RDR2, Deus Ex from your list. Both all time greats.
Not on your list, but I've done recent play throughs and believe they are also worthy of your time:
1. Baldurs Gate 1 / BG2 / Icewind Dale - Choose one and play through to see what the best in CRPGs was like. Planescape Torment is also an option (haven't played) if you want a lively story from what it sounds like.
2. Dark Souls 1 - Elden Ring and the others from the series are great, but worth seeing the original. Has a lot of jank which makes it more enjoyable than the more super polished later games.
3. Ocarina of Time - just finished my first play through recently and this was very good. I understand why its regarded as #1. Definitely don't use a walkthrough.
4. Chrono Trigger - I can't stand JRPG combat but Chrono Trigger does it extremely well for the first 80% of the game or so. The end gets to be a bit grindy / repetitive battles but the story, art, combat, characters, etc. all make sense why this is an all time great.
Your time here on Earth is limited. Use the wisdom of the crowd to choose the things worth playing. This doesn't apply when you're craving an experience and need to have it. But if you're choosing the best book off the shelf, stick to the greats.