At no point in Tebows career did I ever watch a big game of his and think "man, he just single-handedly took over that game and won it"
Great leader, great motivator that got the most out of his teammates, and a solid college QB, but pretty much at no point was he such a dominant athlete that he looked like a man playing with boys. Suh and Barry Sanders both gave that impression regularly, like they were playing a different game that everyone else on the field had no clue how to compete with them.
He was basically the same as Colin Klein at K-state this year. Not flashy, rarely did anything to make your jaw drop and make you question if you really saw what you just saw, but very consistently good and a winner. And theres nothing wrong with that, that's a very good college player that anyone would love to have on their team. It's just not a legendary, once in a generation freak of an athlete like Suh or Sanders.