Biology, the logic of the biome, is completely antithetical to several presuppositions about sociology and philosophy and religion. Transgenderism, being almost purely sociological and philosophical and religious, practically must reject the biological, mustn't it? We see this repeated in so many ways in the current climate of both academia and church.

So in order to remain logically consistent with ones-self, one in your position cannot accept biology as a thing.

------

You and I do not split on anything deeper than this I don't think. You've shown me some picture of a feminine male and my immediate thought is, "Yeah, he succeeds as a female in society, but has he delivered his male gametes to a female's gametes?"

Sociologically and Philosophically and even Politically, I have no problem with the existence of that blonde 'man-girl' thing that you posted that supposedly received 'hormone therapy' before it reached puberty. But Biologically speaking, that thing is a complete failure of an organism and has relinquished all methods of perpetuating its DNA.

In a biological sense, it is a failed organism.

----

As a liberal (lower case l) it is not my place to tell you that you cannot do what you want as an adult. But as a biologically minded person, I also happen to know that what you are doing is completely nonsensical in a biological sense and I must insist that you not press your nonsense onto children.

You will, if theoretically successful, completely destroy the human race as a thing. Organisms exist in order to mix gametes. The failure to mix gametes is the failure of the organism.

You can dislike this reality all you want but that would be, literally, pure neuroticism.

The psychotic says "2+2=5"
The neurotic says "2+2=4, but I just can't stand it."