Not gonna look it up, but there was a whole thing about Schilling trying to build a franchise and buying this game to rework into Amular IP to not only help with marketing/exposure, but to use sales to help fund the mmo and justify loan deals.
I don't remember if the game underperformed or Schilling over promised, maybe both, and it wasn't the only cause if anything, but I do vaguely remember the strange juxtaposition of the politician saying the game was basically a flop and proved the studio wouldn't ever meet their creative/production goals while the game was actually selling decently and getting decent reviews.
Remember it because then the opinion that Amular was vaporware was justified by saying the single player game was mostly made by a different studio, which of course was technically true while completely missing the point that the IP and studio were being called flops to justify what imo was a politically motivated move, while the game wasn't actually flopping.
There were design/creative issues, of course, like the trailer with the guy stabbing the skeleton. But it's still weird to me the game is getting remasters and dlcs and was sold and rated decently. Game managed to be exactly what Schilling was planning for it being, despite being cited as proof the studio/IP couldn't be a success and needed to be shut down.
In part, a fake news political hit job before it was commonplace. Imagine the outrage with Schilling and 38 even existing if they'd made it past that initial fiasco. In 100 alternate realities they probably get politically axed in 99 of them.