Alex
Still a Music Elitist
- 14,792
- 7,566
I know it's an ugly choice. This is my 18-team league and these are the crucial bullshit decisions I have to make week-in, week-out.Ugh, that is all I can say about that choice. I would cruise the waiver wire first, but if those are really your two best options, I play McGahee in standard scoring, Cotchery in PPR.
Some guys I look at instead that are available in most ESPN leagues, Mike Tolbert, Brandon Jacobs or Austin Pettis (PPR). Not exactly enticing options either but I would play them before McGahee or Cotchery.
*edit Zac Stacy is another pick-up choice. I'm not expecting much out of him this week, but would be a much better option than McGahee moving forward.
Here's my current roster.

These are the top W/Rs available.

I'm #1 in the waiver wire so I suppose I could pick up Pettis. Might not be a bad idea.
Should I pick up Peyton Hillis from FA since he signed with the Giants?